- 11,099
- 4,323
@KLOL506 There's still a bit less than 12 hours till lockdown.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Freezing and Temperature Feats Continued
- Thread starter DarkDragonMedeus
- Start date
- Status
- 31,638
- 34,661
- Thread starter
- #443
I agree, we perhaps might need to close the thread before the lock down given we got over 450+ posts and wait till after the move before looking over verses.
It was agreed that while Force and Heat are indeed two different things, it's case by case on verses treating them. But as me, DontTalk, and Elizhaa said, same energy sources should make them scale generally. Where as them just being different military weapons carried by regular people with no notable supernatural powers are examples of them being separate based on what Ugarik, Dargoo, and even myself said on that matter.
It was agreed that while Force and Heat are indeed two different things, it's case by case on verses treating them. But as me, DontTalk, and Elizhaa said, same energy sources should make them scale generally. Where as them just being different military weapons carried by regular people with no notable supernatural powers are examples of them being separate based on what Ugarik, Dargoo, and even myself said on that matter.
- 31,638
- 34,661
- Thread starter
- #445
My PC kind of crashed, when I had a few paragraphs written. So my wording might be off given I forgot exactly what I wrote.
I don't think that was DontTalk that wanted to continue discussing it, but rather he agreed that the natural standard is techniques under the same context scale under each other whether it's a magic spell or a Ki technique. And same with tanking said spells or Ki attacks. That was more or less Dargoo who seemed to want to clarify other things.
He moved to my wall, but we seem confused on what the votes are about. He seems to think we misunderstand each other on what the votes are about. DontTalkDT did bring up scaling Heat manipulation feats to striking strength being a different story under certain circumstances. He also said something about not going to debate until "We agree on what we're voting Yay and Nay on" or something along the lines.
I don't think that was DontTalk that wanted to continue discussing it, but rather he agreed that the natural standard is techniques under the same context scale under each other whether it's a magic spell or a Ki technique. And same with tanking said spells or Ki attacks. That was more or less Dargoo who seemed to want to clarify other things.
He moved to my wall, but we seem confused on what the votes are about. He seems to think we misunderstand each other on what the votes are about. DontTalkDT did bring up scaling Heat manipulation feats to striking strength being a different story under certain circumstances. He also said something about not going to debate until "We agree on what we're voting Yay and Nay on" or something along the lines.
- 168,521
- 77,242
No. Sorry. It depends on how quickly everybody involved get the conversion process done, and if we manage to handle moving everybody in this community to their new accounts without significant problems.
We also likely need to extend the partial lockdown some time afterwards, to properly focus on updating all of the versus thread links.
We also likely need to extend the partial lockdown some time afterwards, to properly focus on updating all of the versus thread links.
- 31,638
- 34,661
- Thread starter
- #452
Seems best to wait for the Forum move.
- 648
- 97
Alright I was having a conversatio with KLOL506. So apparently DDM's proposal would partly mean that ability to bring about a change in energy (which we agreed is the best interpretation of freezing) scales to striking strength?
If this is true could someone explain how this works? I don't get how you can logically go from "character can make x change in energy in one object (remember, energy goes somewhere else so it's a net zero change if you look at the big picture)" to "character can use x energy in an attack."
If this is true could someone explain how this works? I don't get how you can logically go from "character can make x change in energy in one object (remember, energy goes somewhere else so it's a net zero change if you look at the big picture)" to "character can use x energy in an attack."
- 10,939
- 12,428
Considering that supernatural powers usually use a separate power source from physical strength, I personally see no reason to scale supernatural AP to physical AP. (Unless there are supporting information, of course)
Like, completely independent of the entire freezing debate. Pretty sure we never did that for any kind of magic.
Not that I know whether or not that was actually proposed, btw.
Like, completely independent of the entire freezing debate. Pretty sure we never did that for any kind of magic.
Not that I know whether or not that was actually proposed, btw.
- 11,099
- 4,323
I think scaling supernatural to physical AP should only be when the physical strikes are based on a magical power source, such as chi or the Force in Star Wars.
Or when characters tank each other's powers physically.
Or when characters tank each other's powers physically.
- 648
- 97
Well yeah I think that's kinda obvious. But my question was about something else.
If a character is shown to displace 8.35 gigatons of tnt equivalent energy(KLOL and I agreed that "displacement", or directly moving the energy itself rather than providing a counteracting force to the particles is the best interpretation of freezing) why do we assume that they can also produce 8.35 gigatons of tnt equivalent and use it in an attack?
If a character is shown to displace 8.35 gigatons of tnt equivalent energy(KLOL and I agreed that "displacement", or directly moving the energy itself rather than providing a counteracting force to the particles is the best interpretation of freezing) why do we assume that they can also produce 8.35 gigatons of tnt equivalent and use it in an attack?
- 9,978
- 2,016
More than simply sharing the same source of power, it should also accounts for the difficulty of the technique. Just cuz a magic blast uses the same source of energy that the massive aoe attack doesn't mean it scale if the last attack consume more supply.
- 648
- 97
But "displacing" energy and "producing" energy arent linearly related at all, not even when it comes to chi, chakra, mana etc. It could take 10 mana to disperse 10 gigatons of energy but also take 10 mana to create a Building level explosion. Nothing implies otherwise, so Occam's razor says we should discard it (not completely, only in terms of quantifying striking strength) instead of assigning some arbitrary value that nothing, not even fiction implies.KLOL506 said:
- 15,637
- 5,392
^DarkDragonMedeus said:
Guys, I'd rather whatever posts are made here are readable when the forum move is done instead of us having a massive debate but have no way of actually going over it.
- 31,638
- 34,661
- Thread starter
- #470
I'm with DontTalk that it's not exactly a default. More or less, abilities done using Supernatural powers scale to other supernatural powers of the same source though. However, I already mentioned examples where plenty of verses due scale magic to striking strength. Such as pretty much every single JRPG, because they have a Tier via a supernatural feat, they can trade blows with magic regardless of spell; hence durability scales. And trade blows via punching, or swinging swords at each other. And it's not like the Black Mage is leagues above the Warrior power level wise. As for "Healing drains energy", that's more or less a common weakness rather than part of the scaling is that characters can heal or revive, but doing so drains stamina.
Also, I do agree with Dargoo with this though. That we shouldn't waste the rest of our posts. However, I do need to note that our most recent posts are probably getting hakai'd anyway, and that even if the thread gets emptied out, the thread will still successfully move and we could always link this thread to any new ones.
Also, I do agree with Dargoo with this though. That we shouldn't waste the rest of our posts. However, I do need to note that our most recent posts are probably getting hakai'd anyway, and that even if the thread gets emptied out, the thread will still successfully move and we could always link this thread to any new ones.
- 168,521
- 77,242
For the record, I agree with Spino.
This won't be saved to the new forum though, so it is the wrong time for standard practice revisions right now.
However, I would appreciate if somebody remembers to bring this up later.
This won't be saved to the new forum though, so it is the wrong time for standard practice revisions right now.
However, I would appreciate if somebody remembers to bring this up later.
Agnaa
VS Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
Translation Helper
Human Resources
Gold Supporter
- 15,676
- 14,054
Zark heavily disagrees with including heat separately in AP/Dura, and thinks it should be relegated to the P&A section.
Since this seems very different from what was planned to be talked about after the forum move, I figured I'd bring it up now. Does anyone know who has agreed to listing them in AP/Dura?
Since this seems very different from what was planned to be talked about after the forum move, I figured I'd bring it up now. Does anyone know who has agreed to listing them in AP/Dura?
- 11,099
- 4,323
Welp, it was pretty much near-unanimously agreed. Don't recall anyone disagreeing with that in the previous threads, albeit I was admittedly not a big part of it.
Agnaa
VS Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
Translation Helper
Human Resources
Gold Supporter
- 15,676
- 14,054
I don't remember it being disagreed with either.
But what should we do now that it's not so unanimous? Should "where do we place heat feats" simply be a question in one of the later threads?
But what should we do now that it's not so unanimous? Should "where do we place heat feats" simply be a question in one of the later threads?
Agnaa
VS Battles
Super Moderator
Administrator
Calculation Group
Translation Helper
Human Resources
Gold Supporter
- 15,676
- 14,054
Spino is also bringing up issues of how, since conduction would need to be accounted for, almost no heat feats would be over tier 8, and no heat feats would scale to their full value when tanked. Making the idea of separating them a lot more dicey, imo.
On Discord.
EDIT: AKM Sama seems to disagree with separating heat/force, but has missed thees threads until now. Looks like we'll really need to be consulting staff more actively about these revisions, and they're probably not as close as concluding as they seemed.
On Discord.
EDIT: AKM Sama seems to disagree with separating heat/force, but has missed thees threads until now. Looks like we'll really need to be consulting staff more actively about these revisions, and they're probably not as close as concluding as they seemed.
- Status
