• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

High School DxD Downgrade: Tier 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

Digital_Franz

He/Him
Messages
2,247
Reaction score
1,421
I'm back (to this verse). Well, for the same page, accepted in this thread (again).

Currently I am going against the 2-C rating of worlds which is accepted for the following reason:
Not an actual place (that would be the Dimensional Gap), term that describes a collection of myth realms. 21 Universes for ExE and FxF (Parallel worlds to DxD), 22 universes for DxD (has Isolation Barrier.)
So actually myth realms are Universes. Fair enough.

From the cosmology page:
What the hell is going on? So actually the rating should be Low 2-C, possibly 2-C.

Why are they possibly Low 2-C though?
Got it translated and nah it isn't that.

We have this:
This is doubtful because the concept of parallel worlds/dimensions/universes does not seem to apply to these worlds according to the author's conception. Got it translated too.

Also, it should be mentioned that hell has fake celestial bodies, and nah this doesn't indicate the size.

We have this:
Extraordinary claim without proof. Why? Let's get to the thing.

In the verse, we have insane feats like:

The standards:
So all in all, these realms are part of the same universe.

Now, since these dimensions are shown to be part of the same universe, the destruction of said universe would be 3-A without the feat of destroying space-time in its entirety.

The world destruction statements do not indicate the destruction of space-time/timeline, and this one seems very relevant to this fact.

That's all for this thread.
 


This alone is enough. This points something.
The bicycle~
 
This alone is enough. This points something.
Not commenting on the thread itself, but the bicycle is specially made by Azazel so what’s the issue? Heaven is in another dimension, much like the other mythological worlds, so it’s not possible that a normal bicycle can enter another dimension. The bicycle itself was confiscated for a reason.

I’m not sure what the second scan is supposed to represent.
 
I’m not knowledgeable regarding 3A and above but I’m grateful that it’s again said that Hell has fake celestial bodies. This also could say that in the rating games that we see, everything that was made to create it is also fake which I pointed out in CRTs last time

Good job Digital
 


Ep 2 10:30 to full ep
I don't see anything at all, unless you gave me the wrong timeframe. At the very least, this needs to be explained, and I don't think the anime does.
Not commenting on the thread itself, but the bicycle is specially made by Azazel so what’s the issue? Heaven is in another dimension, much like the other mythological worlds, so it’s not possible that a normal bicycle can enter another dimension. The bicycle itself was confiscated for a reason.
The bicycle is special in that it travels at high speed, but the point is that it still performs a 3D movement, unless you mean it performs a 4D movement. The bicycle went into space at high speed and arrived in heaven, using the same mode of movement.
I’m not sure what the second scan is supposed to represent.
Well, just that the Dimensional Gap is in the world, and also it's also the Dimensional Wall.
 
I don't see anything at all, unless you gave me the wrong timeframe. At the very least, this needs to be explained, and I don't think the anime does.
Sorry 10:50 and after that

you can clearly see that train go through a portal, in the novel its describe as similar to black hole
 
The bicycle went into space at high speed and arrived in heaven
Heaven is not physically located in outer space, or is that what you’re saying? Azazel already made a UFO that can go into outer space.

Heaven is in another dimension, so it’s not possible to arrive there ‘physically’. Not to mention, each faction has defenses that are supposed to prevent unwarranted access. That’s why Azi Dahaka’s ability to teleport into each of the mythological dimensions was an issue for them. The bicycle is clearly special.

For the bicycle to arrive there, it must have the ability to enter into other dimensions and also ignore their defensive measures.
 
Sorry 10:50 and after that

you can clearly see that train go through a portal, in the novel its describe as similar to black hole
Oh for the train, yeah but it doesn't help really. Reason below.
Not commenting on the thread itself, but the bicycle is specially made by Azazel so what’s the issue? Heaven is in another dimension, much like the other mythological worlds, so it’s not possible that a normal bicycle can enter another dimension. The bicycle itself was confiscated for a reason.
They are different dimensions, I don't deny this point, but I say that they are not spatio-temporally separated. Here is what the standards tell us:
 
Heaven is not physically located in outer space, or is that what you’re saying? Azazel already made a UFO that can go into outer space.

Heaven is in another dimension, so it’s not possible to arrive there ‘physically’. Not to mention, each faction has defenses that are supposed to prevent unwarranted access. That’s why Azi Dahaka’s ability to teleport into each of the mythological dimensions was an issue for them. The bicycle is clearly special.

For the bicycle to arrive there, it must have the ability to enter into other dimensions and also ignore their defensive measures.
Not that it's physically located in outer space, but they are physically part of the same space.
The bicycle is special in the sense that even with its 3D physical movement it can reach these realms. Yeah, they have defense systems for what reason? Because it's possible to get there with 3D means and they would have to prevent intruders from entering. Now teleportation is a pain for them precisely because they can't detect the guy before he enters.
 
Bro now you going to say that ExE and FxF are the physically part of the same universe because those are separated by dimensional gap even though those dimension has their own space and time even hell and Haven has their own space and time as well other timeline to because they are separated dimensional gap
 
They are different dimensions, I don't deny this point, but I say that they are not spatio-temporally separated.
OK, but what does spatio-temporally separated mean, in this context? We know the Underworld had its own time flow/axis before the start of canon.
Now teleportation is a pain for them precisely because they can't detect the guy before he enters.
Anybody can teleport. The issue was that Azi Dahaka had knowledge of forbidden techniques that allowed him to bypass their defensive techniques. The average joe can’t teleport there.

Bro now you going to say that ExE and FxF are the physically part of the same universe because those are separated by dimensional gap even though those dimension has their own space and time even hell and Haven has their own space and time
What if they are? We don’t really know where any of those worlds are.

No need to bring them in, for now.
 
Bro now you going to say that ExE and FxF are the physically part of the same universe because those are separated by dimensional gap
They are literally in the same timeline, you should read your cosmology page.
even though those dimension has their own space and time even hell and Haven has their own space and time
Well you have to prove that they have their own space-times.
OK, but what does spatio-temporally separated mean, in this context? We know the Underworld had its own time flow/axis before the start of canon.
Being completely isolated from each other or if you want, that they are separate space-time continuums. For the flow of time, this does not indicate a separation, since even in the universe there are such variations of time.
Anybody can teleport. The issue was that Azi Dahaka had knowledge of forbidden techniques that allowed him to bypass their defensive techniques. The average joe can’t teleport there.
Yeah sure a feat for him.
 
They are literally in the same timeline, you should read your cosmology page.
They are parallel world so yah
Well you have to prove that they have their own space-times.

Being completely isolated from each other or if you want, that they are separate space-time continuums. For the flow of time, this does not indicate a separation, since even in the universe there are such variations of time.
i don't since you accept that they have their own time i need to proof the dimension are infinite in size

These are notes that the worlds are indeed universes; while they don't need all of these, at least one of them should indicate this.

If the size of the realms described has having infinite sizes or other synonyms, that should strongly indicate them being universes




I think this much enough
 
Last edited:
i don't since you accept that they have their own time i need to proof the dimension are infinite in size
Uh no. I said sure they are separated dimensions but they are not spatio-temporally separated.
These are notes that the worlds are indeed universes; while they don't need all of these, at least one of them should indicate this.

If the size of the realms described has having infinite sizes or other synonyms, that should strongly indicate them being universes
Sure but you should read the next part, what I'm actually using:
OK, you want to prove that these are just universes (which so far is not valid), but you don't prove that they are spatiotemporally separated. Why aren't they? Back to the OP.
A shock wave can't travel through a separated space-time, so this is already an anti-feat for separation. Also, it is possible to travel through these Heavens with a simple 3D movement.
 
A shock wave can't travel through a separated space-time, so this is already an anti-feat for separation. Also, it is possible to travel through these Heavens with a simple 3D movement.
I don't need to read op you need to

From the cosmology page:
In conclusion, the mythological dimensions are at least 4-A, possibly Low 2-C.

Heaven is one space time continue

About bicycle in this case is

the bicycle is specially made by Azazel so what’s the issue? Heaven is in another dimension, much like the other mythological worlds, so it’s not possible that a normal bicycle can enter another dimension. The bicycle itself was confiscated for a reason.


You're entire thread base on this

What the hell is going on? So actually the rating should be Low 2-C, possibly 2-C.


This is your own creation not exist in previous accepted op
 
Last edited:
I don't need to read op you need to
I guess I should.
About bicycle in this case is

the bicycle is specially made by Azazel so what’s the issue? Heaven is in another dimension, much like the other mythological worlds, so it’s not possible that a normal bicycle can enter another dimension. The bicycle itself was confiscated for a reason.
Specially made by Azazel doesn't mean anything. The only thing special about it is that it can fly, and therefore it's a one-way ticket to heaven.
You're entire thread base on this

What the hell is going on? So actually the rating should be Low 2-C, possibly 2-C.


This is your own creation not exist in previous accepted op
Don't start this please.
 
Then anyone can fly to heaven and hell just by that that they doesn't need to cross the dimension gap that separate the dimension and it's clearly shown in the Anime that without portal and teleportation you can enter dimension gap author need to cut the space to enter dimensional gap

If you season 3 is not canon then episode zero of season 4 also shown that

bicycle in this case is special and not a normal bicycle
Don't start this please.
Yes I am since you first bring that and base on that you bring this
A shockwave that crosses the Heavens
A dragon makes its fireball travel between the Heavens

A dragon moves between the Heavens
 
Last edited:
Then anyone can fly to heaven and hell just by that that they doesn't need to cross the dimension gap that separate the dimension and it's clearly shown in the Anime that without portal and teleportation you can enter dimension gap author need to cut the space to enter dimensional gap

If you season 3 is not canon then episode zero of season 4 also shown that

bicycle in this case is special and not a normal bicycle
Just because everyone can fly doesn't mean they can; there's no logical implication with what I said. First of all, most characters who can fly aren't that fast and just fly on earth, not space.

Well, the thing is, even though the Dimensional Gap exists and is the wall separating dimensions, it makes travel between dimensions difficult, but not impossible. There are many reasons for using teleportation, some of which were mentioned by @Burning_Full_Fingers above (the security systems).
That is because, while the wall may make it difficult in practice, one could in theory still move from one realm to the other with just regular three dimensional movement. That means that the realms are still part of one common three dimensional space, which by our standards constitutes only one universe.

Also, there's this feat on Issei's profile that's pretty convincing that these aren't separate space-times.
Yes I am since you first bring that and base on that you bring this
A shockwave that crosses the Heavens
A dragon makes its fireball travel between the Heavens

A dragon moves between the Heavens
OK, it's still fine.
 
Just because everyone can fly doesn't mean they can; there's no logical implication with what I said. First of all, most characters who can fly aren't that fast and just fly on earth, not space.

Well, the thing is, even though the Dimensional Gap exists and is the wall separating dimensions, it makes travel between dimensions difficult, but not impossible. There are many reasons for using teleportation, some of which were mentioned by @Burning_Full_Fingers above (the security systems).
No is not what I asked before I asked how bicycle inter dimension gap which is completely separate dimension without crossing that you can inter heaven or hell and it's clear that without cutting space, destroying space, creating portal, our teleportation you can enter dimension gap so you can't cross the dimension gap without entering dimension gap until you teleport directly to those realm so it's not physically directly entering heaven or hell it entering by magical things

It should be recognized that travel between universes is not feasible unless through the use of a portal or similar unusual mechanisms. This is because it should be impossible for two distinct universes to be connected by a path that only goes through regular 3 dimensional space. Universes must be separated by something other than 3 dimensional distance or physical barriers, otherwise they would be considered to both be part of one large universe for our tiering purposes.



Also, there's this feat on Issei's profile that's pretty convincing that these aren't separate space-times.
Yah it's make hole in dimension to enter which is considered similar portal creation

Also this is not separate space time it just pocket reality created inside dimension gap not space time continue

so I don't think it's make any sense to bring here

All i think you first have knowledge of dxd before creating those threads you don't read the novel and watch the dxd anime

OK, it's still fine.
now only thing you have is bicycle which is special in this case
 
Last edited:
No is not what I asked before I asked how bicycle inter dimension gap which is completely separate dimension without crossing that you can inter heaven or hell and it's clear that without cutting space, destroying space, creating portal, our teleportation you can enter dimension gap so you can't cross the dimension gap without entering dimension gap until you teleport directly to those realm so it's not physically directly entering heaven or hell it entering by magical things
OK, can you provide a scan where it says it's only possible to enter by these means? Because characters using only these means doesn't mean they're the only possible ones. What's stopping her from going to the end of the universe and then crossing the dimensional gap that's supposed to be there? And as I said in my previous post, just cutting the space is not enough.
Yah it's make hole in dimension to enter which is considered similar portal creation
Ayo this isn't Portal Creation, hell no. Making a hole in space is different from creating a Portal. A portal allows to move between space-times, making a simple hole in space does not. I've already mentioned this here.
Also this is not separate space time it just pocket reality created inside dimension gap not space time continue

so I don't think it's make any sense to bring here
Well, you guys don't treat this as just a Pocket Dimension but as a separate space-time because it's called a dimension like the others.
All i think you first have knowledge of dxd before creating those threads you don't read the novel and watch the dxd anime
Also fine.
now only thing you have is bicycle which is special in this case
Special, the only thing you got, but we need to know how it's special.
 
OK, can you provide a scan where it says it's only possible to enter by these means? Because characters using only these means doesn't mean they're the only possible ones. What's stopping her from going to the end of the universe and then crossing the dimensional gap that's supposed to be there? And as I said in my previous post, just cutting the space is not enough.
Heaven is not physically located in outer space, or is that what you’re saying? Azazel already made a UFO that can go into outer space.

Or proof where is stated that heaven and other realms exit in outer space

If heaven is exist outside in outer space than how can we the heaven has infinite size with his own time

Ayo this isn't Portal Creation, hell no. Making a hole in space is different from creating a Portal. A portal allows to move between space-times, making a simple hole in space does not. I've already mentioned this here.
https://i.gyazo.com/39839265ea152c3c8080e13309f66f60.png it used great Red power great Red use this method to enter other dimension there is few more if you want I give them here
No, no one is doing that for dimension lost it's only happened in innovate clear which is clearly stated creative fake universe with user can control the fate and destiny of the fake universe and its do not affecting the real world in anyway
 
Heaven is not physically located in outer space, or is that what you’re saying?
Yeah, I never said Heaven is physically located in outer space.
https://i.gyazo.com/39839265ea152c3c8080e13309f66f60.png it used great Red power great Red use this method to enter other dimension there is few more if you want I give them here
Doesn't really help regarding the whole space-time stuff. If you have anything about a portal and not just a hole in space you can drop.
No, no one is doing that for dimension lost it's only happened in innovate clear which is clearly stated creative fake universe with user can control the fate and destiny of the fake universe and its do not affecting the real world in anyway
Not affecting the real world doesn't mean it's spatio-temporally separated. Even what happens in Dimensional Lost doesn't affect the outside world, but it isn't spatio-temporally separated.
 
I said they are in the same physical universe, not that Heaven is in the Human World.
Heaven and hell infinity in size with it own time


In essence, this details the fact that there’s a void without concepts of distance and direction, the laws of physics, space, and time. This infinite void world is beyond all dimensions in High School DxD existing detached, but between from every dimension. that indicate the separation of space and time from these other dimensions.
 
Last edited:
Heaven and hell infinity in size with it own time
Cough, this~
In essence, this details the fact that there’s a void without concepts of distance and direction, the laws of physics, space, and time. This infinite void world is beyond all dimensions in High School DxD existing detached, but between from every dimension. that indicate the separation of space and time from these other dimensions.
OK so? It's still the Dimensional Wall, and it also doesn't indicate a spatio-temporal separation. Worse, it's a void. While we're at it, can you find the part in the novel that matches what's described in the anime as having no concept of distance? Because on Discord a friend told me that this is something added by the anime and the TL. So I'd like scans from the novel.
Oh, okay. Well yeah, they should be in the ‘same place’, just in different dimensions with their own time.
You roughly get it, but I don't agree with the "their own time".
 
Cough, this~

OK so? It's still the Dimensional Wall, and it also doesn't indicate a spatio-temporal separation. Worse, it's a void. While we're at it, can you find the part in the novel that matches what's described in the anime as having no concept of distance? Because on Discord a friend told me that this is something added by the anime and the TL. So I'd like scans from the novel.
So you saying that anime is not canon to dxd

Or can you explain to me how space time separate then
You roughly get it, but I don't agree with the "their own time".
There is clear statement about having time whether you accept or not it's don't change anything because in the novel it's clearly stated and even anime
 
Last edited:
Also should be noted that in dxd when come to pseudo space then they clearly stated that while it's come to mythological world's like heaven and hell it's never stated that they are pseudo space but dimension with their own time
2db2d8d46465665000739868743f95de.png


Having own time
0fba7d1afbeb403300b3e5901adc2f9c.png
 
Last edited:
Or can you explain to me how space time separate then
Each dimension should have its own timeline.
There is clear statement about having time whether you accept or not it's don't change anything because in the novel it's clearly stated and even anime
Also should be noted that in dxd when come to pseudo space then they clearly stated that while it's come to mythological world's like heaven and hell it's never stated that they are pseudo space but dimension with their own time
2db2d8d46465665000739868743f95de.png


Having own time
0fba7d1afbeb403300b3e5901adc2f9c.png
Having its own time flow does not mean that it has "its own time", because even in our universe different places can have their own time flow.
We need staff here or this won’t be concluded
Yeah.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top