One-Punch Man: Planet Discussion

[Chariot190]

Bro, you are arguing that Saitama got tossed into a coast, and the coast basically exploded, vanishing, with debris being launched thousands of meters, but because the crater isn't ten fucktillion meters deep (even though it's still deep and an absolute fuckton of mass got ejected), it must be support for some wacky hyperdurable planet? The hell do you want from that? For Saitama to get yeeted through the planet itself?

 

[ZillertheBucko]

Bro, you are arguing that Saitama got tossed into a coast, and the coast basically exploded, vanishing, with debris being launched thousands of meters, but because the crater isn't ten fucktillion meters deep (even though it's still deep and an absolute fuckton of mass got ejected), it must be support for some wacky hyperdurable planet? The hell do you want from that? For Saitama to get yeeted through the planet itself?

I mean

maybe just a bit more like this
but there was no crater, the bit of rubble was mainly flat
if it at least showed him being visibly underground or standing in a crater, sure, but that shit was flat (as a pancake) despite tier 6 force that would be the equivalent of a needle striking it

also we're still not saying the planet has literal high durability at this point, just that it's protected by plot, so we can't discount things for not being destructive enough
cat's out of the bag at this point, so it's basically related to KE feats that get rejected because "not destructive enough"

 

[Kachon123]

Can we move on from that Garou example? It doesn't really have much to do with any relevant topic being brought up and it's cluttering up the thread.

 

[Chariot190]

but there was no crater, the bit of rubble was mainly flat

Literally an entire coastline was shattered, it's likely not a case of "oh it was flat", but rather it was so ******* big that it just looked flat when zoomed in. Even if it wasn't, so what? You wanna argue anything below a handful of meters on ground level is actually ultra durable material and that's why it didn't get destroyed?

if it at least showed him being visibly underground or standing in a crater, sure, but that shit was flat (as a pancake) despite tier 6 force that would be the equivalent of a needle striking it

He says, while ignoring a state basically got blown to bits.

also we're still not saying the planet has literal high durability at this point, just that it's protected by plot, so we can't discount things for not being destructive enough

So then it's just PIS? Which means absolutely ohing and shouldn't warrant any second thought? It's PIS, case by case, whatever.

cat's out of the bag at this point, so it's basically related to KE feats that get rejected because "not destructive enough"

They'd still show absolutely ludicrous destruction either way.

Can we move on from that Garou example? It doesn't really have much to do with any relevant topic being brought up and it's cluttering up the thread.

Never let Ziller cook for you brother.

 

[ZillertheBucko]

Never let Ziller cook for you brother.

hold up this thread was about to be rejected before I came in, I'm not about to take this slander

 

[Qawsedf234]

Never let Ziller cook for you brother.

It's true.

For the thread I'm with Chariot. This is a circular loop style of scaling and relies on AoE vs DC. Plus while the OP said this isn't for an upgrade, if accepted it will in fact immediately be used for an upgrade.

So I'm against it.

 

[ZillertheBucko]

For the thread I'm with Chariot. This is a circular loop style of scaling and relies on AoE vs DC. Plus while the OP said this isn't for an upgrade, if accepted it will in fact immediately be used for an upgrade.

It’s not really about that anymore, it’d be best to catch up with the more recent comments

 

[Kachon123]

Bumping this.

 

[Andytrenom]

I feel like you can say this about many verses that have had tier 6 stuff happen in it. Usually it's just an artistic liberty to portray these feats and not break the setting

 

[ZillertheBucko]

Those verses can do what they want, they don't have anything to do with this really
as for the matter at hand, all we need to discuss is the flaw with applying the KE restriction to the OPM feats.

 

[Qawsedf234]

4 Admins have rejected the thread and Armor has agreed with Chariot's points about not scaling the planer to be more durable.

The CRT is rejected.