Ladybug Becomes 2-A!

[Suigetsuhyugs]

The idea that Gimmi's wish "destroys and recreates everything" while leaving important moments, like Marinette becoming Ladybug untouched just doesn’t add up. If the wish can selectively erase certain events but preserve others, we can seriously question how it actually functions? Also, after Marinette prevents the supervillain from using the wish, every window in the Burrow that disappeared magically reappears. This implies that those timelines were not permanently erased but rather temporarily altered. If that’s the case, it obviously contradicts the idea that Bunnyx’s past could be recreated while leaving her unaffected. If the wish truly altered reality, it should impact all aspects of time including Bunnyx’s existence making the situation inherently inconsistent.

Everything is destroyed but some moments are recreated the same like what happened when Gabriel wished, even Marinette still remembers Gabriel as a villain. Bunnix's past up until the moment of the wish was recreated all the same which means bunnix would have still be Alix but her future would be recreated in a different way than before because of the wish so her future selfs were destroyed.

 

[Hixkaryana]

Everything is destroyed but some moments are recreated the same like what happened when Gabriel wished, even Marinette still remembers Gabriel as a villain. Bunnix's past up until the moment of the wish was recreated all the same which means bunnix would have still be Alix but her future would be recreated in a different way than before because of the wish so her future selfs were destroyed.

But that still raises a big inconsistency. If her past was unchanged and she remained the same, how do we explain the erasure of her future versions?
The fact that her older selves were destroyed means that something in the timeline must have shifted, even if her past stayed intact. If the wish truly didn’t change anything about her, then her future versions shouldn't have been affected. Her future versions clearly know what's going on and have been through the exact same thing as Alix, it doesn't make sense for them to randomly disappear.

So either Bunnyx’s past was perfectly recreated without any changes, which means her future selves should still exist, or the timeline was altered in a way that caused her future versions to be erased, which isn't true because they know exactly what's going on. Leaving us with only the first option making her future versions disappearing a big big big inconsistency.

 

[Suigetsuhyugs]

But that still raises a big inconsistency. If her past was unchanged and she remained the same, how do we explain the erasure of her future versions?
The fact that her older selves were destroyed means that something in the timeline must have shifted, even if her past stayed intact. If the wish truly didn’t change anything about her, then her future versions shouldn't have been affected. Her future versions clearly know what's going on and have been through the exact same thing as Alix, it doesn't make sense for them to randomly disappear.

So either Bunnyx’s past was perfectly recreated without any changes, which means her future selves should still exist, or the timeline was altered in a way that caused her future versions to be erased, which isn't true because they know exactly what's going on. Leaving us with only the first option making her future versions disappearing a big big big inconsistency.

Her past wasn't changed but her present and future likely were changed maybe Alix would have died at some point before becoming adult alix making it so her 2 future selfs would be erased.
Her future selfs know that 15yo Alix was gonna prevent that wish from happening so they were temporarily erased while the wish was yet to came fully into effect

 

[Ar1216789]

Whats the conclusion on the scaling? Is it 2-A or 2-B?