- 20,105
- 10,899
I'm on Repp's side here. There's no proof that TSB can destroy souls, otherwise all the Edo Tenseis that have been attacked by them wouldn't even have their final goodbyes in the end.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
TSB soul destruction!
- Thread starter Dzhindzholia
- Start date
- Status
- 14,956
- 1,831
It destroys the souls attached to the part of the body it disintegrates. As seen by Minato's soul not having his arms as he leaves the Edo tensei body.Theglassman12 said:
- 14,956
- 1,831
I dont know why we are acting like soul manipulation is new for Naruto lol. It was a thing ever since Pain.
- 20,105
- 10,899
Is the databook even reliable?? Cause it has some very stupid claims that makes no sense, like Universe Temari.Kepekley23 said:
- 20,105
- 10,899
@Rocker what does that have to do with this thread? No one ever said that.
- 15,332
- 7,563
Universal Temari is a mistranslation.
It is reliable as long as it doesn't contradict the series or it's an outlier.
It is reliable as long as it doesn't contradict the series or it's an outlier.
- 15,332
- 7,563
Also, I'd appreciate if I didn't have to deal with the Databook fallacy again.
- 14,956
- 1,831
Ho boy the usual universal Temari as has been said 100 million times that is a mistranslation. The databook has never made claims that go against the manga.Theglassman12 said:
- 14,956
- 1,831
I am not saying that anyone said that but I dont know why TSBs having soul manipulation is such an extraodinary claim when they are made by the guy who first manifested the rinnengan which have soul based abilities and split the sould of the ten-tails into 9 pieces.Theglassman12 said:
- 8,438
- 3,294
This looks like a hostile repeat of other threads that isn't going anywhere. Seems like there is simply no evidence to be found; only conjecture here.
Should this be closed?
Should this be closed?
- 4,143
- 571
- Thread starter
- #54
"You completely lack proof"
Are you sure about that?Minato's ghost isn't proof?
I see,you are trying your best to debunk it now.
"when a confirmed in-canon mechanic that explains the situation perfectly exists."
What are you even talking about?Minato was released,his soul must regenerate instantly,
"When a soul is released from the Impure World Reincarnation, their body disintegrates back into dust and the sacrifice's corpse will be left lying in the debris. The soul may linger briefly - with their personality restored if it was being suppressed - to leave parting words or take final actions. Souls released by their summoner will be enveloped in light throughout the process"
Also,Edo Tensei can only reanimate those who were in the Pure Land,Minato never was there(Oro still reanimated him).So,going by your logic his soul should regerate since he never was in pure land and his hands can't go there on their own.He ascended Pure Land only After Hagoromo released Edo Tensei.
Are you sure about that?Minato's ghost isn't proof?
I see,you are trying your best to debunk it now.
"when a confirmed in-canon mechanic that explains the situation perfectly exists."
What are you even talking about?Minato was released,his soul must regenerate instantly,
"When a soul is released from the Impure World Reincarnation, their body disintegrates back into dust and the sacrifice's corpse will be left lying in the debris. The soul may linger briefly - with their personality restored if it was being suppressed - to leave parting words or take final actions. Souls released by their summoner will be enveloped in light throughout the process"
Also,Edo Tensei can only reanimate those who were in the Pure Land,Minato never was there(Oro still reanimated him).So,going by your logic his soul should regerate since he never was in pure land and his hands can't go there on their own.He ascended Pure Land only After Hagoromo released Edo Tensei.
- 11,444
- 1,998
@Rocker
But the TSBs haven't done anything like that. Your only on-screen evidence is an armless Minato which can be explained through mechanics that are actually known to happen in the series.
@Assaltwaffle
I really want to close this and every other thread like it.
But the TSBs haven't done anything like that. Your only on-screen evidence is an armless Minato which can be explained through mechanics that are actually known to happen in the series.
@Assaltwaffle
I really want to close this and every other thread like it.
- 15,332
- 7,563
It shouldn't be closed yet.
I'd like a summary of the discussion. I know it's about the TSB's soul-hax, but this thread is chaotic and hard to follow.
I'd like a summary of the discussion. I know it's about the TSB's soul-hax, but this thread is chaotic and hard to follow.
- 14,956
- 1,831
Man I dont particularly disagree, but I dont think that the soul of the arms not being there are completely explained not without speculation as well. But since we dont have much more evidence I think it is okay to close this.Reppuzan said:
- 4,143
- 571
- Thread starter
- #59
Close this thread after you debunk everything i wrote.It is like you don't allow any upgrades for Naruto.
We can't make a conclusion without a debate!
We can't make a conclusion without a debate!
- 14,956
- 1,831
Anyway I have said all I can about this I think I am out unless someone has something new to offer.
- 7,271
- 2,232
TSBs negate edo tensei, Obito states this himself.
1. "Does Sakura soul have a stab wound?
Maybe? but 100 healings should help with that."
Please stop. Sakura doesn't have a hole in her soul nor can she regenerate it
2. If it cancels the jutsu then the soul is no longer bounded to the part of the body that was erased (
3. It never said it erases souls, it said it turns all jutsu to nothing. Doesn't affect anything besides jutsu
1. "Does Sakura soul have a stab wound?
Maybe? but 100 healings should help with that."
Please stop. Sakura doesn't have a hole in her soul nor can she regenerate it
2. If it cancels the jutsu then the soul is no longer bounded to the part of the body that was erased (
3. It never said it erases souls, it said it turns all jutsu to nothing. Doesn't affect anything besides jutsu
- 14,956
- 1,831
I dont know what you want me to stop I provided my evidence for that in my arguments above. And you have no proof that she did or did not have a hole in her soul that is the point of the argument in the first place.Unite My Rice said:
- 15,332
- 7,563
Well, that Sakura can regenerate souls isn't a stretch, seeing as Tsunade could regenerate Orochimaru's arms after Hiruzen's DRS.
That said, it is specifically said that TSBs negate Edo Tensei. I don't see how it can be argued that it targets souls directly. The Minato thing is explained in the story.
That said, it is specifically said that TSBs negate Edo Tensei. I don't see how it can be argued that it targets souls directly. The Minato thing is explained in the story.
- 7,271
- 2,232
Absence of evidence is evidence of absence. Stop trying to reverse-counter every debunk against these swiss cheese hole riddled arguments.
Absence of proof of her healing her soul = she can't.
Absence of proof of her healing her soul = she can't.
- 4,143
- 571
- Thread starter
- #65
"It never said it erases souls, it said it turns all jutsu to nothing. Doesn't affect anything besides jutsu"
What?So,now the technique can affect only things that it mentioned to affect?Disagree completely.
What?So,now the technique can affect only things that it mentioned to affect?Disagree completely.
- 14,956
- 1,831
The proof is that she has 100 healings which Tsunade has and Tsunade said she has passed on all her knowledge to Sakura as her student Tsunade said she can heal Orochimaru's soul.Unite My Rice said:
- 15,332
- 7,563
What proves it can target souls?
The TSB naturally negates Edo Tensei.
The TSB naturally negates Edo Tensei.
- 7,271
- 2,232
"What?So,now the technique can affect only things that it mentioned to affect?Disagree completely."
Uh yeah, otherwise you're just saying things that aren't substantiated by anything credible or official.
Uh yeah, otherwise you're just saying things that aren't substantiated by anything credible or official.
- 4,143
- 571
- Thread starter
- #69
@Unite My Rice
Chyo was able to revive gaara with her healing jutsu.Chakra is a spiritual and physicall energy,don't ignore the word spiritual.
Chyo was able to revive gaara with her healing jutsu.Chakra is a spiritual and physicall energy,don't ignore the word spiritual.
- 4,143
- 571
- Thread starter
- #70
@Unite My Rice
Then,you need to make the revision for the whole wiki.
Then,you need to make the revision for the whole wiki.
- 7,271
- 2,232
Chiyo used a life-force tranferring technique on Gaara. She died to give him life.
But this is about truth seeking balls.
But this is about truth seeking balls.
- 15,332
- 7,563
Chiyo's Healing Jutsu is an extremely special situation, as it exchanges her own life to restore the dead. It doesn't apply to the TSBs.
There is zero evidence of what is being proposed here.
There is zero evidence of what is being proposed here.
- 16,172
- 11,538
Why am i laughing at this...Unite My Rice said:
- 4,143
- 571
- Thread starter
- #74
I just want to admit that Chyo was able to revive already dead Gaara and that Sakura can heal a little hole in her body and spirit,since chakra is a spiritual and physicall energy.
- 15,332
- 7,563
Chakra is spiritual and physical, but very few techniques can master or make use of its spiritual side.
Regardless of that, what is the evidence for the TSBs destroying souls? You keep avoiding the question.
Regardless of that, what is the evidence for the TSBs destroying souls? You keep avoiding the question.
- 4,143
- 571
- Thread starter
- #77
I have a feat that supports my opinion about TSBs,but you can't denie it clearly,since Minato was not from the Pure Land his arms should have regenerated (going by Repp's logic) , but they didn't,TSBs can affect souls.
Edit: I don't avoid the question,look at the OP and everything i wrote.
Edit: I don't avoid the question,look at the OP and everything i wrote.
- 14,956
- 1,831
Hey if you want to say something is wank at least give your arguments for why, if not stop derailing threads.SchroKatze said:
- 15,332
- 7,563
@Schro
You are not helping.
@Dzhind
Except the Edo Tensei is naturally negated by a TSB. I've already posted the scans.
You are not helping.
@Dzhind
Except the Edo Tensei is naturally negated by a TSB. I've already posted the scans.
- 15,332
- 7,563
I'm all for giving you guys a chance to speak, but if you don't have anything other than the Minato feat, I'm afraid we will have to close this thread.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
