• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Truth-Seeking Ball V2

Status
Not open for further replies.
(The last thread was closed prematurely)


First of all, it should be acknowledged that Narutoworld operates under its own laws. Jutsus require chakra, & chakra is a product of energy (spiritual & physical energy).

EDO Tensei is a essentially a summoning jutsu, summoning the spirits of the dead to the world to do thy bidding. Spirits are intangible but since Narutoworld has its own sets of laws, ninjas can interact with spirits (Yin specialist have better luck doing so tho); for example, Dan's spirit jutsu— Yin energy release — was trapped inside a barrier ninjas made during the War Arc.

The TSB by itself is the encapsulation of all elements and the concept of yin & yang to the highest degree; Of course it shouldn't be strange to see it interact with spirits in the fashion Omimi had described.

If the issue here is confusion surrounding how the spirit-hand of Minato is eradicated (or sent to the afterlife), I say there shouldn't be much issue understanding how it's done. Just look up the definition of chakra (& spirit, physical) in the context of Naruto world & recall that Sarutobi already displayed the ability to take of Orochimaru's hand in part 1 naruto with the Death God summoning; & how Tsunade could essentially restore the souless hand with her medical expertise.
 
This is likely going to be closed, what I will say is this. When we see minatos Soul ascending, his arms are still missing from where the TSB severed them.

Take of that what you will.
 
It's simple really. Take Itachi accession as example. His spirit was intact.
Itachi-leaves-sasuke-e1340790428985
But with Minato, the hand is gone for good.

You can obliterate an EDO Tensei manifested (tangible) bodies with a nuke but it will always reform. With TSB, all things that don't have Six paths chakra (sage chakra) in the Narutoworld (body, spirit, chakra etc) is erased & even EDO tensei would cease to be
4990557-viz minato arm (1)
 
I once read that the tsb uses yin-yang release to nullify ninjutsu edo tensei is a ninjutsu so tsb must have nullified the jutsu's Regenerationn
 
Has the soul ever been described or considered an "element" in Naruto? If not, then has it ever been stated indirectly or directly in any of the descriptions of the TSB powers to affect the souls of whoever it touches? If not, the a final question what're are the chances that this whole minato issue isn't simply an artistic error?
 
Davidsteel1 said:
Has the soul ever been described or considered an "element" in Naruto? If not, then has it ever been stated indirectly or directly in any of the descriptions of the TSB powers to affect the souls of whoever it touches? If not, the a final question what're are the chances that this whole minato issue isn't simply an artistic error?
soul = chakra in nv
 
No soul doesn't equal chakra, it's part of what makes chakra yes but only a component of it. Besides the TSB negates nin-jutsu not chakra itself
 
0690-012
0591-006
0591-009


red color = soul

black color = edo body


red color = soul

black color = edo body <---------soul---------->

<-------edo body------>


0691-022
0691-024


0591-001





edo body------>


try to compare them and tell me what is this--------------------->





<---------soul


<-------edo body


is it soul or edo body

unlike edo body soul have no mark on thier body or face

all soul in nv look white color

and edo body has normel color
 
If staff members close threads, do not immediately create new ones.
 
Goudama's essentially negate all ninjutsu, that includes the Edo's ability to regenerate the vessel. The spirits missing limbs are the result of the goudama's ability to turn anything it touches to dust, similar to dust release. Souls in Naruto are not intangible, Naruto was able to pull his own soul back to his body.
 
I was talking about the Goudama's ability to turn anything it touches to dust, similar to dust release.
 
I'm really getting annoyed with you Omimi.

The only canon Yin-Yang Techniques are the Creation of All Things Jutsu (whose only feat was creating the Tailed Beasts), TSBs and ETSBs. That's it.

You cannot use the element argument when no specific element has ever been tied to the manipulation of souls. That's like me saying, "Captain Planet has all powers combined, so he can definitely manipulate space-time even though his form is comprised of Earth, Fire, Water, Wind, and Heart". There's no correlation. End of story.

Your only evidence is a single panel that has no corroboration with anything else in the series in function or design.

I'm still firmly against this until someone else can convince me otherwise.
 
We should probably close this thread, and tell the participants to not bring up the subject again then.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top