Question concerning Platinum & Giratina

[The_2nd_Existential_Seed]

We have an onlooker confirming in both endings [ Whether captured or KO ], that Lucas/Dawn did intact defeat Unsealeds Giratina. I am NOT saying Legend Scaling for ALL Gen's are good.. But... With this as a guide... If we were to make said profile for them ( I want to SO BAD... But this was the only thing stopping me. ) ... Would this make that generations legendary battle scalable, and a acception to the rule ? ( Sans E4 & Cynthia scaling... As we have no evidence they even put up a fight post-fighting Unsealed Giratina . ) . In Gen IV, it's pretty consistent ( for that Gen's MC ).... Especially if we count their Post-Game accomplishments. ( Later takes on Dialga, Palkia, and Arceus... FYI, it's the only official Post-Game that has you fight Arceus... Just putting that out there. ) .

 

[The_2nd_Existential_Seed]

That bump though . However.. Just to make it better... Maybe the keys " Pre-Reverse World" & "Post-Reverse World " will work. Even if Cynthia was correct " They were tested ", it was still technically a defeated via context of what both e people etching them fight implied. NO other legendary fight ever stated the trainer won, other than they gained their trust. As such, I personally believe this is an exception.

For every trainer before and after, this is an outlier. However, considering Platinum then can handle Arceus and the other strong s heck Pokémon afterwards Post-Game... And her Post-Game is only with the Unsealed Variations and Sealed Variations of the Creation Trio... Kinda hard to believe it's an outlier... Especially considering Platinum & other variations of said game were the only games you " legitimately" fought them.