- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #121
The nukes thing was removed from the OP yeah
Radiation manipulation stays though, because of the nuclear carrier, not cause of the radiation treatment thing
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
New Year, new metal knight
- Thread starter ZillertheBucko
- Start date
- Status
Radiation manipulation stays though, because of the nuclear carrier, not cause of the radiation treatment thing
- 31,590
- 28,052
Yes, you do.
Otherwise we might as well say to hell with accuracy and give Harry Potter's profile a gun because with enough prep time, he could buy a gun if he wanted.
What is the difference between "making something" and "buying something" in practice? Nothing at all, really. But it's not in his character to use or own a gun, so we don't do it even though, by all means, there is nothing stopping Harry Potter from buying or stealing a firearm.
Are you telling me that it is categorically impossible for Harry Potter to own a gun? If not, then you must acknowledge that is is possible for Harry Potter to own a gun?
Yet you understand why we don't list a gun as part of Harry Potter's possible equipment, right?
- 31,590
- 28,052
Okay, I'm going to resort to pulling up our page on Standard Equipment and Optional Equipment.
So clearly, Child Emperor's tech cannot be considered a part of Metal Knight's Standard Equipment for obvious reasons.
Child Emperor's tech is not something that Metal Knight has owned or made use of in the manga. And certianly not for any clear extended period of time.
Therefore this discussion frankly should be over. Child Emperor's tech is not a part of Metal Knight's standard or optional equipment.
So clearly, Child Emperor's tech cannot be considered a part of Metal Knight's Standard Equipment for obvious reasons.
Child Emperor's tech is not something that Metal Knight has owned or made use of in the manga. And certianly not for any clear extended period of time.
Therefore this discussion frankly should be over. Child Emperor's tech is not a part of Metal Knight's standard or optional equipment.
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #124
Well yes, I do. Not only does Harry Potter not have a preparation key from what I remember, but he also does not need a gun. However, if Harry Potter was in a vs thread against the outerversal super demon who can only be defeated by a bullet, and he was given prior knowledge and a year of prep time, I think nobody would argue that he would be able to acquire a gun in that time and come and shoot him and win. For obvious reasons, it’s not something that would be listed on the profiles since it doesn’t fit into standard or optional equipment, and doesn’t have a place in his Powers and Abilities section either. On the other hand, metal knight having child emperor’s tech abilities would be something that would need to be listed in the profile since it’s a whole catalogue of potential new abilities that isn’t already something people would know he obviously has access to.
If you were paying attention you’d know this is already considered. As said before, child emperor’s gadgets themselves wouldn’t be part of his equipment section, but the technology used to create them would indeed be represented in metal knight’s preparation key abilities.
So quick to end the discussion and try and close the thread before I even respond to your new arguments
- 20,607
- 17,607
It wouldn't apply anyways. All the ratings are solely prep based and Mwtal Knight couldn't use them without constructing gear first.
But said prep can also be accomplished by just linking thr page and mentioning he might have other abilities.
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #126
I was gonna go chill and do something else but now I’m seriously concerned that the thread’s gonna be closed the second I’m gone when I stop replying to the new arguments you come up with, which I am not a fan of.Well yes, I do. Not only does Harry Potter not have a preparation key from what I remember, but he also does not need a gun. However, if Harry Potter was in a vs thread against the outerversal super demon who can only be defeated by a bullet, and he was given prior knowledge and a year of prep time, I think nobody would argue that he would be able to acquire a gun in that time and come and shoot him and win. For obvious reasons, it’s not something that would be listed on the profiles since it doesn’t fit into standard or optional equipment, and doesn’t have a place in his Powers and Abilities section either. On the other hand, metal knight having child emperor’s tech abilities would be something that would need to be listed in the profile since it’s a whole catalogue of potential new abilities that isn’t already something people would know he obviously has access to.
If you were paying attention you’d know this is already considered. As said before, child emperor’s gadgets themselves wouldn’t be part of his equipment section, but the technology used to create them would indeed be represented in metal knight’s preparation key abilities.
So quick to end the discussion and try and close the thread before I even respond to your new arguments
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #127
I’m confused now
so you said it wouldn’t apply before, but you’re also saying that it would apply with prep if you link the abilities?
- 31,590
- 28,052
Thread's not closed.
- 20,607
- 17,607
What I mean is that the majority of his powers are not combat applicable. They're all prep based. The powers we give him are based off of those prep things or machines he's used for stuff.
Having access to CE's tech would not give him any of those abilities in a fight. They would be prep based powers.
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #130
yeah, I was proposing that they're prep only
- 31,590
- 28,052
Can you cite any other precedent where this amount of leeway is given to a character having access to certain technology?
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #132
obviously not, but surely something not having a precedent isn't going to be one of your arguments against it being true, right?
- 31,590
- 28,052
It would help your case more if this was something regularly accepted.
If you're asking for an exceptional circumstance to be approved, then it's not unwarranted to expect substantial evidence for it. More than what has been presented.
If you're asking for an exceptional circumstance to be approved, then it's not unwarranted to expect substantial evidence for it. More than what has been presented.
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #134
well I guess so? But it doesn't really change anything since I wasn't relying on there being a precedent for it
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #135
bump
- 31,590
- 28,052
How much time are you asking for by the way before what gets accepted is applied and this is closed? Until this weekend?
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #137
I don't know, I'm just gonna keep bumping it until something changes
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #138
Also just to keep track of everything
approved changes include radiation manipulation, energy projection, self destruction (for main drone), and that's basically it
the currently debated thing is giving metal knight access to child emperor's technology based abilities with preparation time, with the omission of brave giant
approved changes include radiation manipulation, energy projection, self destruction (for main drone), and that's basically it
the currently debated thing is giving metal knight access to child emperor's technology based abilities with preparation time, with the omission of brave giant
- 31,590
- 28,052
The thread can't remain open indefinitely.
After a certain point you've got to accept that some of your proposals have been accepted and some have been rejected.
- 8,997
- 9,718
I think we should just go with Qawsed's suggestion and call it there
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #141
it will close eventually, since it's impossible to keep a thread alive indefinitely
but today is not that day
for now, there is no good reason to not keep it open
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #143
About Qaw's suggestion, it is still kind of vague to me. Does it mean that bofoi does have access to the abilities when given prep time? Or does it mean a complete rejection of the proposal? Either way, I still would prefer to list the specific abilities that would be granted since the proposal only applies to child emperor's technology and not all of his abilities, specifying which ones would be a better way to format it.
- 31,590
- 28,052
Metal Knight had a drone of his taken directly to the Monster Association Headquarters.... This is completely irrelevant Ziller.
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #145
true
- 31,590
- 28,052
The issue is not just "The character is super knowledgeable, so he should be able to use any tech that Child Emperor can use." It matters whether he has been shown or stated to use it.
Say, for example, the nation of Wakanda in the MCU is a highly advanced technological society with wealth, resources, genius scientists, etc.... Does that mean we would give them Tony Stark's arc reactor just because it has been shown that Shuri is cleverer than Tony?
No, I don't think we would.
You say that "We're not giving Metal Knight access to Child Emperor's gadgets, just the technology that those gadgets use"... but it's the same thing, essentially. You're inventing this headcanon version of Metal Knight where he uses poison gas, and ice beams, and adhesive bullets... but just because those things exist does not mean he would necessarily use them.
The best thing we could do is just add a note to his profile saying "Metal Knight's full arsenal has not been revealed yet."
It too speculative to say "He might be able to use this power, and this power, and this power, etc. given an unknown amount of time, money and connections."
Say, for example, the nation of Wakanda in the MCU is a highly advanced technological society with wealth, resources, genius scientists, etc.... Does that mean we would give them Tony Stark's arc reactor just because it has been shown that Shuri is cleverer than Tony?
No, I don't think we would.
You say that "We're not giving Metal Knight access to Child Emperor's gadgets, just the technology that those gadgets use"... but it's the same thing, essentially. You're inventing this headcanon version of Metal Knight where he uses poison gas, and ice beams, and adhesive bullets... but just because those things exist does not mean he would necessarily use them.
The best thing we could do is just add a note to his profile saying "Metal Knight's full arsenal has not been revealed yet."
It too speculative to say "He might be able to use this power, and this power, and this power, etc. given an unknown amount of time, money and connections."
- 8,997
- 9,718
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #148
Which is still a weaker example than this situation, in which we know that child emperor was directly under metal knight as his assistant for some amount time, and child emperor is only a 10 year old, meaning that the time between becoming independent from bofoi to the monster association arc would have not been a significant amount of time, an incredibly tight timeframe for, according to you, coming up with like 20 inventions that metal knight has no idea how to create.
So yes, I completely agree that we wouldn't give shuri tony's abilities; and no, it is nowhere near the same situation
I would agree with you here, if it hadn't been for the fact that we don't actually see prep time metal knight fighting against an enemy; there's nothing to suggest that it would be out of character, or as you put it "headcanon", to say that he might think to do these things in a proper preparation situation. In fact he literally arrives late to the fight every time he could have prepared, against the monster association and again against dark matter.
- 31,590
- 28,052
That sounds like an argument from skepticism to be honest.
You can't get the abilities added to the profile just because you don't believe Metal Knight shouldn't have them.
It is absolutely headcanon until it is demonstrated that Metal Knight makes use of these technologies.
- 20,607
- 17,607
Yes. It means with prep time you can make an argument of him being able to replicate some gear or effects.
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #151
Well in that case, I would pretty much agree with that resolution
- 31,590
- 28,052
I don't care what happens for the VS threads, so long as we've got this settled now for the profile.
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #153
…uh, isn’t believing metal knight should have them like, the point of making a crt about metal knight having them? I don’t see your point here
- 31,590
- 28,052
Not when your primary reasoning is just that disbelief.
- 20,607
- 17,607
Alright. We can apply what I said and thread should be done.
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #156
When did I say “I think metal knight should have the abilities because I think he should have the abilities”
- 31,590
- 28,052
I don't think you've ever said that exact combination of words.
Anyway, this discussion appears to be done now.
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #158
so all that's left is to apply the changes?
- 31,590
- 28,052
Yes. I'll put a sandbox together. Can you re-post the scans here needed for the new abilities?
- 13,903
- 5,405
- Thread starter
- #160
I'll put them into imgur and repost them here soon
- Status
Similar threads
