- 5,230
- 2,318
i have literally read through the entire thing once and am reading through it again, i know homestuckIf anyone knows Homestuck is this true? because if it is then he'll go back to just the 5th spot then.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
i have literally read through the entire thing once and am reading through it again, i know homestuckIf anyone knows Homestuck is this true? because if it is then he'll go back to just the 5th spot then.
he shouldn't he gets haxed to hell and back and then slappedJohn actually stomped Oryx in a match if memory serves lol
OK? i'm still going ask for more conformation from another knowledgeable member of the verse since i don't want to consistently change his placement when i could have another knowledgeable member of Homestuck co-sign what you said and not deal with that possibly because of my ignorance of Homestuck.i have literally read through the entire thing once and am reading through it again, i know homestuck
UKG and Homura Exist and passively stomp john, madoka also has several passives that let her stomp john tooMadoka also stomped John at one point (then again John’s hax was Low 1-C back in January 2020, although he lost cuz she had Type 5 Acasul)
He is right, John has no passive. His 1-A stuff is by causing a narrative paradox that can destroy a 1-A setting(Paradox Space), not instant in any way,If anyone knows Homestuck is this true? because if it is then he'll go back to just the 5th spot then.
Alright so he should just take the 5th spotHe is right, John has no passive. His 1-A stuff is by causing a narrative paradox that can destroy a 1-A setting(Paradox Space), not instant in any way,not in character either nor it is directly done by him, but by someone that has his same power it's more of, he is able to.
Or by just doing retcon fuckery, since retcon stuff as a whole is still 1-A in scale and potencyHe is right, John has no passive. His 1-A stuff is by causing a narrative paradox that can destroy a 1-A setting(Paradox Space), not instant in any way,not in character either nor it is directly done by him, but by someone that has his same power it's more of, he is able to.
Alright then he'll have the 5th Placement then.He is right, John has no passive. His 1-A stuff is by causing a narrative paradox that can destroy a 1-A setting(Paradox Space), not instant in any way,not in character either nor it is directly done by him, but by someone that has his same power it's more of, he is able to.
nah she doesnt really have a way to deal with them, john can by way of retconning them, but aradia really cantActually, shouldn’t Aradia also go into 5th with John? She also has Type 5 Acasul
That makes sensenah she doesnt really have a way to deal with them, john can by way of retconning them, but aradia really cant
BumpSo i'm going through evaluating profiles that don't meet my standards which have been set here.
This is something that i like the users of this thread to have input on. So if you believe a certain profile should stay or go explain to me why it should stay or go.
With that prefacing done lets begin.
High 1-B: The Watchers (Reasons: Doesn’t have a verses page, most likely doesn’t have any active members and is incredibly bare-bones. Lacking scans for any of its abilities, having tons of spelling and formatting mistakes. Leaning towards removal)
1-B The Higher Entities (Reasons: Doesn’t have active supporters to argue on its behalf but most of their powers are explained well enough and a decent amount of their powers have citations for them. Neutral leaning towards allowing them to stay)
1-C Star Maker (Reasons: Doesn’t have a verses page, doesn’t have citations for any of its abilities and most likely doesn’t have any active supporters. It does possess a blog that explains its tiering but that's about it. Leaning towards removal)
1-C The Quantum Man (Reasons: Just look at the profile, that shit should be deleted from existence itself, much less from this thread. Leaning towards absolute removal)
So are saying your neutral on Star Maker's removal? since that was the only one you didn't address in your original comment.For quantum man if you think it should be deleted bring it up on the profile deletion thread everything else I shared my thoughts on or am neutral.
No. i don't believe it should necessarily be deleted but i'm going to make the case that it has to go through at least Massive re-works before it comes any-where close to resembling something usable within a Vs-Debate.Was the quantum man deleted.
Don't really care that it was accepted by multiple people who're knowledgeable of the verse. That isn't my problem with the profile, one of my main problem with it is the tiering. Specifically his 1-A reasoning given just being stated to have a "Tegmark's Type 4 Multiverse" without proper context/citations and other supporting evidence wouldn't grant you that tier.Quantum Man had several crts last tier and it was accepted by multiple people who are knowledgeable (staff and non-staff) on tiering and the like, so if you have problems with it make a crt.
Just look at its history and see who posted it, who worked on it and then see who is still active. Don't insert your self rule that no one agreed or changes rules that lots if not all users agreed till now from.
The page isn't good as i already explained, it doesn't have either nor does The QM have references to literally any of his tiering nor P&A's section. It's completely blank which wouldn't be tolerated for any other series in this Wiki. I couldn't make a profile for say Bleach without providing explanations for the abilities, citations behind each asserted ability and tier etc.If the page is good, has quotes (scans/blogs), or references then it doesn't matter if it has active or not otherwise we would have deleted them.
I don't need "Knowledgeable Members" to agree with me that the profile is out-dated for the profile to be out-dated, That's fallacious reasoning. Well if someone that is following this thread is a knowledgeable member about Mortebianca but won't debate on The Quantum Man's behalf then tough-shit if their's no-one who's willing to debate this character he's being removed for other characters that have people who are actually going to debate for their placement.Sure on those that knowledgeable members agree are outdated not those that you decided so. Not just the people who follow this thread are all "knowledgeable members" about a character/series. For example, The Starmaker by Olaf Stapledon is one of my all time favorite sci-fi book, i've read it multiple times thus making me a knowledgeable member just that I'm not interesed in debating it. Or take Naruto for example, how many memembers knowledgeable do you think are present here? Lots, sure but there are even more that don't follow the thread.
no. Its just that the rest have smurf hax. Sailor moon is on the non smurf listI am surprised to see a Sailor Moon character has not made it to this list. I remember the times from 2017-2019. Wasn't this verse was like, one of the most haxed verse where even fodders would solo all of dbs? Did this verse get downgraded?
most of their hax is thought based , attack based or passive? I remember a man constantly pissing off everyone in reddit by calling us "sailor moon fanboys" when i tried to debate that sailor moon beats xeno goku with hax. That was before dbh became haxed btw.no. Its just that the rest have smurf hax. Sailor moon is on the non smurf list
the others have passive smurf haxmost of their hax is thought based , attack based or passive?
does sailor moon has any passives?the others have passive smurf hax
A couple but nothing too crazy a least when compared to fellow magical girl verse PMMM with the god tiers having several offensive passives, a boat load of abilities and potent defensive hax too (Acausality type 5, NEP, AE type 1, etc).does sailor moon has any passives?
And then there are verses like misfit and instant death that takes the terms "Haxed AF" too far.A couple but nothing too crazy a least when compared to fellow magical girl verse PMMM with the god tiers having several offensive passives, a boat load of abilities and potent defensive hax too (Acausality type 5, NEP, AE type 1, etc).
PMMM is the perfect example of being "haxxed AF" without being smurfs yet still strong enough to make this list (filled with 1-A or above smurfs) while Sailor moon is overall more "balanced" in terms of hax, potent but not too oppressive.
Tied with 11-CLike High 3-A is one of the tiers that has some of the least amount of Smurfs in it (Only 2 Smurfs within it).
Pretty much.Tied with 11-C
Could you link these profiles by any-chance? it would make my job easier.Alright so I decided to look at the non smurf list to see who could fill some spots:
High 1-C 5th Characters from Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
4-C 5th Teridax
Low 4-C 5th HIM
10-C 5th Mysterious Stranger
Mysterious StrangerCould you link these profiles by any-chance? it would make my job easier.
Edit: Nevermind, Also Gurren Lagann is already on this list, tied for the 3rd placement with Will of the Honkai.
they are already on the listAlright so I decided to look at the non smurf list to see who could fill some spots:
High 1-C 5th Characters from Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
4-C 5th Teridax
Low 4-C 5th HIM
10-C 5th Mysterious Stranger
I missed one sorrythey are already on the list
No plothaxwhy is the admnistrator below scp. They are from the same verse. They should share the spot