- 1,009
- 797
I've been curious as to who people consider the "high and low tiers" of Melty outside of Archetype Earth for a good while now. Obviously AE is THE strongest, but how do people rank those that come after? Don't think a thread like this has been done either soooooooo
Note: Lets ignore Ryougi Shiki for this discussion since (A. I'm explicitly just referring to characters that are more known for being Tsukihime/Melty characters, and I'm very positive most still consider Ryougi as a Garden of Sinners characters even now and (B. don't want this thread to primarily be just arguing over Void and Archetype Earth, which is what would absolutely happen. So yeah. Before anyone asks, yes, Aoko however can be included here for this discussion. Also, yes, ladders from the character's respective story modes can be used. They're canon and literally all the Melty profiles on this site use them for scaling.
Anyways, obviously characters like Nero Chaos, Red Arcueid, full power Akiha and Nanaya will be regarded as some of the most powerful, but what are y'alls rankings for the cast?
Hopefully this stays civil
Edit: to be clear, I'm asking who y'all rank above who. Not specifically stats. Would honestly prefer this not getting derailed over stat debates since discussing the rankings of the characters would vastly be more interesting imo.
I'm also just referring to the playable Melty characters (at their respective peaks), but including lore important characters like Crimson Moon, Zelretch, Kiri, etc is fine. Completely optional though.
2nd edit: Ryougi can be included without Void here
Note: Lets ignore Ryougi Shiki for this discussion since (A. I'm explicitly just referring to characters that are more known for being Tsukihime/Melty characters, and I'm very positive most still consider Ryougi as a Garden of Sinners characters even now and (B. don't want this thread to primarily be just arguing over Void and Archetype Earth, which is what would absolutely happen. So yeah. Before anyone asks, yes, Aoko however can be included here for this discussion. Also, yes, ladders from the character's respective story modes can be used. They're canon and literally all the Melty profiles on this site use them for scaling.
Anyways, obviously characters like Nero Chaos, Red Arcueid, full power Akiha and Nanaya will be regarded as some of the most powerful, but what are y'alls rankings for the cast?
Hopefully this stays civil
Edit: to be clear, I'm asking who y'all rank above who. Not specifically stats. Would honestly prefer this not getting derailed over stat debates since discussing the rankings of the characters would vastly be more interesting imo.
I'm also just referring to the playable Melty characters (at their respective peaks), but including lore important characters like Crimson Moon, Zelretch, Kiri, etc is fine. Completely optional though.
2nd edit: Ryougi can be included without Void here
Last edited: