All of you never considered that the town BB crushed was a higher D townClassic OP downplayers.
On a more serious note here my own irrelevant opinion after reading the 4 pages of this : i tend to lean toward the opposition. I think they have better arguments and the fact that despite multiples uses of his fruit, BB never displayed anything like the level of destruction/power the statements he make imply.
Not to mention, that if his darkness had that much mass, what use would WB fruit be to him ? He would merely have to slam a bit of darkness on the ground to create much more powerfull earthquakes than WB or BW could ever hope to do with it.
Don't you see how its correlated? He's able to bring the gravity of it down to 0 allowing even fodders to not be harmed them amp it massively depending on what he needs to do
I tackled this and you completely ignored it
why doesnt kizaru just blip around the world to find the one piece in a matter of hours?
Yes, Blackbeard can control his Devil fruit power
Why doens't Luffy stretch all the way across the grandline? Why don't they just build a plane and fly over the red line?
Why? It doesn't seem like one has anything to do with the other.
We aren't arguing on what's conclusive evidence or not, we're arguing on interpretations. The interpretation you're presenting requires us to completely discount all of the countless statements made by knowledgeable characters and even the author themselves about the strength of Blackbeard's Devil Fruit as hyperbolic because it has supposed contradictory feats.
Blackbeard states he compresses objects with infinite power. If we're taking this to be non-hyperbolic, wouldn't this mean he has infinite AP?
Not inherently since "infinite" used in both statements doesn't inherently mean true infinity, "infinite" could just mean vast or great in scope/power. It all depends on the context, of which in either scenario, it still paints a picture that Blackbeard's Devil Fruit is incredibly powerful and holds immense gravitational force.
Okay. Cool.
no for the same reasons why black holes dont have infinite ap
Hearing people gas me up after being a joke for my entire run feels so good.
Good to have you back
The bazooka troops are shown to be injured by being immersed in his darkness, and same for the guards at the prison entrance. It doesn't look like he "chose to not pierce their skin" as you phrased it.
Just because they were responded to doesn't mean the objections no longer exist.
No. I don't think there's anything suggesting the throw is what hurts them... They all appeared injured before they land.
1- The bazooka troops were already being attacked and being injured by blackbeard crew wayyy before he even did any attack[1] they were also offscreened so we can't know what exactly happened but its heavily implied Shiryu helped the bb pirates defeat them thus explaining the injuries of the rest[2]
I would agree with being an interpretation if we didn't have enough information to make an objective statement
And then shot back out for liberation iirc. As we established, liberation is used for projectile attacks and not crushing.
