-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Esdeath vs Nico Robin
- Thread starter Ryuga21
- Start date
- 14,575
- 5,877
Time Stop GG I guess.
- 14,575
- 5,877
Not sure. I don't know Esdeath really well.
- 762
- 438
Ask some knowledgable members from Akame Ga Kill about it about that, I will go off on my assumptions.
In terms of AP, Esdeath could this hands down. She is above 3.76 Megatons while Robin is at 2.46 Megatons but like Robin said "Power, speed... they mean nothing to me".
Robin has Resistance to Cold Temperature, helping her a bit in this battle against the Ice Queen.
She can try to overwhelm Robin with her Danmaku and Summoning ability but I believe Robin could easily summon her giant big arms and smash them apart or just summoning clones of herself to aid her much better.
Esdeath's Extrasensory Perception (Her sixth sense) will help her if Robin try to spring surprise attack on her but since Robin won't be carrying much of a murderous intent (not that I can't see if Esdeath hadn't kill one of the SH), how effective it is idk but I leave this as an advantage for Esdeath.
I don't know how Robin will react to Esdeath's Afterimages creation since Esdeath can fool Robin in attacking the image when she is somewhere else, probably mounting an attack but like Esdeath, she has her own danger intuition and could sense danger approaching.
Robin could pull off a win with her abilities and able to hold down Esdeath with her multiple of hands and Esdeath won't be breaking out of that grip lock with the difference in Lifting Strength. Could Esdeath manipulates ice if she being held down, unable to use her hands (she usually does a gesture when attacking so I figure...). Even if she exert some cold temperature to ward off Robin, Robin would certainly handle it.
But again, we must not underestimate Esdeath. As the battle goes on, she will definetely notice Robin's weakness of her Hana Hana no Mi and captilizes on that. She would likely try to leave herself seemingly open and try to get Robin to fall into her trap. Whether she falls for it idk but with her danger intuition, maybe not.
Then we have the Time Stop Hax. There is nothing Robin can do to stop this. Going by Standard Battle Assumption, she has no idea that Esdeath can Time Stop and will hurt her severely. She has no way of telling if it is coming or not and Esdeath will activate this if she feel threatened enough. And when she activate it, and I mean WHEN, she does, it is over. She could break free from Robin's immoblized hands that is holding her and fires off a ice spear from a distance and kill Robin.
This is a long way of saying Esdeath wins this with high difficulty.
In terms of AP, Esdeath could this hands down. She is above 3.76 Megatons while Robin is at 2.46 Megatons but like Robin said "Power, speed... they mean nothing to me".
Robin has Resistance to Cold Temperature, helping her a bit in this battle against the Ice Queen.
She can try to overwhelm Robin with her Danmaku and Summoning ability but I believe Robin could easily summon her giant big arms and smash them apart or just summoning clones of herself to aid her much better.
Esdeath's Extrasensory Perception (Her sixth sense) will help her if Robin try to spring surprise attack on her but since Robin won't be carrying much of a murderous intent (not that I can't see if Esdeath hadn't kill one of the SH), how effective it is idk but I leave this as an advantage for Esdeath.
I don't know how Robin will react to Esdeath's Afterimages creation since Esdeath can fool Robin in attacking the image when she is somewhere else, probably mounting an attack but like Esdeath, she has her own danger intuition and could sense danger approaching.
Robin could pull off a win with her abilities and able to hold down Esdeath with her multiple of hands and Esdeath won't be breaking out of that grip lock with the difference in Lifting Strength. Could Esdeath manipulates ice if she being held down, unable to use her hands (she usually does a gesture when attacking so I figure...). Even if she exert some cold temperature to ward off Robin, Robin would certainly handle it.
But again, we must not underestimate Esdeath. As the battle goes on, she will definetely notice Robin's weakness of her Hana Hana no Mi and captilizes on that. She would likely try to leave herself seemingly open and try to get Robin to fall into her trap. Whether she falls for it idk but with her danger intuition, maybe not.
Then we have the Time Stop Hax. There is nothing Robin can do to stop this. Going by Standard Battle Assumption, she has no idea that Esdeath can Time Stop and will hurt her severely. She has no way of telling if it is coming or not and Esdeath will activate this if she feel threatened enough. And when she activate it, and I mean WHEN, she does, it is over. She could break free from Robin's immoblized hands that is holding her and fires off a ice spear from a distance and kill Robin.
This is a long way of saying Esdeath wins this with high difficulty.
- 762
- 438
BUMP
- 63,529
- 8,506
1. She does not need too
2. I need to check Budo's feat since it might have a horizon
2. I need to check Budo's feat since it might have a horizon
- 762
- 438
But if it come to battle of attrition, which I listed why above, she will use it and Robin not knowing about it will get caught and it gg for EsdeathRei Rubro said:
- 63,529
- 8,506
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/U.../Akame_ga_Kill!._General_Budo_creates_a_storm
Does this storm have a horizon?
I don't get storm calcs myselfs
Does this storm have a horizon?
I don't get storm calcs myselfs
- 2,047
- 778
Can you post a scan of the panel of the feat?
- 2,047
- 778
Actually that calc already uses Horizon scaling from the looks of it.
- 63,529
- 8,506
That calc was rendered unuseable due to it using KE
I just used it as an image for the storm.
Imma reread the chapter real quick, gimme a sec
I just used it as an image for the storm.
Imma reread the chapter real quick, gimme a sec
- 762
- 438
You're gonna re-calculate it?Schnee One said:
- 63,529
- 8,506
No, but a baseline CAPE storm is 6 megatons as per DMUAs calc.
It'd be a minor upgrade
Anyway, Imma post some scans here and if it's good, I need to change the justifications, I don't want to derail any further
It'd be a minor upgrade
Anyway, Imma post some scans here and if it's good, I need to change the justifications, I don't want to derail any further
- 63,529
- 8,506
https://www.***********.net/akame-ga-kiru/56/44
This is the other image.
From the looks of the edges, the horizon is a bust correct me if I'm wrong
This is the other image.
From the looks of the edges, the horizon is a bust correct me if I'm wrong
- 762
- 438
Doesn't seem to be expanding to the horizon in my opinion. It is unlike that of Esdeath's storm feat.
- 63,529
- 8,506
Yeah I figured.
Esdeath for Plums reasons.
Esdeath for Plums reasons.
- 10,065
- 5,294
Esdeath puts Robin on ice FRA.
- 3,464
- 891
Easy death FRA
- 14,575
- 5,877
Yes, Esdeath takes this for reason above.
- 2,047
- 778
Ice ice baby for the reasons above.
- 762
- 438
That's six for Esdeath, one more for the Ice Queen to take this to Grace.... OR Thousand Armed Goddess that is Robin could make a comeback of sort.
- 4,965
- 3,771
Well, if Robin has some sort of prep time, I would say she has a better chance of besting Esdeath, but no pre-knowledge of Stopping time equates to Robin losing but it would be a very hard battle for Esdeath to win. I vote for Esdeath via Plum's reasonings. And's that Grace people
- 63,529
- 8,506
No defending Robin? Huh.
- 4,965
- 3,771
If Robin has prep time and she know about Esdeath's time stop hax, I would defend her but I can'tSchnee One said:
- 63,529
- 8,506
You give Esdeath prep she bombards with 200 Ice Soldiers
- 14,575
- 5,877
Plum gave great reasons. There's no point in arguing when he has covered Robin's options.
- 762
- 438
And Robin will summon hundreds of giant arms and smash them to pieces?
- 63,529
- 8,506
She won't be able to smash them to pieces when they're stronger then her.
But again, no point arguing
But again, no point arguing
- 762
- 438
I forgot to include the part where the ice Calvary can freaking regenerate, that's fair. Though they are limited if Robin can distract her with constant usage of his almost instaneous hands to distract her, allowing her to cripple most of the army before moving onto the big mama before they could regenerate.
Though as you said, no points in arguing. Let's enjoy the 24 hours countdown to Esdeath victory
Though as you said, no points in arguing. Let's enjoy the 24 hours countdown to Esdeath victory
- 63,529
- 8,506
Esdeath made such an incredible comeback ever since she got revised
Remember when she was 3-9 for almost a year?
Remember when she was 3-9 for almost a year?
- 762
- 438
That's was before she gots GG Time Stop Hax?Schnee One said:
- 14,575
- 5,877
It's not a comeback actually since Robin hasn't been winning this in any point of the match.
Comeback is when a character is losing and suddenly he gets the advantage and wins (a.k.a. asspull ovo)
Comeback is when a character is losing and suddenly he gets the advantage and wins (a.k.a. asspull ovo)
- 63,529
- 8,506
No.
She's had time Stop since her profile was created, it's just that back then it was accepted that you can bypass it through heat or solid ice resistance.
Then IMADE made the thread on why that was wrong and she recovered when her Tiers got revised.
Speaking of old matches......
Sorry to derail the thread since it's over, but how well above 4.4 Kilotons is Erza? I here she either stomps characters that strong as Natsu Stomps Rogue, other times I hear she's stronger.
I have a match in mind depending on the answer
She's had time Stop since her profile was created, it's just that back then it was accepted that you can bypass it through heat or solid ice resistance.
Then IMADE made the thread on why that was wrong and she recovered when her Tiers got revised.
Speaking of old matches......
Sorry to derail the thread since it's over, but how well above 4.4 Kilotons is Erza? I here she either stomps characters that strong as Natsu Stomps Rogue, other times I hear she's stronger.
I have a match in mind depending on the answer
- 63,529
- 8,506
?Calaca Vs said:
You misunderstood what I said.
Esdeath had a 3-9 win loss back before she got revised, then she got revised and now has one of the better ones on the site
That's a comeback.
- 14,575
- 5,877
Oh, right. Excuse me.
Similar to Luffy, btw. PreTS version.
Similar to Luffy, btw. PreTS version.
- 63,529
- 8,506
That too, RubberBand Man made one
- 2,047
- 778
4.4 Kilotons or Megatons? I'm not really sure actually but if you plan on making Esdeath vs Erza that's doesn't sound like a good idea. Erza matches are booty.
- 4,965
- 3,771
Megatons I believe Schnee means. Because Erza is no way near Low 7-C.
