gildedguy vs garou (8-6-0)

[WeeklyBattles]

Cal made it 8-5

 

[Milly_Rocking_Bandit]

All of GG's votes are invalid.

 

[Dienomite22]

Cal's reasonings were countered

 

[KGiffoni]

All of GG's votes are invalid.

I partially agree. While there are valid reasons for one to think GG takes this, i think lots of good arguments for Garou are being ignored.

 

[Milly_Rocking_Bandit]

No, nothing GG has gets past Analytical Prediction+Instinctive Reaction, something I've continuously brought up. Logically, it's 0-5.

 

[Bob8999]

dude this thing is 409 posts long, threads have a max of 500 posts, we need to get to grace before then the best chance of that is if it remains 7-5. (unless two more people come and vote for garou.)

 

[WeeklyBattles]

Grace has already passed, it started yesterday morning with cal's vote.

 

[KGiffoni]

I don't see any sword deflection, or deflection at all (all I saw was dodging), especially given he outpowered those dudes as opposed to the inverse happening here.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bjqVvobFf8 (3:22)

Garou outpowered people who could one-shot him before, 3x ain't that of a gap.

 

[GyroNutz]

Garou FRA

 

[Bob8999]

counted

and im not counting cal´s because his reasons have been countered, rendering them null and void and i cant count votes without reasons.

 

[KGiffoni]

I'll write a little resume with the conclusions on the advantages of each character here just so people can keep up with the thread without having to read more than 400 comments. If there's anything i'm forgetting, let me know and i'll add it right away.

Garou:

Ôù╝ Superior Reactive Evolution and Rage Power;

Ôù╝ Analytical Prediction and Instinctive Reaction;

Ôù╝ Attack Reflection via WSRSF;

Ôù╝ Comparable H2H experience;

Ôù╝ Information analysis;

Ôù╝ Regenerationn (Low-Mid);

Ôù╝ Experience dealing with blade users (Royal Ripper, Atomic Samurai, Spring Mustachio, etc);

Ôù╝ Experience dealing with bullet hell (Orochi, Golden Ball, Atomic Samurai, Death Gatling);

Ôù╝ Stamina.

Gildedguy:

Ôù╝ Has his own RE that, while inferior, also has a good pace;

Ôù╝ Comparable H2H experience generally;

Ôù╝ 1.5x AP advantage;

Ôù╝ His durability is above his AP;

Ôù╝ Range;

Ôù╝ Blade user;

Ôù╝ Danmaku user.

 

[GyroNutz]

Gilded scales to 310 megatons, Garou scales to 203. So Gilded doesn't have a 3x AP advantage.

Also weakened Garou vs Death Gatling is probably relevant in terms of dealing with danmaku.

 

[KGiffoni]

I thought Garou only scaled to 100 because the 200 megatons feat was performed by Bang and Bomb together. About Death Gatling, i'll add that in.

 

[GyroNutz]

It was also stated that both Bang and Bomb stood no chance against EC

Because of Elder Centipede's size and ability to molt. When Bang and Bomb were hit by a direct attack from Elder Centipede, they were generally fine after it. Not to mention that Bang and Bomb used a more powerful variant of the move on Rover and were unharmed by the recoil, Garou took several point blank shots from Rover before adapting further and that he could harm and overpower Darkshine who was unharmed by Bang's attacks after adapting further.

 

[KGiffoni]

I see. Guess it's only an 1.5x AP advantage then.

 

[WeeklyBattles]

Closing. If you have any issue with it then take it to the removal board.