This thread manages to go to incon grace again, why am I not surprised. I don't even have the energy to go through a back and forth for multiple pages once again. So I'll just voice out my major concern with the arguments being presented.
And that concern is that everyone is now suddenly a brain surgeon talking as if they are a professional on the matter and are saying as a matter of fact that Makima's vague as hell bio hax would be able to do a number of things on Gojo. Which is ironic because I got accused of using headcannons for my arguments on Gojo's favor when the entire bio hax wincon relies on head cannons.
Literally my first point about the hax and a fact that the profiles themselves point out is that the ability is vague asf, we get no explanation or even visual as to how it works internally, they just bleed from the outside and thats it. But now everyone's saying it targets this or that, causes this or that when we dont know jack about how the ability actually works.
Its literally possible for her not to have caused any brain damage at all, or cause it to a greater extent than what Gojo has received. But now, not only has everyone unanimously accepted that it is far letha than what Gojo has endured, but also that it will somehow instantly knock Gojo unconscious??
It is just like finepoint said. All the discussion surrounding biohax wincon is purely theoretical, no one here is an expert at brain science I'm pretty sure, and what I am sure of is that no one knows how the damned ability works, why? Cause we've never been given an explanation, or a visual demonstration of what it does internally.
To say that a person, who has healed brain damage 5 times, with an actual visual representation of the damage he took each time, and has been confirmed to have a better healing factor than someone who literally healed his brain getting struck by lightning, will crumble INSTANTLY against an attack that vaguely causes internal hemorrhage without ANY explanation of how it does it or what parts of the brain it actually strikes or ANYTHING for that matter is, by definition,
headcannon.
You can't even fully use the darkness devil as a crutch here, since it clearly has a way different biology than regular humans. Idk why people are trying to compare what the ability did to someone with a way different biology to humans when the ability has already been used on humans. When it was used against humans it clearly didn't have effects that is too much to heal for Gojo, so instead of just assuming that the ability would have the same impact to Gojo that it had to those humans since the targets share similar biology, you guys arguing that they are actually two different abilities, or more specifically, that the two instances in which the ability was used were of different potencies, something that hasn't been stated before. Again, headcannon.
To add another layer, seems like everyone also forgot one of my main points against the bio hax in the first place. Which is that the matter of Makima using the ability is unlikely as hell. She used the general ability twice, and if we separate the two (bio hax with a point and with a stare) then she's used the point one (the one that would actually win the match) then she'd have used the ability ONCE throughout the entire series. Though even if we say they are the same move since my last argument just alluded to that, two times isn't much better.
Saying she'd start with this move in the first place, is makimg Makima extremely lucky. She has no idea about any of Gojo's kit. Makima already has prior info on the darkness devil tho to what extent is unknown, but we can assume this is at least enough to know what the DD can do in a fight (since she seemed prepared that the darkness devil was stronger than her). This means that not only has she started with the bio hax a grand total of two times, but in one of those times it was against fodder and in the other she had prior knowledge on who she's fighting. Something she doesn't have here, in fact its literally the opposite. He knows Gojo isn't fodder but also lacks any information on what Gojo's abilities are.
She has a hundred of other abilities she can utilize, abilities that she's used way more times in one match than she has used the bio hax in the entire manga yet no one is questioning the fact that she starts with it? Everyone just assumes she will?
Good luck on getting that CRT accepted too btw, considering the entire argument hinges on the idea that santa claus regenerated instantly when that is explicitly not the case.
And before you argue this is before her darkness form, she already commented how her wounds regenerated instantly, so the darkness devil aability should have been active here. Furthermore in her actual darkness form she was never hit meaning there's no proof of how fast she regenerates. Not to mention it could entirely be possible thaat the darkness devil regeneration and the one santa claus got are different. We already know that what ability a person gets from a contract wont be one to one with the actual devil's powers. The very first contract with the series, the zombie contract turned the yakuza into mindless zombies, and im pretty sure the zombie devil itself wasn't mindless since yknow it could talk and stuff. Its entirely possible that the darkness devil's regeneration is voluntary, or a hundred of other possibilities tht wont result in "regeneration negation".
After all, if the darkness devil really could regenerate that fast and with those injuries, he'd have better regen than Pochita, who Makima had to make a sword for to specifically nullify his regen. Pochita regenerated all of Makima's other attacks. At best Makima would have regeneration negation for the DD specifically.
