The now overdue Calebcity profile creation

[Dalesean027]

Anywho since this has been so thoroughly rejected this can be closed. GGs boys

Completely killed my hope for the RDC profiles I wanted to do but it is what it is, we move

 

[Shmooply]

I wanted to do but it is what it is, we move

For now...

 

[TheMassivlyUnkn0wn]

RDC?

 

[Dalesean027]

RDC?

Rdcworld1

 

[ZillertheBucko]

Anywho since this has been so thoroughly rejected this can be closed. GGs boys

Since when was it rejected?

 

[Dalesean027]

Since when was it rejected?

Was Ant, damage, and DMUA's thorough anti this profile not a rejection of this profile.

Ovens and KT only agree if we butcher this profile into several profiles which ruins the whole thing so in my eyes that's still a rejection

 

[KingNanaya]

Was Ant, damage, and DMUA's thorough anti this profile not a rejection of this profile.

Ovens and KT only agree if we butcher this profile into several profiles which ruins the whole thing so in my eyes that's still a rejection

yeah, having 15 different profiles named Caleb sounds kinda stupid

 

[Eden_Warlock99]

I wonder if we can put it in the (superior) FC/OC wiki, or nah?

 

[Damage3245]

I wonder if we can put it in the (superior) FC/OC wiki, or nah?

It may be fine there.

 

[Dalesean027]

I wonder if we can put it in the (superior) FC/OC wiki, or nah?

Well yeah but that still defeats the point

 

[Eden_Warlock99]

Well yeah but that still defeats the point

Once the Versus Thread Revision happens, Caleb would be able to have valid matches with VsBattles characters

 

[ZillertheBucko]

Was Ant, damage, and DMUA's thorough anti this profile not a rejection of this profile.

Which doesn’t mean we close the thread, we just keep debating until their minds are changed, that’s it. This is the only chance we’re gonna get so might as well not quit early.

 

[KingTempest]

Is there nothing else linking the characters to all 1 person?

 

[Dalesean027]

Is there nothing else linking the characters to all 1 person?

There could be more but the main guy git it is MIA

 

[ZillertheBucko]

Let’s just all watch every calebcity video until we can find what we need

 

[The_Yellow_Topaz]

Caleb, while in character, refers to the fact they're the same person all the time.
"The line doesn't work here", from When the Hero is as Smart as the Villain being one of the examples.​

 

[CinnabarManx421]

Yeah there’s absolutely no point in splitting this profile up into a dozen smaller more ugly profiles compared to the beautiful big one we’ve made, most of them wouldn’t have enough feats or abilities individually to be indexed in the first place.

 

[TheMassivlyUnkn0wn]

LETS GOOO THE CALEB PROFILE CAN WORK AGAIN!!!

 

[Damage3245]

Caleb, while in character, refers to the fact they're the same person all the time.
"The line doesn't work here", from When the Hero is as Smart as the Villain being one of the examples.​

What does that line have to do with it?

 

[ZillertheBucko]

What does that line have to do with it?

Are you familiar with the video it comes from?

 

[Damage3245]

Are you familiar with the video it comes from?

Yeah, I watched it.

Looks like Caleb breaking character momentarily.

It doesn't mean the characters are literally the same person.

 

[The_Yellow_Topaz]

What does that line have to do with it?

The villain character says,
"You're smarter than you look",
To which the hero replies with the forementioned line

This is a direct reference to the fact they're the same person.​

 

[ZillertheBucko]

Yeah, I watched it.

Looks like Caleb breaking character momentarily.

It doesn't mean the characters are literally the same person.

well it's evidence

 

[Damage3245]

The villain character says,
"You're smarter than you look",
To which the hero replies with the forementioned line

This is a direct reference to the fact they're the same person.​

A 4th wall reference to the fact that they both look the same because they're played by the same actor is more plausible of an interpretation than "These two are literally the same character".

 

[The_Yellow_Topaz]

A 4th wall reference to the fact that they both look the same because they're played by the same actor is more plausible of an interpretation than "These two are literally the same character".

Both are possible, so it works as support either way
I never framed this as the "end-all be-all" piece of evidence after all​

 

[CinnabarManx421]

Honestly it seems we’re in a stalemate. The anti Caleb side is just saying that all of the evidence is him being meta while the pro Caleb side is saying it’s him referring to it in universe. Both are plausible explanations.

 

[TheMassivlyUnkn0wn]

honestly just add the profile it harms no one

putting it on joke battles wiki feels disrespectful as it's WAY too high effort for it + no one talks on the joke battles wiki threads

 

[The_Yellow_Topaz]

Since you guys are having trouble convincing the moderators.
I decided to marathon all 230+ CalebCity videos.
It was funny as hell boi
​

SUBTITLES​

Green is an evidence in favor of OP
Red is an evidence against the OP
Yellow is a VERY strong evidence

I will be gathering evidence and counterevidence for both sides so it's fair.

A Compilation of CalebCity Comments on Characters

• Turning on someone elses shower: "Caleb calls someone called "Jordan", but we never see 'em"​
• When you have to rethink your relationship: "Main Character is referred as "Caleb" by the girl" (Caleb can SING, DAMN)​
• My Top 100 Vines: "Character is referred as "Caleb" again several times, one where he is the magician"​
• My Top 100 Vines: "Character played by Caleb is referred as John, we also have other different names when Caleb is playing a parody character from an already known series like Link and Anikin"​
• When you decide to turn your life around for the better: "Former Robber is referred as "Mr Grill""​
• Every Scary Movie Trailer: "Character is referred as Tyler"​
• Things you want to do, but don't: "Caleb is the character again"​
• How the writers of some Animes just be letting the villain's abilities make no sense: "Villain is referred as Koa for the first time"​
• When you travel through time to stop yourself from making a dumb mistake: "Caleb time travels to warn himself"​
• When you get too serious playing Basketball: "Caleb is referred by name again"​
• I will no longer be adding clips where Caleb is making a parody of already existing characters, there are more during the run of his channel, but it's clear those don't scale to his profile.​
• Drama shows after 12 seasons: "John comes back" (I don't know if characters being consistent is a pro or a con)​
• Cutting a knife with a 1000 degree MARSHMELLOW and The new invisible cloak just came in!: "Guy with Glasses is a consistent character in both"​
• Your whole funny bone: "Calebcity directly transitions between the reality and the in-universe dimension"​
• The first plant to become a venus fly trap and if insects had to introduce themselves: "These videos show continuity, as the plant that turns into a venus fly trap is the crazy plant referred in the later video"​
• Basically how trying to stay neutral is: "Caleb is the character here as well, even though he has a different outfit. Characters in the CalebCity Universe are recognized by their outfit"​
• Someone tries to rob an upcomning rapper: "Robber is named Austin"​
• I hate porta potties: "Description says "This always happens to me, they just caught it on camera this time." suggesting the skit character is Caleb, and in some capacity, the characters are the actor himself"​
• The "where I'm from" type people: "To further reiterate this, description says "I never finished my story either""​
• Basically ANY voice command device: "MC's friend is called Chris"​
• Just some throw away videos: "Very definitive answer, all his in-universe skits are played by his in-universe character in a skit. Description also says "me doing this""​
• When the Hero is just as smart as the villain: "Villain says "you're smarter than you look", and the hero responds by stating the line doesn't work here, aluding to the fact they're the same person"​

...
Aight, I'm tired, I'll update this later.​

 

[KingNanaya]

I decided to marathon all 230+ CalebCity videos.​

damn, without me???

 

[TheMassivlyUnkn0wn]

Theres more evidence supporting the OP than evidence against it, I think that seals the deal

 

[Dalesean027]

Since you guys are having trouble convincing the moderators.
I decided to marathon all 230+ CalebCity videos.
It was funny as hell boi
​

SUBTITLES​

Green is an evidence in favor of OP
Red is an evidence against the OP

I will be gathering evidence and counterevidence for both sides so it's fair.

A Compilation of CalebCity Comments on Characters

• Turning on someone elses shower: "Caleb calls someone called "Jordan", but we never see 'em"​
• When you have to rethink your relationship: "Main Character is referred as "Caleb" by the girl" (Caleb can SING, DAMN)​
• My Top 100 Vines: "Character is referred as "Caleb" again several times, one where he is the magician"​
• My Top 100 Vines: "Character played by Caleb is referred as John, we also have other different names when Caleb is playing a parody character from an already known series like Link and Anikin"​
• When you decide to turn your life around for the better: "Former Robber is referred as "Mr Grill""​
• Every Scary Movie Trailer: "Character is referred as Tyler"​
• Things you want to do, but don't: "Caleb is the character again"​
• How the writers of some Animes just be letting the villain's abilities make no sense: "Villain is referred as Koa for the first time"​
• When you travel through time to stop yourself from making a dumb mistake: "Caleb time travels to warn himself"​
• When you get too serious playing Basketball: "Caleb is referred by name again"​

...
Aight, I'm tired, I'll update this later.​

Bump

 

[The_Yellow_Topaz]

Since you guys are having trouble convincing the moderators.
I decided to marathon all 230+ CalebCity videos.
It was funny as hell boi
​

SUBTITLES​

Green is an evidence in favor of OP
Red is an evidence against the OP
Yellow is a VERY strong evidence

I will be gathering evidence and counterevidence for both sides so it's fair.

A Compilation of CalebCity Comments on Characters

• Turning on someone elses shower: "Caleb calls someone called "Jordan", but we never see 'em"​
• When you have to rethink your relationship: "Main Character is referred as "Caleb" by the girl" (Caleb can SING, DAMN)​
• My Top 100 Vines: "Character is referred as "Caleb" again several times, one where he is the magician"​
• My Top 100 Vines: "Character played by Caleb is referred as John, we also have other different names when Caleb is playing a parody character from an already known series like Link and Anikin"​
• When you decide to turn your life around for the better: "Former Robber is referred as "Mr Grill""​
• Every Scary Movie Trailer: "Character is referred as Tyler"​
• Things you want to do, but don't: "Caleb is the character again"​
• How the writers of some Animes just be letting the villain's abilities make no sense: "Villain is referred as Koa for the first time"​
• When you travel through time to stop yourself from making a dumb mistake: "Caleb time travels to warn himself"​
• When you get too serious playing Basketball: "Caleb is referred by name again"​
• I will no longer be adding clips where Caleb is making a parody of already existing characters, there are more during the run of his channel, but it's clear those don't scale to his profile.​
• Drama shows after 12 seasons: "John comes back" (I don't know if characters being consistent is a pro or a con)​
• Cutting a knife with a 1000 degree MARSHMELLOW and The new invisible cloak just came in!: "Guy with Glasses is a consistent character in both"​
• Your whole funny bone: "Calebcity directly transitions between the reality and the in-universe dimension"​
• The first plant to become a venus fly trap and if insects had to introduce themselves: "These videos show continuity, as the plant that turns into a venus fly trap is the crazy plant referred in the later video"​
• Basically how trying to stay neutral is: "Caleb is the character here as well, even though he has a different outfit. Characters in the CalebCity Universe are recognized by their outfit"​
• Someone tries to rob an upcomning rapper: "Robber is named Austin"​
• I hate porta potties: "Description says "This always happens to me, they just caught it on camera this time." suggesting the skit character is Caleb, and in some capacity, the characters are the actor himself"​
• The "where I'm from" type people: "To further reiterate this, description says "I never finished my story either""​
• Basically ANY voice command device: "MC's friend is called Chris"​
• Just some throw away videos: "Very definitive answer, all his in-universe skits are played by his in-universe character in a skit. Description also says "me doing this""​
• When the Hero is just as smart as the villain: "Villain says "you're smarter than you look", and the hero responds by stating the line doesn't work here, aluding to the fact they're the same person"​

...
Aight, I'm tired, I'll update this later.​

UPDATED: 3 Years of content watched, 3 Years of content to go!

 

[Godernet]

Holy shit why am I only now seeing this.

I’ve seen the profile before and agree

W Calebcity fans

 

[Grand_Astartes]

Agree with everything besides the Mid Godly but that is already fixed + Caleb goat

 

[TheMassivlyUnkn0wn]

i think its currently 16 videos with evidence for the OP and 7 with evidence against it. we're doing good

 

[ZillertheBucko]

If this doesn’t go through we’re starting our own scaling index site and becoming “vs wiki but with Caleb” and it’ll be a hit

 

[TheMassivlyUnkn0wn]

honestly just put it on the codex they'd probably allow it. they already allow youtubers so uh.

codex 1 vsbw 0

 

[CinnabarManx421]

If this doesn’t go through we’re starting our own scaling index site and becoming “vs wiki but with Caleb” and it’ll be a hit

“We’ll make our own battle board, with Blackjack and hookers!”

 

[Antvasima]

Can somebody explain why this page would not break our rules please?

 

[Emirp sumitpo]

Can somebody explain why this page would not break our rules please?

We literally did so in the OP.