- 11,195
- 17,348
So, coming off of the massive speed CRT that Black Clover just had, this CRT is more on the miscellaneous side of things. There are four revisions I'm gonna talk about here, so with that said, here we go.
Noelle's Accelerated Development
Noelle's Accelerated Development in this fight is actually really good. Looking at the start of the fight, we see that at the start of the fight, Base Vanica effortlessly negates Valkyrie Dress Noelle's Sea Dragon's Roar. This gap in power is also why Noelle needed the help of Loropechika's Mana Zone to cut Vanica's power in half and boost her own power. But then, after Vanica uses 70% of her Devil Power, Decaying World activates, and Mana Zone is destroyed. Yet, even then, Noelle is able to withstand several stab wounds (even if she evaded lethal wounds, it's notable that she withstood those hits to begin with) from 70% Vanica's attacks and even managed to stab her. In fact, it's enough that Vanica bleeds, which even shocks her.
Now, even with this Accelerated Development, Noelle is still weaker than 70% Vanica. Her Point-Blank Sea Dragon's Roar gets countered by Vanica's Red Beast. That said, this should be cause for Noelle to downscale to baseline High 6-B (100 teratons), given she was able to withstand several hits, evade her attacks enough to dodge lethal wounds (so she'd also somewhat scale in speed), and stab her enough to make her bleed, shocking her.
However, that's not the only Noelle revision I'll be discussing here...
Splitting Noelle's Keys
We really need to split Noelle's Post-Timeskip Key into the Heart Kingdom Joint Struggle Arc and the Spade Kingdom Raid Arc. Based on the changes I have just suggested, her Heart Kingdom Joint Struggle key would be as follows:
High 6-C, higher with Valkyrie Dress, up to High 6-B with Accelerated Development
Now comes the Spade Kingdom Raid Arc, which I believe should be as follows:
High 6-C, High 6-B with Valkyrie Dress, far higher with Spirit Dive
Notice the High 6-B Valkyrie Dress? Yeah, that's because Noelle's Valkyrie Dress becomes potent enough that 100% Vanica had to actively block (or I guess catch) Noelle's lance. Bear in mind that this same Vanica has the stamina to withstand stab wounds, so that's telling of Valkyrie Dress's strength. Not sure how much into High 6-B this should be, maybe we can downscale to baseline again. I don't know, but this 100% should be High 6-B.
Mimosa's Durability + Pre-Timeskip Noelle's AP and Durability
Mimosa's durability honestly sucks. Both keys should really have Unknown durability, and I say this because the justifications in their current state honestly suck. The justifications are "Survived a strike from Mars" (who is 8-A at the time) and "Survived the Dark Disciple's explosion"
The problem is: In both cases, she was one-shot by these attacks. Thus, her durability should not scale.
As for Noelle, her 8-A AP and durability is really unjustified. Both should be Unknown, because her only notable AP feats come from Sea Dragon's Roar and, like Mimosa, she was one-shot by Mars. She takes a hit from Solid in the Royal Knights Arc, but Solid's AP is Unknown at the time due to a lack of feats.
Sealed Licht's AP
So, as per the VS Battles Wiki combined attack standards, Sealed Licht's feat of blocking Asta and Yuno's attack isn't necessarily 2x their AP, because the attack was a physical one rather than a combination of their powers. The other two cases of combined attacks in Black Clover actively involve the two characters combining their powers (Yuno's Wind Magic + Asta's Anti-Magic, Noelle's Water Magic + Mimosa's Plant Magic), but not this one. So, Sealed Licht's AP would go down to:
At least 6-C, likely High 6-C
He'd be scaling above Black Asta and Spirit Dive Yuno individually in that fight between them, and the second part of his rating of course comes from his performance against Zagred being arguably better than that of Two-Horned Black Asta and Elf Spirit Dive Yuno.
That's everything I've got so... DISCUSS!
Noelle's Accelerated Development
Noelle's Accelerated Development in this fight is actually really good. Looking at the start of the fight, we see that at the start of the fight, Base Vanica effortlessly negates Valkyrie Dress Noelle's Sea Dragon's Roar. This gap in power is also why Noelle needed the help of Loropechika's Mana Zone to cut Vanica's power in half and boost her own power. But then, after Vanica uses 70% of her Devil Power, Decaying World activates, and Mana Zone is destroyed. Yet, even then, Noelle is able to withstand several stab wounds (even if she evaded lethal wounds, it's notable that she withstood those hits to begin with) from 70% Vanica's attacks and even managed to stab her. In fact, it's enough that Vanica bleeds, which even shocks her.
Now, even with this Accelerated Development, Noelle is still weaker than 70% Vanica. Her Point-Blank Sea Dragon's Roar gets countered by Vanica's Red Beast. That said, this should be cause for Noelle to downscale to baseline High 6-B (100 teratons), given she was able to withstand several hits, evade her attacks enough to dodge lethal wounds (so she'd also somewhat scale in speed), and stab her enough to make her bleed, shocking her.
However, that's not the only Noelle revision I'll be discussing here...
Splitting Noelle's Keys
We really need to split Noelle's Post-Timeskip Key into the Heart Kingdom Joint Struggle Arc and the Spade Kingdom Raid Arc. Based on the changes I have just suggested, her Heart Kingdom Joint Struggle key would be as follows:
High 6-C, higher with Valkyrie Dress, up to High 6-B with Accelerated Development
Now comes the Spade Kingdom Raid Arc, which I believe should be as follows:
High 6-C, High 6-B with Valkyrie Dress, far higher with Spirit Dive
Notice the High 6-B Valkyrie Dress? Yeah, that's because Noelle's Valkyrie Dress becomes potent enough that 100% Vanica had to actively block (or I guess catch) Noelle's lance. Bear in mind that this same Vanica has the stamina to withstand stab wounds, so that's telling of Valkyrie Dress's strength. Not sure how much into High 6-B this should be, maybe we can downscale to baseline again. I don't know, but this 100% should be High 6-B.
Mimosa's Durability + Pre-Timeskip Noelle's AP and Durability
Mimosa's durability honestly sucks. Both keys should really have Unknown durability, and I say this because the justifications in their current state honestly suck. The justifications are "Survived a strike from Mars" (who is 8-A at the time) and "Survived the Dark Disciple's explosion"
The problem is: In both cases, she was one-shot by these attacks. Thus, her durability should not scale.
As for Noelle, her 8-A AP and durability is really unjustified. Both should be Unknown, because her only notable AP feats come from Sea Dragon's Roar and, like Mimosa, she was one-shot by Mars. She takes a hit from Solid in the Royal Knights Arc, but Solid's AP is Unknown at the time due to a lack of feats.
Sealed Licht's AP
So, as per the VS Battles Wiki combined attack standards, Sealed Licht's feat of blocking Asta and Yuno's attack isn't necessarily 2x their AP, because the attack was a physical one rather than a combination of their powers. The other two cases of combined attacks in Black Clover actively involve the two characters combining their powers (Yuno's Wind Magic + Asta's Anti-Magic, Noelle's Water Magic + Mimosa's Plant Magic), but not this one. So, Sealed Licht's AP would go down to:
At least 6-C, likely High 6-C
He'd be scaling above Black Asta and Spirit Dive Yuno individually in that fight between them, and the second part of his rating of course comes from his performance against Zagred being arguably better than that of Two-Horned Black Asta and Elf Spirit Dive Yuno.
That's everything I've got so... DISCUSS!
