- 3,557
- 639
Pokemon League Rules
Ash: Charizard, Pikachu, Sceptile, Heracross, Krookadile, Snorlax
Red: Saur, Pika, Poli, Aero, Vee, Snor
Current Votes
Ash- 4
Red- 6
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Ash vs Red (Adventures)
- Thread starter SuperKamiNappa
- Start date
-
- Tags
- pokémon
- Status
Pokemon League Rules
Ash: Charizard, Pikachu, Sceptile, Heracross, Krookadile, Snorlax
Red: Saur, Pika, Poli, Aero, Vee, Snor
Current Votes
Ash- 4
Red- 6
- 9,684
- 8,232
Hmm, Ash should take this
- 750
- 44
Pokémon in the anime have MUCH better feats than their game/manga counterparts so Imma go with Ash.
Also, Ash is superhuman so he'd likely just rip Red's head off.
Also, Ash is superhuman so he'd likely just rip Red's head off.
- 783
- 132
Why are you giving Red a weak as hell team.
Anyways, Ash wins this because you gape him like his strongest possible team and not Red his.
Their Pikas are about equal (I believe Red's is slightly stronger though), but you gape Ash his Zard who beat Articuno, Sceptile who beat Darkrai, and 3 other bulky Pokémon he has that have taen way more punishment than they should ever have.
Anyways, Ash wins this because you gape him like his strongest possible team and not Red his.
Their Pikas are about equal (I believe Red's is slightly stronger though), but you gape Ash his Zard who beat Articuno, Sceptile who beat Darkrai, and 3 other bulky Pokémon he has that have taen way more punishment than they should ever have.
- 3,557
- 639
- Thread starter
- #6
This is Manga Red not Game Red, he only has 7 main Pokemon and chose a team that wouldn't have 2 water typesPikachu942 said:
- 63
- 0
Obviously Ash if we go by team strength
- 783
- 132
This is Manga Red not Game Red, he only has 7 main Pokemon and chose a team that wouldn't have 2 water types
He had Mewtwo & Articuno in the manga...I read it, I know. Red's got a strong-ass team if you give him his strongest but this team isn't gonna beat Ash.
He had Mewtwo & Articuno in the manga...I read it, I know. Red's got a strong-ass team if you give him his strongest but this team isn't gonna beat Ash.
- 9,684
- 8,232
Sheoth said:
Ash has more experince fighting all different types of trainers though, from Kanto to Kalos, while red just trains in the mountains
- 1,629
- 143
Ash has more experince fighting all different types of trainers though, from Kanto to Kalos, while red just trains in the mountains
Ash may have fought a diverse number of trainers, but he certainly has never shown to have learned anything from it.
Red has fought plenty of different trainers and legendaries as well, and actually incorporates strategy into his battles.
- 11,582
- 548
Ash may have fought a diverse number of trainers, but he certainly has never shown to have learned anything from it.Sheoth said:
Red has fought plenty of different trainers and legendaries as well, and actually incorporates strategy into his battles.
So Red for me then?
- 9,684
- 8,232
Ash may have fought a diverse number of trainers, but he certainly has never shown to have learned anything from it.Sheoth said:
Red has fought plenty of different trainers and legendaries as well, and actually incorporates strategy into his battles.
Actually Ash does the same thing to......
- 9,684
- 8,232
Here's a Ash respect thread https://www.reddit.com/r/respectthreads/comments/3ogeya/respect_ash_ketchum_pokemon_anime/ go to the part that say's Strategy/Skill
- 1,629
- 143
Ash has more experince fighting all different types of trainers though, from Kanto to Kalos, while red just trains in the mountains Ash may have fought a diverse number of trainers, but he certainly has never shown to have learned anything from it.
Red has fought plenty of different trainers and legendaries as well, and actually incorporates strategy into his battles.
Actually Ash does the same thing to......
Not to nearly the same extent as Red does though. The battles in Adventures are waaaay more fast paced and crucial than the anime battles. You need to constantly be alert and ready to make a switch or you're screwed (especially considering that the trainers themselves can be targeted in battles). They are constantly ready for everything in Adventures and rarely make careless mistakes, so they will always have some kind of plan from the get go or quickly think one up on the spot...
And I've seen plenty of the Anime; it can't even be compare to the Adventures manga...
Red has fought plenty of different trainers and legendaries as well, and actually incorporates strategy into his battles.
Actually Ash does the same thing to......
Not to nearly the same extent as Red does though. The battles in Adventures are waaaay more fast paced and crucial than the anime battles. You need to constantly be alert and ready to make a switch or you're screwed (especially considering that the trainers themselves can be targeted in battles). They are constantly ready for everything in Adventures and rarely make careless mistakes, so they will always have some kind of plan from the get go or quickly think one up on the spot...
And I've seen plenty of the Anime; it can't even be compare to the Adventures manga...
- 750
- 44
What are the feats of Red's Pokémon? That will be what judges this. Ash's Pikachu is like multi city block level.
- 11,582
- 548
No, that would be his Charizard.Sheoth said:
- 11,582
- 548
@Sheoth: Well it has something to do with his Charizard being capable of going into it's X/Y form or something, idk.
- 783
- 132
Red's Pikachu is of a similar level to Ash's, if not slightly stronger IMO (he helped to damage a Kyogre armor thing in the Emerald arc which was as strong or stronger than the actual thing).HomestuckLover1 said:
Oh, and another about the Pikachu, his MegaVolt attack not only one-shotted all of Lance's Pokémon at once (all at least Town Level), but beat a LUGIA.
Red has other Pokémon he doesn't have here in the battle like Mewtwo who could compete with both Deoxys and Darkrai, and outsped a Hyper Beam.
I could get other feats but I'm lazy.
- 9,684
- 8,232
CrossverseCrisis said:
It's from Charizards fight with Articuno
- 11,582
- 548
Welp theres that, Sheoth.Pietro Maximoff said:
- 9,684
- 8,232
Red actually dosen't have Articuno nor Mewto anymore
- 783
- 132
Fair enough, but Red's Pikachu is really powerfulPietro Maximoff said:
- 1,629
- 143
It's from Charizards fight with Articuno
Oh thank god.
Well in that case, I would still give it to red, but with much greater difficulty. Ash's Charizard was beaten by a dusclops in the same season if I recall... So whether to take the victory as an outlier or the loss as PIS I am unsure.... But since red has dealt with legendaries on multiple occasions before (and won), and has the strategy factor, I will still go with him.
- 9,684
- 8,232
Ash fought a Entei,Daraki,Latios,Articuno, all three regis, and a mega lucario, all of those using skill and stragery as well
IMO though this is a Draw
IMO though this is a Draw
- 9,684
- 8,232
Though ash's pokemon are overrall stronger then reds though....
- 1,629
- 143
Out of all of these listed, the only ones involving any real strategy was Latios and darkrai, and even then, ash lost all of his Pokemon in both these fights. Most of these fights were basically him relying on his pokemons raw stats.Pietro Maximoff said:
The fights in Adventures use a lot of outside the box thinking and planning. I would give scans, but that would be a HUGE pain in the ass on my current device. But y'all can take my word for it I hope...
- 9,684
- 8,232
Sheoth said:
You sure? Because i've watched those fights multiple times and ash used skill and stragey in those fights unless i missed something......
- 1,629
- 143
The entei one was literally a beam struggle half the time.
In The articuno fight, ash took quite a few risks and was somewhat reliant once again on Charizards overall stats
Pretty sure ash only fought regice against Brandon in the show (could be wrong) which was full of "you can do it pikachu!" Moments
And Latios and darkrai were the most strategic the show has gotten..
The adventure fights however, are centered around being quick, adaptable and having the best strategy and plans before and during the actual fight. Based on general skills commanding Pokemon that were displayed, I would easily give it to Red.
In The articuno fight, ash took quite a few risks and was somewhat reliant once again on Charizards overall stats
Pretty sure ash only fought regice against Brandon in the show (could be wrong) which was full of "you can do it pikachu!" Moments
And Latios and darkrai were the most strategic the show has gotten..
The adventure fights however, are centered around being quick, adaptable and having the best strategy and plans before and during the actual fight. Based on general skills commanding Pokemon that were displayed, I would easily give it to Red.
- 9,684
- 8,232
Sheoth said:
My memory must be fogged up. becasue i don't remeber any of that.....
- 9,684
- 8,232
anyway i go to sleep for class tommorrow i'll see you guys later.....
- 2,417
- 400
I guess Red, reasons just like what Sheoth said. Dex Holders from Adventures (especially gen 3 onwards) are very strategic in battles. Just read FR-LG chapter and Emerald chapter and you will see how skilled and strategic Red is in PKM Battles. HG-SS chapter also shows you how strong his junior, Gold, who trained under him, is.
(Also Red was the League Champion of Kanto, and Ash...)
(Also Red was the League Champion of Kanto, and Ash...)
- 14,154
- 2,513
I would say Red, what he lacks in power he more than counters with strategy.
- 18,704
- 5,885
Red
- 3,557
- 639
- Thread starter
- #40
Greninja isn't involved in this fightPurkle200 said:
- Status
Similar threads
