MCU Winter Soldier vs DCEU Batman

[Gemmysaur]

Bucky Barnes

vs

Bruce Banner


Scenario: Thanos completed the Infinity Gauntlet ahead of scheduled and decided to goof around. He sent Bucky to Gotham under a guise of a mission given by Cap to kill a certain bat-themed vigilante. Batman noticed the metal-armed assassin is forcing him out for a fight by hurting innocents. Batman then decides to engage.

Round 1: Base Batman

- Standard Equipment for both

Round 2: Armored Batman

- Batman gets the Bat Armor while Bucky gets to borrow Cap's shield

 

[Gwynbleiddd]

Round 1: Probably Bucky due to his metal arm and probably superior speed.

Round 2:I'm pretty sure Cap's shiled can pierce Batman's armor

Note: I haven't seen Batman Vs Superman

 

[GreatestSin]

R1 goes to bucky, batman is really good but the really really durable arm will make it really really hard for batman, but this will still be a really really close match...

R2 goes to batman, the armor allowed him to survive several throws through walls, he may have less speed but weapon and gadgets plus enhanced strength would mostlikely even allow the destruction of the cyborg-arm after several hits ^_^

 

[Legion350]

R1 Bucky is just too fast, strong and durable for Batman. R2 Bucky also takes this because he has multiple items that allow him to match Batman(Shield, and Arm).Plus he is just plain faster.

 

[Bruce_Reb]

R1 is probably a 50-50. Batman's gadgets can be a real bitch. R2 is a sure win for batman.

 

[SonicWizard]

Hmmm. DCEU with suit got attacked by non-weakned Sups at beginning of battle and didn't die. That is one impressive feat. And it's not like Cap has the patriotic shield. It's Bucky. "0h! Bucky used C@p sh&ild and be@t up Ir0n M@n!" For 2 seconds.

 

[Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan]

Winter Soldier.

 

[Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan]

hands down

 

[Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan]

Stronger and faster and more durable. I don't care Batman's intelligent he got manipulated anyway. And also the Super Soldier Serum makes people clever too. The Grappling Hook can't grapple Cap's shield. And Bucky is pretty used with Cap's shield.

 

[Bruce_Reb]

You do realize the second matchup is a fat AP win for Batman, don't you?

 

[HellFire707]

You do realize the second matchup is a fat AP win for Batman, don't you?

Well, the armor should weigh and slow him down. Speed and reflexes are more important in a battle than most people realize.

 

[Gargoyle_1]

Bruce banner?

 

[HellFire707]

Lol, I noticed that too, I was like, "Banner? Wtf?"

 

[Gemmysaur]

And I thought no one would ever notice that. Good eyes guys.

EDIT

R1

Bucky - Gwyn Gsin GKS77

Bats -

Inconclusive - Bruce Reb

- - -

R2

Bucky - Gwyn GKS77

Bats - Gsn

Inconclusive -

- - -

No reasoning - Bruce Reb

Need clarification - Spino75dino

- - -

On another note, do you guys think I should remove round 2 entirely? It's only now that I saw it as being Likely Building level durability (though I question its reasoning).

Oh, and this thread is a year old, almost, so I should probably redo this anyway.

 

[Colonel_Krukov]

Round 1 to Bucky via speed

Round 2 for me is Inconclusive. Bucky is faster but that beasty bat-armour is a bit too durable for Bucky to bypass.

 

[Bruce_Reb]

R1 - Bucky. Reasoning: They seem to be even except for the fact that Bucky is much faster, so my vote goes to him.

R2 - Batman. Reasoning: Durabilty, there's no way Bucky can breach his armor. Batman is great strategist, he'd find a way to hit Bucky straight on with time, and one blow is all he really needs.

 

[Byakuya_"Senbonzakura"_Kuchiki]

R1: Bucky wins because he's faster thus giving him the advantage.

R2: Batman would win because his armor is pretty durable and Bucky will have a very hard time trying his best to even scratch it.

 

[Dinobot1996]

R1: Winter Soldier takes the majority through superior speed and strength with his metal arm, as well as his skill with ranged weaponry that will give Batman an extremely difficult time, even with his costume being resistant to bullets.

R2: Despite his inferior speed, Batman should take this through durability. Bucky can put up a good fight, but all he could do is use the shield to try to chip away at Batman's armor while blocking attacks, while if Bruce gets in even a single solid hit, the Winter Soldier lacks the durability to shrug it off.

 

[Hithere17]

R1 goes to Bucky. Too fast, strong, and any of his winter soldier gear would be able put Bruce down. R2 still goes to Bucky. cap was able to pierce quinjets, ultron, and iron mans armor with the shield, put that in buckys arm and he breaks that bat armor easily

 

[Bruce_Reb]

Likely PIS?

 

[Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan]

Both rounds go to Bucky, he's a super soldier, he breaks that armour easily with a vibranium shield

 

[Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan]

@Gemmysaur Why do I need clarification?

 

[Bruce_Reb]

"he's a super soldier" says as little as "he's batman".

 

[Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan]

I'm not saying "He's Bucky", idiot.

 

[CrackerVolley]

Speaking about this, he's Bruce Wyane, not Bruce Banner

 

[Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan]

Lol ikr?

 

[Bruce_Reb]

Save yourself the foul language, please.

 

[Spinosaurus75DinosaurFan]

?

 

[SonicWizard]

Um, dudes? Bats looks like he's destroying Darksied Forces left and right in the Justice League trailers. That's something.

 

[Byakuya_"Senbonzakura"_Kuchiki]

^Wait for the movie to show then we'll see more clarifications.

 

[Gemmysaur]

Current Tally:

R1

Bucky (8) - Gwyn, Gsin, GKS77, Kru, Bruce Reb, Senbon Byakuya, Dinobot, Hithere

Bats (0)

R2

Bucky (3) - Gwyn, GKS77, Hithere

Bats (4) - Gsn, Bruce Reb, Senbon Byakuya, Dinobot

Inconclusive (1) - Kru

So... considering this has been under the radar for a month + 1 day, I think it's safe to add R1. R2 though, while a better fight than R1 imo, is still too divided.

Yeah. I think this should be closed now, so I will. Ha.