- 8,997
- 9,718
Oh shit. Read your reply wrong. He should upscale from high Demon level threats
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
One Punch Man Disaster Ratings Part 2
- Thread starter ByAsura
- Start date
-
- Tags
- one-punch man
- Status
- 25,025
- 27,039
Ah I see
- 25,025
- 27,039
Why unknown?
- 25,025
- 27,039
I mean being superior to his subordinates is something. that's better than just unknown
- 22,391
- 18,598
- Thread starter
- #47
In a subjective versus match kind of way, yes. But Unknown is far more accurate for indexing, especially due to Geryu's attack speed.
We can just go Unknown (Far superior to his subordinates; was confident in fighting Saitama even after he effortlessly one-shot Geryuanshoop)
It's basically the same result, but without a specific rating.
We can just go Unknown (Far superior to his subordinates; was confident in fighting Saitama even after he effortlessly one-shot Geryuanshoop)
It's basically the same result, but without a specific rating.
- 31,404
- 27,703
I agree.
- 25,025
- 27,039
But that's not really the case since we do have one solid thing, so it's not really unknown.
We don't scale geryu's attack speed to anyone but Saitama, so I don't see the point here.
- 22,391
- 18,598
- Thread starter
- #50
That is the case, since the gap is completely unknown and extremely vague. We did the same for Drive Knight before.
Also, trust me, people are going to become apes after seeing that Boros is only at least Hypersonic.
There's constant talks of it, but we can never get anywhere.
- 25,025
- 27,039
I'm pretty sure they're gonna go completely ape all the same seeing Boros as unknown.
CosmicWreck
He/Him- 674
- 385
Well, I don't disagree but why stop at speed? In that case you might as well make that entire key unknown tbh.
- 25,025
- 27,039
Released has his own feats, so his AP would not be unknown. For Armored Boros IDK
- 22,391
- 18,598
- Thread starter
- #55
On that one, we already scale him to possibly Continent level for something he actually did do.
CosmicWreck
He/Him- 674
- 385
Armored Boros simply never lamenting on Saitama destroying his ship shouldn't be anymore impressive or different to actually lamenting on Saitama beating on his subordinates. Nor should it be considered any more impressive since during that very same report Boros mistakenly thought only the top combatants could handle him.
Sealed Boros and the top combatants should be on the same level of strength since the same reasoning can be used. Unless you're going to shirk the statements aside and rewrite the page entirely with new interpretations of scaling it seems hardly necessary to change Boros' current keys like that. Honestly, out of things I find questionable of Boros' page I don't think this is one of them.
- 22,391
- 18,598
- Thread starter
- #57
Firstly, 'never lamenting' is a gross under exaggeration; Boros outright wanted to wreck him after this. Secondly, I was actually talking about his durability feat. Third, Saitama was holding back massively the entire time, so your point about him mistakenly thinking the top combatants could win doesn't make any sense.
Literally never said they can't be scaled. Did you even read my post? I just said Boros should be Unknown rather than at least Hypersonic, just like the Drive Knight stuff.
Literally never said they can't be scaled. Did you even read my post? I just said Boros should be Unknown rather than at least Hypersonic, just like the Drive Knight stuff.
Last edited:
- 22,391
- 18,598
- Thread starter
- #58
On another note, does anyone still object to me switching Suiryu's speed to Hypersonic?
- 25,025
- 27,039
Nope
CosmicWreck
He/Him- 674
- 385
I don't think you quite grasped what I was saying but never mind. It's beyond the scope of this thread and I don't think it's particularly important.
Go ahead I guess.
- 15,450
- 15,867
I… don’t see why Unknown would be more accurate here. If you’re gonna definitively say that he’s superior to Melz, Groribas and Gery, then he should straight-up scale to their speed.
And as for Gery’s attack speed making it weird, I think just doing “At least Hypersonic (Far superior to his subordinates), possibly far higher (Was confident in fighting Saitama even after he effortlessly one-shot Geryuganshoop)” would make more sense.
- 15,450
- 15,867
Wdym it’s not representative of his speed, he has literally no speed feats. How can it not represent something we literally didn’t see?
I separated them to imply that maybe Boros scales to Gery’s attack speed, but it’s unclear, hence “possibly far higher”.
I separated them to imply that maybe Boros scales to Gery’s attack speed, but it’s unclear, hence “possibly far higher”.
- 22,391
- 18,598
- Thread starter
- #69
Literally the point. He has no speed feats, or really anything to indicate his level of speed. Him seeing his minions as massive fodder is accurate, but not really close to ascertaining his true speed.
Which doesn't make a whole lot of sense because they'd essentially just convey the same thing.
Anyway, what do you think of this suggestion?
- 15,450
- 15,867
Then “At least Hypersonic, likely far higher” makes even more sense, just add something like “Could potentially be even faster, as he never showcased his speed” to his likely far higher justification. No reason to slap Unknown on him.
Something like “Unknown (Never displayed his speed), likely at least Hypersonic (Should be far superior to his subordinates)” would make more sense imo. Adding a non-possibly/likely tier after Unknown just makes the Unknown rating seem pointless.
- 22,391
- 18,598
- Thread starter
- #71
It doesn't make more sense, but I guess that's just a matter of opinion.
Possibly far higher was for scaling to the attack speed.
- 8,997
- 9,718
Why can’t Boros just outright scale to it?
- 15,450
- 15,867
Gery doesn’t even scale outright. His attack speed is only Possibly Relativistic+.
I guess “Unknown, possibly Hypersonic or higher” could work.
- 8,997
- 9,718
Can’t Boros scale to possibly Relativistic+?
- 15,450
- 15,867
I mean, I could see an argument for it, but I don’t feel too strongly about it.
- 6,590
- 3,423
I overall agree with LordTracer's points
Outside from that, I guess the only thing left to talk about is Amai Mask and Fuhrer Ugly ? I guess his comment on his speed is WC only ? Because I haven't found it on the manga, even then, that kind of comment doesn't necessarily means he is faster than him
Still, I believe we are upgrading Iaian and some others (like Do-S who was completely blitzed) to Massively Hypersonic, so both him and Amai Mask should stay at the same rating, just with a few more justifications
Outside from that, I guess the only thing left to talk about is Amai Mask and Fuhrer Ugly ? I guess his comment on his speed is WC only ? Because I haven't found it on the manga, even then, that kind of comment doesn't necessarily means he is faster than him
Still, I believe we are upgrading Iaian and some others (like Do-S who was completely blitzed) to Massively Hypersonic, so both him and Amai Mask should stay at the same rating, just with a few more justifications
- 22,391
- 18,598
- Thread starter
- #79
That creates huge scaling issues because VFU >> Sweet Mask and Iaian, yet Atomic Samurai is scaled greatly above VFU, and we're somewhat scaling Iaian to AS.
I think we can fix this by saying VFU purposefully let them 'blitz' him, as he's about to tag them later before they're saved.
I think we can fix this by saying VFU purposefully let them 'blitz' him, as he's about to tag them later before they're saved.
- 6,590
- 3,423
So that Iaian CRT is getting rejected/partially rejected ?
Well, then it falls on my first comment, Amai Mask calling Fuhrer Ugly fast doesn't mean much besides its face value, and I still didn't find that quote on the manga
Well, then it falls on my first comment, Amai Mask calling Fuhrer Ugly fast doesn't mean much besides its face value, and I still didn't find that quote on the manga
- Status
