Moon Movement 5-B to Naruto-Verse UPGRADE (Let's do this again but right :D)

[Ghostimuscrime]

Hey, Qawsed, please kindly check the most recent rebuttals to Slayer's post. I have gathered them above.

imo leave it lex

Hags sealed kags and let the moon levitate for years (no folklore of levitating moon resting at cloud level for years)
even tho hags had his lore and was worshipped as a god
humans would see this daily and never consider to add this to the lore (trust)
re opened the moon (moon level king), redid the jutsu that takes two people by himself, tucking the gedo mazo in a moon and yeeted it

her children (plural) transforming kags into a core and turning it into a moon was a lie kishimoto made up
it was child (singular)


so you should stop fr

 

[Samlex1234]

imo leave it lex

Hags sealed kags and let the moon levitate for years (no folklore of levitating moon resting at cloud level for years)
even tho hags had his lore and was worshipped as a god
humans would see this daily and never consider to add this to the lore (trust)
re opened the moon (moon level king), redid the jutsu that takes two people by himself, tucking the gedo mazo in a moon and yeeted it

her children (plural) transforming kags into a core and turning it into a moon was a lie kishimoto made up
it was child (singular)


so you should stop fr

. Yet we ignore the only visual representation we have for a weak narrative. A chibaku tensei the size of the moon staying in earth stratosphere for years. Definitely “This definitely sounds more logical”

Implications

1. Destruction of the Atmosphere
2. Tidal Forces and Massive Earthquakes
3. Eclipse-Like Darkness at least In one part of the earth as the moon would be blocking the sun.
4. Normal Humans can not even survive this(lack of sunlight, seismic activities Etc)


I'm sorry guys but this is absolutely nonsense and you guys know it. This has to be the most illogical argument/ narrative I have seen on this wiki. I know the whole argument from Slayer is this helps the narrative but I put it to you that it doesn't. We know of one SPCT feat not two. Kaguya/ten tails was sealed once not twice.

 

[Ghostimuscrime]

. Yet we ignore the only visual representation we have for a weak narrative. A chibaku tensei the size of the moon staying in earth stratosphere for years. Definitely “This definitely sounds more logical”

I wonder what logical person thinks

silly hags locked juubi in the moon
broke it
took it out
left the CT eggshell floating for 1k years
locked gm in moon again
sent it away by himself


instead of sealing & transferring at once like the manga & db suggest many times over

but oh well majority chose this route
nun to do anymore

 

[Testarossa002]

This is bordering on a rule violation
If you can't deal with having a CRT rejected, go vent somewhere else.
Implying that those who disagreed can't read is insulting
It's not that deep. Even the OP isn't crashing out.
Knock if off

 

[Ghostimuscrime]

ight, let me edit that out

 

[Deceived3596]

Honestly, I don't think the point about the SPCT levitating within the Stratosphere or above it, into space, is all that important currently. It could be either, and both of them don't necessarily imply a given time frame. So, even if we assume it didn't reside around the planet, and was instead blasted off into space to become the new moon after the technique finished, we still can't derive a time frame with the feat - from that sequence of events alone. Thus, we can't derive the kinetic energy created by its movement into space.

As I said, it all falls back to the aforementioned Anime-filler conversation. So focusing on that should be the top priority. Also, speaking about my original post; I'll just state that I mostly agree with Slayer's arguments, and I am fine considering his arguments as tantamount to my own. I don't want to waste time formulating a post, just for that post to be ultimately pointless when staff already agree with the conclusions reached from it, because of someone else's arguments prior to mine.

 

[JohnHendrix212]

Just focus on the main points of Slayer's rebuttal, make a case against it, and make a CRT in the future, if you want.

I think this thread's dragged out for too long.

 

[Samlex1234]

Honestly, I don't think the point about the SPCT levitating within the Stratosphere or above it, into space, is all that important currently. It could be either, and both of them don't necessarily imply a given time frame. So, even if we assume it didn't reside around the planet, and was instead blasted off into space to become the new moon after the technique finished, we still can't derive a time frame with the feat - from that sequence of events alone. Thus, we can't derive the kinetic energy created by its movement into space.

As I said, it all falls back to the aforementioned Anime-filler conversation. So focusing on that should be the top priority. Also, speaking about my original post; I'll just state that I mostly agree with Slayer's arguments, and I am fine considering his arguments as tantamount to my own. I don't want to waste time formulating a post, just for that post to be ultimately pointless when staff already agree with the conclusions reached from it, because of someone else's arguments prior to mine.

Okay if the narrative implications do not matter why can't we use the only visual representation of the feat we have since we have evidence to support the involvement of Kishi in this episode.

Absolutely no contradictions for the performed feat at leastt. Even the explanation says Hurled/ blasted which still supports the anime that it was done rather quickly. Whether it was Kaguya that was sealed or ten tails or even both what matters at the end of the day to the scaling is the feat performed.

Just focus on the main points of Slayer's rebuttal, make a case against it, and make a CRT in the future, if you want.

I think this thread's dragged out for too long.

We are waiting for Qawsed depending on his input this could be closed immediately or a Tie