• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Yet another Shinza Bansho CRT: Gods Physiology revision

Status
Not open for further replies.
What is left to decide here, and what are the conclusions so far?
 
Yuri is making most sense as always.

- Gods Should have infinite speed and Nigh Omnipresent inside their territory.

- They will lose Acausality type 5 cuz they only proves for type 4 like @Planck69 above clarified

- Most Gods will lose their Large size cuz most of them are human size to begin with. Merc's law is like the only one with a snake bigger than the planet.

- They are still split on the Transduality thing, but personally I am very against using a bunch of summaries from untranslated novel that we can't apply context to. Even the people who are using said scans didn't read the novel fully. So I am going to take Yuri's side here again.

-Immortality stuff will also go since no one seems to take an issue with it removal

- Also the Omniscience thing is a load of crap so it should go. Hadou are not now all knowing, Hajun is a famous example and Marie didn't know about the future Hajun destroying her. Not to mention they weren't aware of Naraka's existence so they are not even scratching the surface of the world knowledge inside the territory or outside of it

EDIT: Had to add a bunch of stuff cuz I missed it on first reply.
 
Last edited:
Okay. That is probably fine then. Should I ask more staff members to help out here?
 
Yuri is making most sense as always.

- Most Gods will lose their Large size cuz most of them are human size to begin with. Merc's law is like the only one with a snake bigger than the planet.
Infera actually gave some good stuff for possible Large Size with Hado Gods. Unless you meant Pseudo/Gudo by "most gods".
 
Okay. That is probably fine then. Should I ask more staff members to help out here?
Hopefully it doesn't take a millennia before some staff that cares about the verse shows up like last big thread.

Infera actually gave some good stuff for possible Large Size with Hado Gods. Unless you meant Pseudo/Gudo by "most gods".
Wasn't most of his point about "presence" or are these the same thing? Magic Gods from Toaru can blow up the universe via their existence or moving an arm or a leg alone but they are still human sized.
 
You can if you think there's a need, although it seems that everything's pretty uncontroversial so far
Well, perhaps I should avoid disturbing them then.
 
I also think Large Size and Omnipresence in territory should have the same justification or be linked based on these. But yeah it seems logic to me.
 
Most Gods will lose their Large size cuz most of them are human size to begin with. Merc's law is like the only one with a snake bigger than the planet.
First by planet I hope you meant multiverse?
"The great mandala that exists across the entire cosmos"

And no Gods are extension of their law, hence they are everywhere(the omnipresence and omniscience stuff)

If a God law encompasses creation thats their size, and also u are using the apoptosis of the god before emanation? to determine their size? When u meant human size?
The human sized gods are the pseudo-gods
 
Already addressed the size thing and never disagreed with speed.

They are not omniscience tho lol.
 
I have a bone to pick with the immortality stuff,

Ootake and Yakou killing their concept of death to come back
This is one of the reason that you think they dont qualify for tier 5
But ootake kills concept and erases anything or story from their beginning till the end, so I dont think what was happening was conventional death but simply erasure of their concept
I mean thats the entire thing machina hax is based on

Then we have the way ren was able to survive his punch by restarting another story at the moment of machina punch

So in the yakou vs ootake, what was happening by ootake fist was not conventional death but EE on conceptual level
 
I have a bone to pick with the immortality stuff,

So in the yakou vs ootake, what was happening by ootake fist was not conventional death but EE on conceptual level
Erasing your concept of death is conceptual by default. Also the current proof would not give type 5 anyway.
 
Erasing your concept of death is conceptual by default. Also the current proof would not give type 5 anyway.
Can you clarify this, type 5 means u can only be killed by something similar to EE which is what was happening in that fight
 
Can you clarify this, type 5 means u can only be killed by something similar to EE which is what was happening in that fight
Type 5 means you can't be killed by death manipulation in itself, and Yakou was on the death side rather than the EE side like Ootake.
Even if you discard this fight, Gods lack proof for this type of Immortality is what I meant.
 
Most of what Yuri and Infrea are saying makes sense so I agree with the changes.

Honestly I cant lie, I always found the Type 5 Acausality and Omniscience odd and had thought about making threads about them in the past so I definitely agree with those two changes.

I am curious tho why are the Gods speed Infinite? Missed that change.
 
Last edited:
Type 5 means you can't be killed by death manipulation in itself, and Yakou was on the death side rather than the EE side like Ootake.
Even if you discard this fight, Gods lack proof for this type of Immortality is what I meant.
Oh okay

I am curious tho why are the Gods speed Infinite?
Longinauze
I am thinking immeasurable since they can move and fight in timeless spaces
 
I am curious tho why are the Gods speed Infinite? Missed that change.
It was put to replace Irrelevant (and is also the most coherent imo) based on LLT ignoring distance, Mibu being able to attack even with infinite distance, Hado's law technically expanding that fast, and little stuff.
 
So do we have sufficient agreement to apply anything here, or should somebody explain the discussion and conclusions so far, after which I ask some administrators to help out?
 
I think everything's good.

Only stuff in the OP left to debate got resolved as far as I see.

May need scans for Pseudo Gods tho, if anyone has something to share.
 
Just thought about it; should Sensory truly be a Hado God thing? I mean, it's litteraly said to be a Throne function as far as I recall, and I don't remember a God using it without its help.

I also don't know why a specific instance of Mercurius talking to Shirou is considered a God thing, most of his things aren't.
 
Just realized that even the new proof for Conceptual would only apply to Hado Gods too. Isn't there any that could encompass any laws?
 
May need scans for Pseudo Gods tho, if anyone has something to share.
Which of the scan?
Or any scan?
Just thought about it; should Sensory truly be a Hado God thing? I mean, it's litteraly said to be a Throne function as far as I recall, and I don't remember a God using it without its help.
Well only gods who have reached the throne needed a sensor so far but yes I think its a throne thing, and the only two hadou that didnt take the throne Reinhard and ren, I can't remember them using sensors, but so far the ones that did are throne gods and the naraka, so yes I think it should be a throne thing,
Its should still be on throne god profiles tho
I also don't know why a specific instance of Mercurius talking to Shirou is considered a God thing, most of his things aren't.
Oh you mean when he told him about "deja vu" its not a God thing its simple telepathy
Just realized that even the new proof for Conceptual would only apply to Hado Gods too. Isn't there any that could encompass any laws?
Can you rephrase, the MLT I used did not allow me to get what you are saying totally
 
I think everything's good.

Only stuff in the OP left to debate got resolved as far as I see.

May need scans for Pseudo Gods tho, if anyone has something to share.
So they get transduality which type and acausalty which type?
Cause the rest

The large size and omnipresent has been resolved.


背後に広がる大曼荼羅が、後光のごとく輝く阿頼耶識の卍となっ て、こいつこそが無限に存在する平行宇宙を掌握する者だと告げてい

ね。


This is a quote for hajun Size and other things the fact that they are the size of what their law covers or embrace(Marie)
 
Which of the scan?
Or any scan?
Mainly the ones about controlling the flow of their Taiji
Well only gods who have reached the throne needed a sensor so far but yes I think its a throne thing, and the only two hadou that didnt take the throne Reinhard and ren, I can't remember them using sensors, but so far the ones that did are throne gods and the naraka, so yes I think it should be a throne thing,
Its should still be on throne god profiles tho
I think we should make something like "can use the Throne" or "when Throne Gods". Better to move it as something for a later revision.
Oh you mean when he told him about "deja vu" its not a God thing its simple telepathy
Yeah, it should be removed from the Gods physiology page.
Can you rephrase, the MLT I used did not allow me to get what you are saying totally
Basically the proof sent by Infera are good, but only apply to Hegemony, who bend stuff of the universe to their will through their Hegemony characteristic. I think there's scans that may explain how it applies to laws in general.
 
So they get transduality which type and acausalty which type?
Cause the rest

The large size and omnipresent has been resolved.


背後に広がる大曼荼羅が、後光のごとく輝く阿頼耶識の卍となっ て、こいつこそが無限に存在する平行宇宙を掌握する者だと告げていね。

This is a quote for hajun Size and other things the fact that they are the size of what their law covers or embrace(Marie)
Type 4 Acausality.

Transduality seems to not really be solved, so Idk for now.

It's not about Hajun's size, more the fact that the Mandala is the proof of him being the one who govern over all universes. But the scenes brought earlier should be enough regarding size.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top