- 11,191
- 12,455
Right, so I've recently gotten into Warhammer, but I can't help but notice that a lot of our pages have problems with them. Some are not so bad, but still need correction, while others actually seriously affect the quality of these things.
So, to prevent myself and any other poor sod who's interested in this from losing their minds following 600 million different threads, I'll instead compress all my problems in a neat, clean, compact little package.
So, without further ado:
The Problem with Space Marines
So, as one might have noticed, the SPEHS MAHRINES are High 8-C to High 6-C. But there are numerous problems with their current rating.
First of all, no calcs at all in the profile itself. The High 8-C rating is particularly egregious as it's justification makes no sense at first glance. I am told that calcs DO exist, however that brings us into our next problem:
The High 8-C rating is blatantly wrong. The redone calc apparently gives them only 8-C, but unfortunately I have no way to check this as I have no idea how to find it. Regardless, should this be true (and it likely is) it should be corrected, along with the other calcs being linked as well.
I would also like to take the time to clarify that this doesn't just affect the Space Marine themselves, but also the Custodes and Sororitas who scale from them directly.
Circlescaling
Now, this is not neccesarily the biggest problem ever to exist ever, but the amount of pages you have to go through to find the calcs that are linked are just absurd. Any of the Primarchs, or most powerful Champion Chaos Marines, nearly all link to their respective same character (Ka'Bandha for the Primarchs, Khar for the Chaos Marines and the few Marines that are compared to him). I think it would be far better to simply suply the calcs anyway rather than let someone navigate through a nightmarishly long list of characters to find the calcs that justify them.
As a side project, the calcs could also be added to the verse page as we do with numerous other complicated series with an enormous amount of scaling.
Conclusion
So those are my problems with the verse. I will admit I'm not the most experienced with it, so I may have goofed at some point, but nonetheless I finally got it out.
So, to prevent myself and any other poor sod who's interested in this from losing their minds following 600 million different threads, I'll instead compress all my problems in a neat, clean, compact little package.
So, without further ado:
The Problem with Space Marines
So, as one might have noticed, the SPEHS MAHRINES are High 8-C to High 6-C. But there are numerous problems with their current rating.
First of all, no calcs at all in the profile itself. The High 8-C rating is particularly egregious as it's justification makes no sense at first glance. I am told that calcs DO exist, however that brings us into our next problem:
The High 8-C rating is blatantly wrong. The redone calc apparently gives them only 8-C, but unfortunately I have no way to check this as I have no idea how to find it. Regardless, should this be true (and it likely is) it should be corrected, along with the other calcs being linked as well.
I would also like to take the time to clarify that this doesn't just affect the Space Marine themselves, but also the Custodes and Sororitas who scale from them directly.
Circlescaling
Now, this is not neccesarily the biggest problem ever to exist ever, but the amount of pages you have to go through to find the calcs that are linked are just absurd. Any of the Primarchs, or most powerful Champion Chaos Marines, nearly all link to their respective same character (Ka'Bandha for the Primarchs, Khar for the Chaos Marines and the few Marines that are compared to him). I think it would be far better to simply suply the calcs anyway rather than let someone navigate through a nightmarishly long list of characters to find the calcs that justify them.
As a side project, the calcs could also be added to the verse page as we do with numerous other complicated series with an enormous amount of scaling.
Conclusion
So those are my problems with the verse. I will admit I'm not the most experienced with it, so I may have goofed at some point, but nonetheless I finally got it out.
