• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Udlmaster
Reaction score
2,128

Profile posts Latest activity Postings About

  • Hey, I saw that you know quite a bit about Buddhism. This is a 1-A thread of Mystic Flour Cookie, who's heavily inspired by Buddhism, she's attained Nirvana and seeks to spread enlightenment, sending everyone to her Nirvana-like Paradise.

    You're gonna laugh


    Marckus matchup has been made now
    Artorimachi_Meteoraft
    Artorimachi_Meteoraft
    A little help please udl since I don’t know anyone else who could help thanks

    Help with this Harry Potter matchup

    Thanks
    I'm looking to get started on and publish some Bloodlines profiles soon, what are some feats, stats, and scaling for vampires with Dots 1-6?

    Also, shouldn't Antediluvians be just a straight up Low 2-C? After all, the Ravnos Antediluvian can create an alternate universe and survived spirit nukes the shockwaves of which penetrated into the various other layers of reality iirc, and the Lasombra Antediluvian became one with The Abyss

    And what's the consensus on the Tchernabog calc? Is the original calc correct, or is one of the suggested corrections in the comments the accepted version?
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    Aight, I'll send you my discord handle in convos

    Couldn't overwritten or just plain dusty materials be reconciled with the more recent/mainline 20Ae/5e canon(s) by considering them as being canon within different Tapestries? If I'm understanding the cosmology right, Tapestries are all individual universes with their own timelines, thus could account for incongruencies between editions by separating the editions into different but closely-related Tapestries.

    I'll ask some calc group members to take a look at the calc and double-check the math so that way the calc can be revised and/or applied to the relevant profiles. Praying for 6-C Meneleus 🙏
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    Going back to Bloodlines, would it be worth getting/making a calc of the opening cutscene of the Bach boss fight? If it's a legit dodge, it could either be a supporting calc for Subsonic+ vampire base speed (the player character in the video is Ventrue so has no Celerity), or could up the base speed to Supersonic.
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    Actually yeah, that would be a good thing to calc.
    If you could find someone willing to calc it, definitely do it, it'd be a crazy good feat and increase the legitimacy of WoD.

    Aight, I'll send you my discord handle in convos

    Sure, make sure when you add me, you use "the_buddha." including the fullstop
    Does infinite layers of underworld/low umbra qualify for infinite layers into High 1-A? Can you explain dot scaling to me? Don't really understand why it is an infinite hierarchy
    Rabbit2002
    Rabbit2002
    Is there a reason why High Umbra is meta and not just qualitative? You mean, since the Underworld (Umbra) sees Tapestry as a shadow, so having many of these structures must be qualitative? Still don't really understand the logic behind this


    Sorry for the above wording, I mean is there any statement about infinite dots?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    The High Umbra is where abstraction begins to go insane. My blog goes into massive details about it, but things like Plato's Cave for everything below it.

    The analogy for the Spires is that the entire umbra is a flat field of wonder while the Spires are the mountains, the mountains are all infinite in size and are infinite recursively refracting as the Tree of Life and so on.

    A lot of my blog discusses this in depth so there's no point repeating myself.

    As for there being an infinite number of Dots, there's nothing explicit, but we know from entities like The Nameless King that Dots do go upwards into infinity. He has backgrounds, which are far more specified on what they do per dot than Spheres, and has nearly all but a listed few at Infinite.

    In terms of what's listed, we are given abilities from Dots 1-9, however, once again, the Nameless King shows us you can go beyond this, as he has Entropy 10. In the game system itself, noting says 9 or 10 is the limit, 10 is what is show for Willpower, but many enemies have 15-20 Willpower.

    You can reach any number of Dots, the system doesn't have flat calculations for reaching X dot with EXP, but rather a rule of "6 EXP x current level" to go to the next level. So for Dot 2 to 3 it would cost 12 EXP. Dot 20 to 21 would cost 126 EXP (Which would be an astronomical amount, but entirely do-able)
    Rabbit2002
    Rabbit2002
    Wasn't Dots Scaling rejected by Ultima? Or is this thread just outdated? https://vsbattles.com/threads/frick-this-sense-of-deja-vu.66548/#post-2292638
    Also what is the exp mechanism (I know it's gameplay) that allows them to reach that tier? AFAIK, any use of something from a lower reality to ascend to a higher reality is automatically an anti-feat of qualitative superiority (or beyond) so...

    Q: Are there any disqualifiers for qualitative superiority?

    A: The potential disqualifiers largely revolve around the aforementioned aspect of inaccessibility: A qualitative superiority is completely irreducible to anything lesser than itself, and conversely, it cannot be reached by any additive process whatsoever.
    The first practical effect of this fact is that the power of a 1-A character cannot be dispersed so much that it reaches into a lower tier. Since there is no conceivable extension of any lower tier that can yield equality to a 1-A structure, neither can there be any subdivision (Even an infinite subdivision) of 1-A that reduces down into such tiers. Unless, of course, this division is somehow non-quantitative in nature (i.e. The results of the division are not actually numerical "chunks" of the character's power); however, this should be made reasonably clear by statements or through background context.
    Secondly, a 1-A level cannot be attained by a process in which the lower level quantitatively "adds up" to itself to break through into the higher one, due to the total lack of structural continuity between the two; the higher level cannot be attained, nor expressed by, any expansions of the lower one, and therefore things from the latter cannot interfere with the former by means of their own lower existences. Put simply: A non-1-A cannot reach the level of 1-A by appealing to another non-1-A
    Regarding Kupala, should I upscale them from Bodhisattvas/Methuselahs and rate them as "At least High 7-A, likely much/far higher", or should I scale them to Antediluvians and rate them as "5-B, possibly Low 2-C"? If Kupala really is a Talon of The Wyrm, then it should likely scale to Koshchei, which fought fairly evenly with Absimiliard iirc. Kupala was also sought out by The Eldest for its knowledge and power, and Absimiliard (this ******** again smfh) saw fit to ritualistically bind Kupala to weaponize it against the other Antediluvians and/or whatever else Gehenna comes knocking with.
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    Ah, so probably retconned out and the wiki is using old info. That's a shame if so
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    Also, do Patterns fit the bill for Type 2 Information?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    Definitely. Patterns and Quintessence are the most fundamental building block of the universe, more fundamental than information.
    Can I make another Markus matchup?

    Also this dnd matchup will you take a look?

    Regarding V5's use of amalgam replacing Disciplines such as Vicissitude and Dementation, could that perhaps speak to what Disciplines the respective Antediluvians fully mastered? While I dislike the idea from a gameplay perspective, it does seem as though it carries some lore implications regarding how those unique Disciplines came to be.
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    I thought about that, but I've decided for the most part to ignore v5 and focus on 20th for now.

    The only exception I make to this rule is Malekai, who's special Discipline being a mix of Dementation and Chimerstry, and this was stated in ToJ.
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    Regarding ignoring v5 for the most part; should that apply to other additions it makes, such as the changes to the physical Disciplines (Potence, Celerity, Fortitude) and the addition of the Blood Potency system, or should v5 changes only be disregarded when they clash irreconcilably with previous editions?
    I'm over my salt and am prepared to begin work on Hunter: the Parenting profiles

    Now, are the feats present in the series itself good enough for proper ratings on most of the stats or do I need references from other WoD content in of itself?

    Like, I know I'll need to pull from other content for Speed, I have no idea where Peak Human comes from for that, but are there any other stats I should be worrying about on that end?
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    Damn that is slanted. So I'm guessing for Horus v Mithras fight to have been as fair as it was, there had to have been something weakening Horus, since at his normal level of power he can do better against an Ante than any 4th Gen. Is there any suggestion that Horus was being negatively affected at the time?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    As far as I'm aware, there wasn't, and it was in Horus' domain, so I consider it a huge outlier for Mithras' power, especially since Mithras was forced into torpor by the German Blitz.
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    I coulda sworn Horus' domain was in Geneva Switzerland
    Regarding scaling between Bodhisattvas and Methuselahs, how does it work exactly? What's the source? Do both 4th and 5th Gens just generally scale roughly 1:1 with Bodhisattvas, does 4th Gen upscale, does 5th Gen downscale?
    Hey there, I was hoping you could take a look at the new information I provided in my Isekai Maou Cosmology CRT which should cement the Interstice as being 2-A. This scaling is no longer dependent on the mention of the Buddhist cosmological system, and I believe you will agree with my interpretation upon seeing the new evidence.
    I just started reading the WTO V20 corebook, and holy shit WoD cosmology is so much more coherent to me now
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    WtO helps explain the Low Umbra's cosmology and how when you die, that's where you go until you "pass on".

    One of the reasons why the cosmology is so big is because there's entire gamelines dedicated to certain parts of it.

    Wraith is the Low Umbra

    Werewolf is the Mid-Umbra

    Mage is the High Umbra and Horizon

    Changling is the Maya Dream realms

    and so on.
    noticed there's a thaumaturgical power that lets the user cast lightning. any chance it meets site standards for natural lightning?

    I like the new I AM THAT I AM page btw
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    "Aggravated damage (marked with an “*”) represents massive trauma – werewolf claws, vampire fangs, raging fires, and the metaphysical injuries inflicted by destruction of a person’s essential Pattern through magick or other paranormal means."

    ""Aggravated” represents the most horrific injuries a person can sustain: fire, acid, virulent toxins, vampire fangs, radiation, explosions, and similar physical atrocities. On a metaphysical level, such damage tears apart the Pattern that binds a living thing together… and so, it follows that Life 3 and Entropy 4 Effects inflict aggravated damage by unweaving that Pattern."

    "Aggravated damage represents the most awful ways to die."

    "Especially vile paranormal toxins deal out aggravated damage, but fortunately such substances are rare. Powerful Night-Folk often shrug off toxins and disease (or, like vampires, remain immune to most of them), but typically one or two substances – like silver to werecreatures or iron to the fae-folk– inflict aggravated damage against them."

    This is just from M20 book, which I had open
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    Another thing about True Names: I just learned that the Wraith Emperor Charon was named after a Demon of that Name by the Lady of Fate/maybe Eve, for the purpose of enabling him to have the power and control over Haven/The Underworld needed to master the River Styx and found the city of Stygia. Does being bestowed another's True Name give one access to that individual's power and abilities?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    I'm not entirely sure about that. Since the Lady of Fate is also possibly Lilith and I don't really know how much power over the Underworld she has or about True names.

    I don't think, in either case, she actually gave him a True name, but rather named him, which in effect limited his existence towards the Underworld (which is what happened with all the Spirits by Gaia)

    Heya, good afternoon from Brazil
    I saw you as a DnD supporter on the verse page...do you mind giving your input here?
    Much obliged for your time.
    I'm making a draft for a Cainite Physiology page. It's pretty far from complete, but I figure it'll help flesh out the VtM profiles on here, and I thought you may wanna give it a look
    • Like
    Reactions: Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    NO LISTS
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    I just got off the phone with I AM THAT I AM and they said that I get to use list format

    Getting back on track tho, I just wanted to double-check with you to make sure that the attributed ratings and powers were solid, especially in Nines' case since scaling him is a little tricky. Like in the same breath he'll tell the PC that he's not much of melee weapons guy, but then he'll train them up to a 5th Dot. We also don't get any on-screen showings from him other than him no-diffing a shovelhead
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    If he can still train someone up to the 5th Dot, I don't mind giving him "possibly 5th Dot" in his abilities for his Clan disciplines.

    I however, maintain lists are BANNED from WoD profiles.
    Bless your heart for arguing with Dr White on that thread 😭 I just read your post where you slammed Dr White and wanted to say good job
    Gnostic cosmology differed strongly from Christian conceptions in other areas as well. In most Gnostic traditions, the material and divine worlds can be clearly distinguished; many Gnostics considered the Creator of the World (whom they called Ialdabaoth) not merely separate from God, but inferior or even malign and resentful. In Gnostic thought, the Godhead, in its Platonic purity, cannot have created the gross cumbersome material world. Rather, emanations from God (usually eight or 30 "aeons", identified as angels in more Christian Gnosticisms) extend from the empyrean to the material, and the lowest such Aeon, the Demiurge, creates the world. Nevertheless, although the Demiurge's Creation remains horribly flawed, hope exists, at least for some. One of the aeons, Sophia, the Feminine Principle of Divine wisdom (whom some traditions blame for the Creation through her lustful weakness or her prideful reason), bring forth a redeeming spirit in memory of the higher world. When that redeemer rescues Sophia from the world through divine marriage, the reign of matter can be broken.
    Is 'the Godhead in it's platonic purity' refers to the Essential Divinity/I AM THAT I AM in the quote?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    It's referring to Jehovah, since Sophia is the feminine aspect of him along with Our Mother, the Merciful One
    I wanna do some Bloodlines profiles, how should I go about their P&As? Should I track down some 3e sourcebooks, go purely with what's shown in-game, or some combination? This ofc applies only to game-exclusive characters and the game versions of characters that appear later in other WoD media such as daddy Nines
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    It was something like Low 7-B or something like that based on a ritual that messed with the atmosphere
    SheevShezarrine
    SheevShezarrine
    4856EDD47EED7B1FA9F759CF4BACC47362CC3089

    Massive W
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    I'm being so serious right now. I miss these types of images man.
    Hello! Since you're the most knowledgeable person on WoD, I wanted to ask, what exactly is the Mummy's first move? Been planning to make a match against him, and I wanted to know what exactly does he do. Is he a smurf, and I assume the concept manip of his is type 1?

    Also, I've noticed something that was weird, but there doesn't seem to be any resistance to madness type 3, which I considered weird since, well, it's WoD.

    Thank you in advance!
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    The Mummy's first move would most likely to be to fling their various instant spells to see what would stick before backing out and trying to figure out their True Name if all else failed.
    Rikimarox2
    Rikimarox2
    Ah, mind me telling me what some of those instant spells are, and if any of his attacks aside from True Name could affect AE1 (Concept) shenanigans?

    Also, thank you for the reply!
    1. So who has the ability to kill true immortals in WOD? Can you list at least that you know at the moment?
    2. So if a godhead is dead physically but can their spirit lives and be impotent?
    3. Is there a feat of characters in WOD that they views as fiction?
    DOOMSLAYER127
    DOOMSLAYER127
    1. God you meant is Jehovah or Essential Divinity?
    2. Really? Is it anywhere mentioned indirectly or directly?
    3. Can this be a qualitative superiority for mages like R>f transcendence?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    Jehovah

    One of the main writers said Umbrood don’t die, they just change forms.

    For their abilities not them themselves.
    DOOMSLAYER127
    DOOMSLAYER127
    Who has qualitative superiority in the WOD? Can you list them?
    1. Is Lilith a true goddess? Because in gehenna toj when explaining about the avatars , it clarified that Lilith isn't a goddess but she was also in the ranks of the elohim. What do you think about this?
    2. What's the reason for gehenna toj(not novel one but game one where Lilith chapter is in)being not canon?
    3. What do you think about Lilith's powers described in gehenna toj especially her weakness?
    4. Antediluvian Ravnos and the cathayans(one of the most powerful kuei jin)battle echoed throughout the umbra and the maya realm. So both of them scale to it or not?
    DOOMSLAYER127
    DOOMSLAYER127
    1• If she can die then how can she be immortal?
    2• Could godheads truly die or is it just a physical death only?
    3• Ravnos have the level 10 power of his discipline Chimerstry to create a alternate reality so he can be universal with this.
    4• So Caine and malkav doesn't have tier 0 hax of word eater so word eater can be stronger than them due to this(in vs battle debating way not in lore way)?
    5• So Only one in vampire who has tier 0 hax is word eater?
    6• Do antes and archmages ever fought eachother?
    7• Where would WOD scale if we use Ultima's new proposal for the tiering system( like a verse can get to 1A if they have r>f transcendence thing)? I heard they will be downgraded if that happens. Is that true?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    1. Lilith can just be “killed” by people who can kill true immortals. Other Gods are similarly true immortals but can still die.
    2. They can become deceased but not departed.
    3. It’s the core reason why Antes have Uni+ as a tier, but it itself is just 1 example, which is why it’s not their only tier.
    4. He can kill them, yeah. But whether he’s stronger is different.
    5. No
    6. In canon, no.
    7. Same as it currently does, 0
    DOOMSLAYER127
    DOOMSLAYER127
    1. So who has the ability to kill true immortals in WOD? Can you list at least that you know at the moment?
    2. So it is not a existence erasure type but their spirit becomes impotent?
    5. So there are other ones too? Can you list the ones you know at the moment please?
    Hi Udlmaster! Can you answer these WoD scale questions?
    1. Can the Universe contain an infinite number of tellurians because the universe can contain all concepts so tellurians are not an exception because it is described as the concept of reality, am I right?
    2. I found evidence that the universe can be found in the cells of a human finger, so does it prove infinite loop when tellurian is contained in the universe and that universe is contained by other tellurian and repeat infinitely?

    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    1. Can the Universe contain an infinite number of tellurians because the universe can contain all concepts so tellurians are not an exception because it is described as the concept of reality, am I right?
    In the story, unsure (it's up the the Storyteller), though in terms of VS debating, recursive hierarchies don't really work out since they balloon in tiering and don't really hit and end point. It becomes that diagram of Set theory where Vsause just adds the sum total on top of itself without end and it just goes up and up and up.

    I'd probably say that the Universe wouldn't/couldn't contain the Tellurian, as the Tellurian is considered to be a higher order of concepts. It wouldn't make much sense either with the plot line of the verse, since the point is the Universe and the Umbra are split off the the Universe is becoming more and more detached from the Umbra by the Weaver.

    I found evidence that the universe can be found in the cells of a human finger, so does it prove infinite loop when tellurian is contained in the universe and that universe is contained by other tellurian and repeat infinitely?
    Theoretically they could, and if a Storyteller decided it to be so, it could be, though the idea of that is that "Everything is complete", that is to say, everything contains all other things, not in the sense that we would be bigger than the universe, but that we have the same "elements" that could be anything else, almost like a fractal.
    Leoduckiscool
    Leoduckiscool
    Thank you so much!, can I ask one more question?, How many layers into 0 does Wod have, infinite layers into 0 or higher?
    The Multiverse is pretty irrelevant in WoD, it takes place at the outer-most edges of the Deep Umbra.
    Do you have a scan of that one please?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    I have the citation, which is Mage the Ascension, Ascension, pg. 208
    DOOMSLAYER127
    DOOMSLAYER127
    Are you referring to the time of judgement book ascension?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    Yeah
    1. Is Godheads tellurians exists in the deep umbra or beyond that?
    2. Is there a true tellurian and encompasses other Tellurians?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    Depends, there's levels to the Godheads.

    Some of them exist in the Astral Courts while others exist beyond.

    As for a "true Tellurian" we just don't know.
    DOOMSLAYER127
    DOOMSLAYER127
    1. Is Lilith's tellurian exists the void where other Tellurians were formed just like Jehovah's?
    2. What exactly is Endless Sea in the revelations of the dark mother? Is it the void or just the sea?
    Hi
    1.Can you list the books that are about WOD Buddha please?
    2. Where does the multiverse scale in WOD and please tell me the reason behind that scale?
    3. Is there infinite Tellurians?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    1. There's several times it's implied throughout the books, one being that every single God has their own "Garden" this is in reference to their own realms and realities.

    It has to therefore be interpreted that these are Tellurians, as there's countless stories of each God making -the- Tellurian, and they can't all be true. So it follows that the Gardens are Tellurians.

    Secondly is that Archmages can create their own Tellurian from a balled off version of their current one, the implication is that we're not even in the "real" tellurian and are just existing in another Archmage's self-made Tellurian like a fractal.

    2. Like I said, I don't have any lists, you'll just have to look around for the books that focus on Eastern Philosophy.

    3. It's reliable. In later books they're confirmed by the Narrator that they are in fact true. For example, in ToJ: Gehenna, we're just flat out told that the Lilith from Revelations of the Dark Mother IS the Lilith we see in ToJ and that the accounts there are true.

    In 20th Edition Vampire we're told that Revelations of the Dark Mother remains to be true and that Lilith is Jehovah's equal.
    DOOMSLAYER127
    DOOMSLAYER127
    Thanks for your response
    DOOMSLAYER127
    DOOMSLAYER127
    1. Did satyros (the writer of revelations of the dark mother) said that gardens are the tellurian? If he didn't said it then can you ask him personally please since he's active on Twitter and i saw you ask him questions about mages on it.
    2. Endless sea shown in revelations of the dark mother is what exactly? A Void or just a sea? If gardens are tellurian then endless sea means Void?
    Hi there, Sorry to bother you but do you maybe happen to know on what sect of Buddhism is journey to the west based on?
    Udlmaster
    Udlmaster
    It's mostly a cultural variant that existed in China at the time, a mix of Chan Buddhism, Flower Garland Buddhism and various other sects that the Cheng'en experienced and had known about during his time alive
    • Like
    Reactions: Gasper
    Link to the FFXIV Discussion Thread.
    My WoL sandbox.
    Sadly, I had to postpone my work on the verse, as I'm having some technical issues with resubbing to the game. I've done ARR almost three times now and keep finding new things that have yet to be added to Meteor's profile. Rest assured I'll be working day and night on this sandbox once I get my subscription to work.
  • Loading…
  • Loading…
  • Loading…
Back
Top