- 1,159
- 726
to be honest even if you think their stars are just red dwarf stars that still makes Namek extremely huge especially for a rocky planet. even attempting to destroy it would take way too much energy
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Dragon Ball Super Discussion Thread 100
- Thread starter Warren_Valion
- Start date
- 29,751
- 24,740
Who knows, maybe they're three tiny suns with weak gravity.
- 1,159
- 726
okay this is actually surprisingly consistent lmao
- 1,159
- 726
no you need a minimum amount of gravity to become a star or else they’d be what we call “brown dwarfs” or “super-jupiter” type planets. it’s actually impossible for them to be smaller than a red dwarf star unless it’s stated somewhere
and if we assume they’re at least red dwarf stars (doesn’t look like it but eh) then Namek is extremely large by that measure
- 1,311
- 995
When Super shenron brought back those erased, he also placed them back onto their universes, so it wasn't like a restorative do-over either
The combined gravitational force of 3 stars on the planet will need to be done first, also, GBE would be the more appropriate value of resisting being pulled apart by the suns iirc, not average density
Last edited:
- 1,159
- 726
IMO using a size approximation works better here since we already know it was an earth-like gravity
- 1,311
- 995
Well, judging by the fact that Bulma isn't baked upon standing on the surface, I am assuming the distance to the suns in the sky is at least the same as Earth to our sun, that may be useful
Killerdrone123
He/Him- 1,617
- 1,132
What do you guys think of these
- 231
- 140
That's kinda toooo big? 
It's fiction so
(it's doesn't matter)
It's fiction so
(it's doesn't matter)
- 10,300
- 5,145
I think it would be good, shown as it would give a good update to Dragon Ball based on facts shown within the work.
- 1,159
- 726
huh this is actually not bad but I feel like whoever did this didn’t have the scans that we had here to justify the size further but the conclusion seems about right to me. Eyeballing it I was thinking it could be around small star level GBE too although idk if we should use the manga or Kai version for busting it
- 1,159
- 726
it’s actually lowballed because normally you wouldn’t assume those stars to be red dwarf stars but instead sun-like main sequence/G-sequence stars. this is more so a conservative calc if anythingThat's kinda toooo big?
It's fiction so
- 9,844
- 3,371
I Mean, we don't use the Piccolo moon busting from kai, so ig we wouldn't use the namek bust as well
- 1,159
- 726
ngl that kinda sucks because the way we currently calc it we don’t even take into account minimum visual acuity
- 1,311
- 995
It's interesting, not sure this many calculation steps will be accepted tho, but then again, he didn't have as many shots of the planet
But tbh, in almost every shot, namek seems bigger than the stars around it
Kai is only used for time frame, actual feat uses the manga
- 1,159
- 726
Yeah I gotta say this is surprisingly consistent lmao
I guess we can use the timeframe for Kai then
- 1,159
- 726
pretty much makes dodoria’s statement about namek’s size a load of crap.
funny thing is even the low end of that calc is above Cell’s solar system busting calc and would probably push manga DBZ into 4-A
also if the size does get to around star sized then it might be worth doing some speed calcs too for the characters who traversed Namek
funny thing is even the low end of that calc is above Cell’s solar system busting calc and would probably push manga DBZ into 4-A
also if the size does get to around star sized then it might be worth doing some speed calcs too for the characters who traversed Namek
- 231
- 140
It will be a whole lot of mess if E of frieza saga, cell saga and buu saga are all at solar system level.
- 9,844
- 3,371
- 1,311
- 995
Not exactly, he just said it wasn't too big a planet iirc, not that it was small, he could've seen bigger ones, planet Vegeta for example was called enormous in the broly novelization that null posted in the Vegeta downgrade attempt. It's definitely larger than an average one tho
Meh, that calc would not be accepted here tbh, the speed of the blast there was calced at ftl (1.3E9m/s), KE wouldn't work
Maybe so
- 29,751
- 24,740
I'm sure there are better ways we could be improving the profiles.
- 1,159
- 726
unironically the only solution to get out of this
- 1,311
- 995
Can you recheck this thread and see if you changed your mind about body control?
- 1,159
- 726
pretty sure we could still use relativistic KE with the manga version
- 4,147
- 4,849
Who needs improved profiles when you can inflate the stats
- 231
- 140
Which stuff is inflated?
- 1,311
- 995
Unless they got the speed directly from the manga itself and it was relativistic, won't be allowed either
Though I found this calc attempting to find the size of namek
Dragon Ball - Namek Size
vsbattles.fandom.com
- 1,159
- 726
if you used the manga version for the size of the explosion and the time frame from Kai I’m pretty sure it comes out to relativistic
on that note we might actually get a higher value given the sheer number of scans we have to justify the size too. 4-B SSJ Goku doesn’t sound bad
- 1,311
- 995
Do we even have a manga Namek explosion calc? I mean, no one has definitely made an accepted calculation of its size alone let alone the manga destruction
- 29,751
- 24,740
I see. I guess I'm fine with Limited Resurrection then as long as the conditions are specified in the justification.
- 1,311
- 995
Wrong thread?
ReaperAndBlues
He/Him- 516
- 445
I hope limited res gets accepted because that really helps my EG Goku CRT
ReaperAndBlues
He/Him- 516
- 445
Speaking of actually, what are your thoughts on Extraordinary Genius in combat for Goku Damage?
- 231
- 140
Hmm i dont know about damage, cos he mostly hold back his punches. So uh? Genius?
- 1,159
- 726
i don’t think we do because no one really cared to but with this it might warrant a calc too now. 4-B SSJ Goku is too good to pass up
- 231
- 140
- 29,751
- 24,740
Whoops, lol.
- 1,311
- 995
You are reaaaaaaalllllyyyyyyy hopeful for this aren't ya?
ReaperAndBlues
He/Him- 516
- 445
I forgot the comma after Goku, d'oh
Similar threads
