speedster352
He/Him- 17,493
- 1,786
Didn't byashura counter this? We have more than enough evidence that they created stars
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
CRT NNT
- Thread starter Zelas
- Start date
- Status
Rabbit2002
She/Her- 2,623
- 1,401
Create a realm doesn't mean universe, realm is just a place, even pocket dimension can refer as realm
- 13,015
- 20,659
It’s called that because we don’t know that the stars and such are created by sheer power. Pocket Reality Manipulation is an ability for a reason
But, the 5-B stuff is concrete enough. So my proposition is to replace the High 4-C with 5-B
- 18,434
- 18,416
Honestly, 4-B Momoshiki isn't anywhere near as ridiculous as this.
- 13,015
- 20,659
Me and the boys on our way to make Dorothy’s Glamour World High 3-A via her creating it via Pocket Reality Manipulation and being stated to be infinite in size
- 4,864
- 4,390
That's why it's agreed that it doesn't scale to their stats at all, holy. You keep on with this it's "vague" when there's deadass not vague, you keep pushing the narrative that they didn't create the celestial objects in their realms and etc and every time you've failed to prove your assertion, please just stop because sorry to say this but it's hella annoying.
1. Can you prove that they aren't referring to actual dimensions because given the evidence, it's heavily hinted to be in a separate realm.
2. That's why it's via creation because it doesn't scale to their stats and because we don't know what methods they used other than the statement of their creation. It's killing 2 birds with a stone.
3."how on earth are we scaling the guys who get killed by country nuking calcs to creating stars" Because it doesn't scale to their stats.
4. "when they have not shown the capability to do this in any form even once" They did literally in what we're talking about.
Sure make a crt because 4-B Momoshiki is irrelevant in this discussion
- 43
- 25
but the world of humans is the world on which we live the earth and the 7ds are on the earth in the past so a universe but also chaos has created the world from nothingness nothingness is the absence of something so there was nothing before chaos created the universe so if there was nothing it must have created the stars the moon and the sun by itself since before there was nothing at all
- 15,423
- 15,343
No... No you don't, these places are called worlds and realms, which don't specify size at all, they literally just refer to places, but even then, I would be willing to accept they are planets, but in general they could just be planets in the same Solar System. We don't have confirmed sizes for what exactly refers to the Demon World and Goddess Realm, for all we know, they went to another dimension and created civilizations, that's what it means by worlds and realms, maybe they created entire dimensions, who knows, we certainly don't have a given timeframe, a given way they made them, a certain way they happened. We have little to no info in regard to these feats. Yet instead of just not using them due to the extreme vagueness and not to mention the sheer outlierish nature of the feats, we just give them the High 4-C ratings and call it a day. Why not make Dorothy from BC High 3-A, why not make the Eclipse Celestial Spirit King 4-B to Low 2-C, why not make EMIYA High 3-A, why not make Momoshiki 4-B...
THE BURDEN OF PROOF IS ON YOU, NOT ME
You need to prove that these things actually happened, which you can't
- 13,015
- 20,659
“We aren’t scaling that to their stats” Then we shouldn’t be using Chaos’ “I’ll destroy anything with a form” quote because that too is really vague
Also, you need to actually prove the positive before telling Mitch to prove the negative. The burden of proof is on you
Rabbit2002
She/Her- 2,623
- 1,401
world of human can refer as earth, Chaos was born in the universe so how can he create the entire universe ?
- 4,864
- 4,390
Yes the means of the creation is unknown which was agreed upon. That's the only vague thing about but since it's basically a basic creation feat, it was left at via creation because
1. We don't know the method of creation
2. It wouldn't scale to their statistics
Like Just 5-B? or 5-B via___?
- 13,015
- 20,659
If we don’t know the method, it shouldn’t even have a tier. That’s just Pocket Reality Manipulation until we actually know the means
- 4,864
- 4,390
That's fine i already agreed to it being vague before
Which I already did previously and he conceded to it. Now what's left for him is his burden
- 13,015
- 20,659
Where did this happen? I don’t see that anywhere
- 43
- 25
yes the human world refers to the planet but not all the time and I demonstrated that it was one more planet a planet with multiple stars a moon and a sun would it be a simple planet? lol and chaos was not born in the universe if so prove it myself even if he was not born in the universe we have no information on the creation of chaos except for the hyperbole of the fact that he comes from the old stars and why he does not create the entire universe when it is explicitly said that he created the world from nothing
- 4,864
- 4,390
In this thread in which he had no contentions with
- 4,864
- 4,390
He's deadass stated to be born from Ancient stars...
PrinceofPein
Username Only- 9,041
- 5,970
I know the intention, I dont think it in anyway means a single thought
Since we literally have a scan saying the order in which the races were created
- 13,015
- 20,659
“World” is the vaguest word that can be used for something like this
Rabbit2002
She/Her- 2,623
- 1,401
Created the world from nothing doesn't mean universe
- 13,015
- 20,659
I read through all the pages you discussed this (pages 6-8) and no, Mitch had plenty of contentions and was just randomly ignored later on and the High 4-C rating just stayed applied because of that. I think the CRT’s shift to focus on the High 6-C stuff led to the High 4-C stuff being forgotten about
- 43
- 25
Chaos being born by Stars is a Rumour. Merlin's Credibility >a Rumour and One is a legend that's why that's what merlin heard when she was little, basically merlin heard one of the wise men of the city tell a story by port to chaos, would have to prove that the wise man is a good source also It says that chaos was bron among ancient star however the top proves that claim came from two wiseman " gossiping ”about chaos meaning they were just sprouting stories meaning it’s unreliable. This would mean my clam is more reliable because it comes from merlin who studied chaos for 3000 years meaning Merlin > the wiseman
- 43
- 25
world does not refer to the planet and I showed that it was not just a planet
Rabbit2002
She/Her- 2,623
- 1,401
You guy say Chaos did not born in the universe and the legend was wrong but there are no prove about that
If you prove it, then Chaos created the world was wrong, too
If you prove it, then Chaos created the world was wrong, too
PrinceofPein
Username Only- 9,041
- 5,970
and dude, did you just call a narration written on the manga panel a rumour? lol that narration credibility >>>>> any character in the verse
And "He came from an ancient star and created the world from nothing" might as well mean life and not planets btw, just saying, there is not statement of him creating the planets or stars like people are saying
- 4,864
- 4,390
How exactly was it ignored later? he was told to bring his contentions to that thread (just for the context behind his problems with it), Then it was Me vs Him which i tried my best to reply to his messages. I don't see how it was ignored, Infact he just stopped replying after I replied to him
- 43
- 25
I never said that creating a world from nothing would amount to a fair universe that in the world that chaos created from nothing there are multiple stars a moon and a sun a planet would be big enough to have all that? no so it would be a universe and I also said that the 7ds live on earth so the human world is indeed a universe
Lugh_Tuathe_Dé
He/Him- 3,706
- 2,077
I'm surprised that this thing is still open
- 4,864
- 4,390
What is stated in the narrative> your headcanon. Chaos is born in our universe until proven otherwise
- 13,015
- 20,659
Still doesn’t mean he didn’t have contentions. That’s a misconstrued statement
Rabbit2002
She/Her- 2,623
- 1,401
any scan the world chaos create contain stars ?
- 43
- 25
it is clearly said in the panel that it is a rumor and since when credibility > each character in the verse then you have no argument to say that he comes from the old stars lol
- 4,864
- 4,390
Where exactly did i say he didn't have contentions?
Rabbit2002
She/Her- 2,623
- 1,401
So there is no agrument say that he created the world ?
PrinceofPein
Username Only- 9,041
- 5,970
like i said a narration of that has more credibility than any character
And luckily for us no character said otheewise to the rumour, in fact they all supported
- 13,015
- 20,659
Right here @Majinere566
PrinceofPein
Username Only- 9,041
- 5,970
This thread is getting clustered, what are the new propositions so we can know what we are arguing
- 43
- 25
wtf???? I'm debunking the fact that he was born from the old stars because it's hyperbole and you're telling me it's a headcannon you don't even counter my argument of no longer an old man in a village say chaos is born of the ancient stars merlin studied for 3000 years and 3000 years later merlin contradict the old man saying that it was chaos that created the world from nothing btw it's a legend you can't say that this legend is true lol
- 4,864
- 4,390
- Status
