- 24,975
- 26,822
I'm pretty unless it's an established to be a special move that's above their regular attacks, he shouldn't get the higher.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
One Punch Man General CRT
- Thread starter ImposingTiger
- Start date
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #42
Ok, nevermind then.
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #43
Do I need more approval to see if we can apply the agreed changes?
- 1,013
- 428
Yeah, try contacting a few more mods who are familiar with OPM.
- 22,337
- 18,523
- 20,529
- 17,434
It'll take me awhile to respond. But at the moment I definently disagree with some of the proposals here.
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #47
ok, i'll wait
- 20,529
- 17,434
The scaling here I don't agree with. Metal Knight's entire weapon fleet can damage City A, but the important bit is that there's no indication that they do so in one shot. You see various explosions on City A but nothing is damaged or cracked. An artillery bombardment does not need to be 7-B to destroy a city, just fire enough 9-A to 8-C weapons will do the job given enough time.
He did not knock out Bang. Dude got right back up and took off his shirt. Hitting someone and moving them =/= upscaling to them. Bang weighs less than 200 pounds, as long as you're strong enough not to have your arm shatter when hitting him you'll be able to move Bang.
A prime example is that Carnage Kabuto could ragdoll Saitama despite being unable to actually harm him.
Though the power increase with the fusion is probably something that can be noted.
Yeah I'm completely against this. This is like taking Doctor Doom's speeches at face value and running with it. Psykos is an egomaniacal psychopath who believes she's superior to everyone and everything. She's about as reliable as I would be in describing the political situation in Kazakhstan, i.e. totally unreliable.
It should not without evidence.
This has always been wrong and is never a justification. This should be entirely removed from his justification.
Against
Iffy on this.
Fine with
Against
Against
- 22,337
- 18,523
In this case, we might need to downgrade his arsenal.
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #50
One head Melzalgard is scaled to Pre Molt Ec via Bang, I just used it. And isn't there an OVA with SF and AS where it's implied he took damage from Melz's hit?
We have some members against it, you are the only one who agrees with it. Idk what to do.
Well, this has been more or less agreed in general, I guess we can apply it.
People have been neutral on Boros and Psykos, Tracer has agreed with them both. How do I decide if an opinion is more worthy than other one?
- 20,529
- 17,434
Only a few OVAs are considered canon to the manga.
I don't think he did anything more than what EC did. Both knocked them back and with EC Bang at least considered going 100% with using his breath technique.
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #53
Then why do you agree with Melz scaling to AB Bang?
- 20,529
- 17,434
I didn't. I agreed with the power multiplication of the fusion.
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #55
- 22,337
- 18,523
You see he's incapacitated at least for a couple seconds.
After he molted.
- 20,529
- 17,434
Being punched away isn't evidence that they scale to their AP. Like I mentioned Carnage Kabuto and other villains like Boros or Beefcake are able to move Saitama, that doesn't mean they scale to his power. PPP could grab his tentacles and hold them down, so I'm not seeing him significantly above any of the lower S-Class.
True.
- 22,337
- 18,523
He wasn't just punched away, he was down and out for a bit.
- 24,975
- 26,822
The OVA implied Bang took some form of damage, although nothing actually series. Which is why the individual Melzalgald is listed as At most 7-A
- 24,975
- 26,822
Also Iaian, the other sword disciples and TTM became MHS with no CRT. I'll revert that
- 20,529
- 17,434
He came back within the next page and didn't even really note that it damaged him. Sending someone flying away isn't a valid AP feat in my view.
- 22,337
- 18,523
It didn't really do any damage, but still had more effect than EC and didn't just send him flying. He was incapacitated for at least a bit as you can see by the previous panel.
In all honesty, at most 7-A is kind of bs. We should probably remove that part.
In all honesty, at most 7-A is kind of bs. We should probably remove that part.
- 15,411
- 15,766
EC actually hurt Bang (and Bomb) though, I wouldn’t say Melz had more of an effect.
- 24,975
- 26,822
He goes back to just "At least Low 7-B individually, higher when merged"
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #67
Ok, I'm going to try to conclude things. If anyone wants to give their input, they are on time.
Neutral:
Disagree: ByAsura (staff), Qawsefd234 (staff)
Neutral: Qawsefd234 (staff)
Disagree: Dual Binoculars (with Bang and Bomb)
idk what ByAsura (staff) thinks about this one.
Neutral:
Disagree: Emirp Sumitpo, Lord Tracer, ByAsura (staff), Dual Binoculars, Qawsefd234 (staff), Kachon123
Neutral: ByAsura (staff), Dual Binoculars
Disagree: Qawsedf234 (staff)
Neutral: ByAsura (staff), Dual Binoculars
Disagree: Qawsedf234 (staff)
idk what Emirp thinks after I brought up my last point.
That's it. What do we do here?
Agree: Dual Binoculars, Quangotjokes, LordTracer, Emirp Sumitpo, Imposing Tiger, Kachon123
Neutral:
Disagree: ByAsura (staff), Qawsefd234 (staff)
Agree: Dual Binoculars (with Rover), LordTracer, Emirp Sumitpo, Quangotjokes, Imposing Tiger, Kachon123
Neutral: Qawsefd234 (staff)
Disagree: Dual Binoculars (with Bang and Bomb)
idk what ByAsura (staff) thinks about this one.
Agree: ImposingTiger, Quangotjokes.
Neutral:
Disagree: Emirp Sumitpo, Lord Tracer, ByAsura (staff), Dual Binoculars, Qawsefd234 (staff), Kachon123
Agree: Imposing Tiger, Quangotjokes, LordTracer, Emirp Sumitpo, Kachon123
Neutral: ByAsura (staff), Dual Binoculars
Disagree: Qawsedf234 (staff)
Agree: Imposing Tiger, Quangotjokes, Lord Tracer, Kachon123
Neutral: ByAsura (staff), Dual Binoculars
Disagree: Qawsedf234 (staff)
idk what Emirp thinks after I brought up my last point.
That's it. What do we do here?
Last edited:
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #69
Cool
- 24,975
- 26,822
I'm actually neutral for these
- 22,337
- 18,523
Hard disagree.
Also, I don't think it matters too much when some of the stuff here just may not be correct at all, like MK's missiles.
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #72
That point doesn't talk about MK
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #74
Bang, Bomb and Rover's point, Psykos point? I don't think they are wrong in any form.
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #76
OK. Then I concede to the Possibly 7-A and Melzalgard's points.
Are the rest worthy of a poll for you?
- 22,337
- 18,523
That depends if the evidence is strong enough. In all honesty, most of it seems ok to an extent, but there's definitely a lot of areas that aren't very convincing (a few of us have already given our grievances throughout the thread).
Also, we don't usually vote to agree on stuff. We keep arguing until points are debunked.
Also, we don't usually vote to agree on stuff. We keep arguing until points are debunked.
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #78
Ok then, what holes do you see in the rest of the points? Let's debate it.
- 22,337
- 18,523
As I said, I've already gone over a few, like the unknown difference between Beast Garou and Darkshine, but I guess I'll go over some more stuff.
Rover, in both instances, is absolutely furious. In the first, he fires a huge blast that engulfs a massive area and shakes the ground above them. He then fires a penetrating blast that's designed to kill Garou at point-blank range. So, of course it's going to be smaller (even though it's not truly smaller and did far more damage to the Association itself) than an omni-directional blasts. Once that fails, he switches to rapid blasts that have less effect on Garou, and do similar collective damage.
Now, if you look at the final blast, this is only the first portion (and even then, it has the same length as that blast's diameter even in the panel you show). It proceeds to knock Garou right down to Psykos' lair afterwards.
In the second, Rover is actually less powerful due to being hit by Saitama, but much angrier. However, this reflected blast was omni-directional, and didn't do much more damage than either of those blasts (it did less, if anything).
So, basically, I do think his blasts vary, but there's no evidence for the blasts varying here.
While I do think they vary in power, taking his mindset is much more important than just 'bigger explosion'. If you go by that logic, every character in fiction should have variable firepower. For example, this is Rover's first blast against the trio in a frenzied state.
Rover, in both instances, is absolutely furious. In the first, he fires a huge blast that engulfs a massive area and shakes the ground above them. He then fires a penetrating blast that's designed to kill Garou at point-blank range. So, of course it's going to be smaller (even though it's not truly smaller and did far more damage to the Association itself) than an omni-directional blasts. Once that fails, he switches to rapid blasts that have less effect on Garou, and do similar collective damage.
Now, if you look at the final blast, this is only the first portion (and even then, it has the same length as that blast's diameter even in the panel you show). It proceeds to knock Garou right down to Psykos' lair afterwards.
In the second, Rover is actually less powerful due to being hit by Saitama, but much angrier. However, this reflected blast was omni-directional, and didn't do much more damage than either of those blasts (it did less, if anything).
So, basically, I do think his blasts vary, but there's no evidence for the blasts varying here.
- 1,984
- 1,235
- Thread starter
- #80
You don't know if it's the first portion. Looking at its shape, it could be ending at any time. What we see is what we see, nothing more.
Rover is hurt and likely less powerful physically, but who says he's weaker with his energy balls. We don't know how they work so we can't assume his attacks are also less effective.
The fact that it was omnidirectional proves it was bigger, because it created a circle, which obviously would be smaller than a straight line. If that blast was fired in one direction, it would actually be much larger, despite being as powerful as it is now. And if you compare the stories in each panel, you will count around 15 at most in his fight against Garou (being one-directional blasts) while they engulf over 20 stories against the trio (being omnidirectional, which as I pointed out earlier, would make the area of effect smaller).
The main problem is that Bomb tanked a hit from Garou with minimal damage, he didn't even break his nose. If we see our current scaling, Bomb should have been absolutely one shoted and destroyed by that blow. Beast Garou is stronger (to an unknown extent, although I would argue it is his biggest amp yet because it has been the closest he's been to death) than Spiral Garou. Bomb matches Beast Garou in a direct move once or twice. SG matched Darkshine in AP. Darkshine broke Half Monster Garou's ribcage (which should have killed him if he hadn't his immortality-like abilities, as seen when he thought he was going to die against Rover). A weaker Half Monster Garou could tank the second biggest blast we've seen from Rover yet without much problem, after evolving during their fight. This puts Darkshine's AP massively above Rover's, and Bomb's AP above Darkshine's. This also means Bomb's AP is much higher than HM Garou's. But we keep saying they are around the same level because Bang was surprised he was unscathed after taking Rover's blast. The only way to solve that problem without falling into outlier territory (which should be avoided if things can be logically explained) is by arguing Rover was attacking Bang and Bomb with higher AP (for whatever reason, maybe he was angrier or maybe he had more time to charge).
