Medaka Box General Discussion

[Agnaa]

You know I'm kinda curious about what revisions are planned?

Mostly AP and formatting.

Though I did notice a Kinda impressive speed feat. Though it might be deemed an outlier with all the current stuff.
That being Medaka blitzing Aijmu's finger gun move that could blow up stars with it's speed. This is after it's "fired."

Ie She's pointing it, goes "Bang" to a white screen and next page Medaka diverted her finger gun.
Though again could be an outlier.

1. We don't treat that feat as real due to all the weirdness with it; it's a recording within a dream world where she has capabilities she doesn't in reality (i.e. being unsealed when she was IRL) being played back after she died. That's why her tier's Unknown, possibly 3-A, instead of At least 4-C, possibly 3-A.
2. It's a bit weird given the way it was all framed. The scan you're referring to is this one which is the last page of the chapter. I wouldn't necessarily assume that this means the bang went off before Medaka started moving, rather than assuming that this ending hid information (that Medaka stopped it) for dramatic effect until the next chapter (MB, and media as a whole, does this a lot). Meaning that it could've been similar to an aimdodge.
3. She was said to stop it with Kurokami Phantom Original Version, which has other statements about its speed both before and after this, establishing it as at or not too far above lightspeed.
4. Seems like a random audience member said that for this feat Medaka stopped Ajimu with sonic speed. I'd consider this a low-end outlier view, but it still works in contrast to your idea.

I am aware it'd be mftl+, I'm just not certain it specifically is an outlier considering how up in the air most of medaka boxes stats are and medaka already being considered "casually" near light speed (like 1-5% light speed?). Hence why i mentioned it here for other's to judge.

She's casually relativistic when playing instruments, but with effort and a special technique she gets modestly FTL. Like, I think at best, if you did some Calc Stacking, you'd be able to put KPOV at FTL+. MFTL+ to that extent would be far, far above what she does with exertion.

I have begun to read NisiOisiN's new manga, "Cipher Academy". Does anybody else have the impression that the "villain girl" in the early chapters is intended to be intended to be a mean version of Medaka? She looks similar and is also extremely competent in any case.

I didn't pick up on that myself. If I did I would've recommended it to you, but I personally didn't enjoy it too much, or see noteworthy parallels.

 

[FoxySonicMaster108]

You know I'm kinda curious about what revisions are planned?

Key changes (for Medaka especially), as well as AP. Most of the characters are going to be 9-A or 8-C I'm guessing.

I am aware it'd be mftl+, I'm just not certain it specifically is an outlier considering how up in the air most of medaka boxes stats are and medaka already being considered "casually" near light speed (like 1-5% light speed?). Hence why i mentioned it here for other's to judge.

Ehhh. That probably wouldn't count because only the attack speed of it is that fast. Medaka stopped Ajimu before she even did anything so no, it wouldn't count for anything higher imo.

See here please:
snip

I can sort of see it.

 

[Jesterofgames]

Mostly AP and formatting.

1. We don't treat that feat as real due to all the weirdness with it; it's a recording within a dream world where she has capabilities she doesn't in reality (i.e. being unsealed when she was IRL) being played back after she died. That's why her tier's Unknown, possibly 3-A, instead of At least 4-C, possibly 3-A.
2. It's a bit weird given the way it was all framed. The scan you're referring to is this one which is the last page of the chapter. I wouldn't necessarily assume that this means the bang went off before Medaka started moving, rather than assuming that this ending hid information (that Medaka stopped it) for dramatic effect until the next chapter (MB, and media as a whole, does this a lot). Meaning that it could've been similar to an aimdodge.
3. She was said to stop it with Kurokami Phantom Original Version, which has other statements about its speed both before and after this, establishing it as at or not too far above lightspeed.
4. Seems like a random audience member said that for this feat Medaka stopped Ajimu with sonic speed. I'd consider this a low-end outlier view, but it still works in contrast to your idea.

Fair, I was just wondering.
Though I personally disagree with point 1 myself. 2-4 are all fair points.

 

[FoxySonicMaster108]

I've always been iffy on the dream stuff, because Ajimu in the dreams is described as her prime self. If she was just called a dream self or something similar, that would be the end of it.

 

[Agnaa]

I've always been iffy on the dream stuff, because Ajimu in the dreams is described as her prime self. If she was just called a dream self or something similar, that would be the end of it.

I just think that's weird because, if that actually existed somewhere as some place real, couldn't she use Alibi Block to just take that unsealed prime self to the real world? Plus, she talks a lot about those places where she communicates with Kumagawa being a dream. Looking back, I found something even weirder; Ajimu says that when Kumagawa dies, he doesn't see her, he sees the version of her that comes from his heart.

 

[FoxySonicMaster108]

I just think that's weird because, if that actually existed somewhere as some place real, couldn't she use Alibi Block to just take that unsealed prime self to the real world? Plus, she talks a lot about those places where she communicates with Kumagawa being a dream. Looking back, I found something even weirder; Ajimu says that when Kumagawa dies, he doesn't see her, he sees the version of her that comes from his heart.

Even with this, I still find it odd that this Ajimu which is described as her prime self would have some different powers/different feats when nothing states that they so vastly different from each other and some of the feats from the dreams are included on Ajimu's profile as NPI. But at the same time, I kinda understand why the feats from the dreams aren't used anyway.

But maybe it's just Kumagawa's Ajimu that's vastly different? I don't even know myself.

 

[Agnaa]

Even with this, I still find it odd that this Ajimu which is described as her prime self would have some different powers/different feats when nothing states that they so vastly different from each other

It's not so much that, but that the events of the dream wouldn't really be taken as possible in reality.

and some of the feats from the dreams are included on Ajimu's profile as NPI.

I had no clue what you were talking about; turns out that was added 3 months ago in a thread none of the knowledgeable staff members on MB participated in. I don't consider this legitimate at all, and can see many issues with the stuff added.

But you're right that including one and not the other is inconsistent.

@DontTalkDT @Antvasima Y'all got any thoughts on that?

EDIT: I've just gone ahead and created a CRT to undo that one.

But maybe it's just Kumagawa's Ajimu that's vastly different? I don't even know myself.

Even then, that's the one that took down the star.

 

[FoxySonicMaster108]

Alright, I'm gonna get back to work on that Medaka sandbox I was working on a while back. It's just been hard since I haven't had the motivation to do it in a bit.

 

[Dragonite007]

Alright, I'm gonna get back to work on that Medaka sandbox I was working on a while back. It's just been hard since I haven't had the motivation to do it in a bit.

After 5 months, the same question:

Has the moon calc already been approved?

 

[FoxySonicMaster108]

After 5 months, the same question:

Has the moon calc already been approved?

Nope, sadly.

 

[Antvasima]

What calculation blog do you need evaluated? You can ask for help in the thread below and mention that I sent you.

Calculation Evaluations (New forum)

This thread is intended for users to link to new blog post calculations, to relay them to the community, and have them evaluated by the calculation group, without contacting the members individually. To evaluate important off-site calculations, preferably copy them to blog posts in this wiki...

vsbattles.com

 

[FoxySonicMaster108]

What calculation blog do you need evaluated? You can ask for help in the thread below and mention that I sent you.

Calculation Evaluations (New forum)

This thread is intended for users to link to new blog post calculations, to relay them to the community, and have them evaluated by the calculation group, without contacting the members individually. To evaluate important off-site calculations, preferably copy them to blog posts in this wiki...

vsbattles.com

This is the one I’m pretty sure. I’ve sent the calc in question and bumped it a few times.

 

[Antvasima]

This is the one I’m pretty sure. I’ve sent the calc in question and bumped it a few times.

Okay. If you link to your last bump, I can ask for help for you.

 

[FoxySonicMaster108]

Okay. If you link to your last bump, I can ask for help for you.

Alright, here it is

 

[Antvasima]

I have now requested help for you.

 

[Dragonite007]

Alright, here it is

Finally, was approved

 

[Antvasima]

Thank you. It can probably be used then.

 

[FoxySonicMaster108]

Amongst all the downgrades, there was an upgrade. Low 5-B Medaka let’s gooo

 

[Antvasima]

@Agnaa

Do you find this acceptable?

 

[Agnaa]

I kind of disagree with using that method for static images; in real life shockwaves travel very slowly. So if you see them comparable to rocks, that means the rocks were only moving at around Mach 1.

Still, that's a broader issue beyond this specific calc, so idk if it's right for me to decide to reject it. Especially without a thread.

 

[Antvasima]

Okay. So do you think that it is better if we keep a standard Moon-destroying energy value instead?

 

[Agnaa]

The High 6-A value we get from that may be more accurate, but I wouldn't want to only apply that to this verse.

I'll quickly whip up a thread about this.

EDIT: I've made the thread.

EDIT 2: Actually, thinking about it more, the standard moon-destroying value is for "Punching the moon so hard that its parts fly off and never reform"; since we know that it never reformed in MB, it has to be at least that value, so we should keep that standard value.

 

[Antvasima]

Okay, so you support 5-C as usual then?

 

[Agnaa]

Yeah.

 

[Antvasima]

Okay. And why is that value better than the new calculation in this case, more specifically?

 

[Dragonite007]

Okay. And why is that value better than the new calculation in this case, more specifically?

They're discussing in this thread

 

[Antvasima]

Okay. Thank you for the information.

 

[Agnaa]

Okay. And why is that value better than the new calculation in this case, more specifically?

Essentially, I think the new calc is flawed, since it's based on the speed of the rocks, asserting a short timeframe because a shockwave is visible.

I argue that a shockwave being visible doesn't necessitate a short timeframe.

And so in lieu of that, our calculation options are either frag over the moon's volume (which would only yield High 6-A, likely an underestimation), or the baseline 5-C calc (which is just "send a planet's mass flying quickly enough that gravity doesn't pull it back together").

 

[Antvasima]

Okay. Thank you for your evaluation.

We will see if the other calc group members agree with you in that regard in your other discussion thread.