• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The now overdue Calebcity profile creation

Status
Not open for further replies.
To get us back on topic, I will be removing Antvasima's comments above and my own. This is a blatant derail of the thread's intended purpose.

EDIT: There. Now let's please move on from that. There is nothing for you to respond to there now, Phoenks.
 
Since you guys are having trouble convincing the moderators.
I decided to marathon all 230+ CalebCity videos.
It was funny as hell boi

SUBTITLES​

Green is an evidence in favor of OP
Red is an evidence against the OP
Yellow is a VERY strong evidence

I will be gathering evidence and counterevidence for both sides so it's fair.

A Compilation of CalebCity Comments on Characters
...
Aight, I'm tired, I'll update this later.​
Bumping this so new people don't need to scroll to find it
 
The vast majority of human beings here want a Caleb profile, the vs wiki was made for a hobby, people want to have fun every once in a while
simply add the profile
 
The fact that there’s an in-universe Caleb that creates all the content, almost everyone is named Caleb, and there are multiple meta references to the fact that they’re all Caleb, on top of the fact that a non composite version of Caleb would offer the more boring shit ever seen on this website….
 
Since you guys are having trouble convincing the moderators.
I decided to marathon all 230+ CalebCity videos.
It was funny as hell boi

SUBTITLES​

Green is an evidence in favor of OP
Red is an evidence against the OP
Yellow is a VERY strong evidence

I will be gathering evidence and counterevidence for both sides so it's fair.

A Compilation of CalebCity Comments on Characters
...
Aight, I'm tired, I'll update this later.​
I mean considering all of this coupled with the evidence in the note and the fact that there's more thats not even here I'd say there's plenty evidence for them being the same caleb it's really just about how comfortable wiki staff feel about it since its making everyone(staff) uneasy and think this will be the like the rising of the anti-christ on the wiki or something
 
Comically overpowered characters have a habit of bothering people, but like....thats also just a lot of VS debating in general, so thats whatever
Yeah I know I'm not really tripping over it it's just kinda silly so I gotta make my jokes here and there🙏😌
 
also i stand by the take that this argument is just another way of saying "we dont allow funny characters even if they have feats"

like let me put scott the woz against generic anime character #591
Time to calc an explosion in Borderline Forever

Anyways I'm leaning more towards agreeing with the OP right now, it definitely seems ridiculous on paper, but we literally have a Logan Paul profile so this should be fine. Even without that, I'd lean towards agreeing
 
Spongebob is a published Cartoon character made by a well known company, so I don't we can fully compare that to Calebcity.
Why does that make it better or worse than an independent property?

Calebcity is well known enough, Vs Battles have indexed lesser famous profiles.
Vs Battles have indexed indie properties before, Helluva Boss being a prime example.
Live-Action is also indexed on the wiki.

So;
being a cartoon,
being well known,
and coming from a company
are things that don't really influence the decision of making a profile or not. They never were.

So in what way is Calebcity different than Spongebob? In what way that matters, are they different?

I thought the requirements were;
-being fiction
-have feats
-be relevant
?​
 
I don't mind it being a viable verse or not.

I'm objecting to it all being considered a single composite character.

Characters all being named "Caleb" (which isn't the case anyway) does not mean each one is literally Caleb.

I mean, look at this justification:


"Seemingly change his character despite contradictions". You realize that the video is just a parody of drama shows that end up having terrible writing/plots? So the characters inside the skit giving contradictory information doesn't mean he is bending reality to make it all make sense... It just means the writing of the skit inside the video doesn't make sense and the fictional series is full of plot holes, plot twists and terrible writing.

Why does both Calebs being the same person be the only rational explanation here?
 
I don't mind it being a viable verse or not.

I'm objecting to it all being considered a single composite character.

Characters all being named "Caleb" (which isn't the case anyway) does not mean each one is literally Caleb.

I mean, look at this justification:
look at this one instead
 
Why does both Calebs being the same person be the only rational explanation here?
Because the descriptions makes clear that it's him, Caleb, who is in those skits!
Again, look at the compilation of the evidence!

which is still halfway done

The descriptions of some videos refers to the character in it as "me, I", etc
It's natural that all Calebs are in-universe versions of the actual Caleb!
Occam's Razor.​
 
meh, instead of debating for half a century we could just put, the following:


Caleb probably has the powers of all other characters because they are him but it's not clear if this is 4th wall breaking reference
 
Nah because its pretty blatant I'd rather not have an entire profile of possibly ratings and its pretty explicit
9-A, possibly 8-C, possibly 8-B, possibly 8-A, possibly 7-C, possibly 7-B, possibly 7-A, possibly 6-C, possibly 6-B, possibly 6-A, possibly 5-C, possibly, 5-B, possibly 5-A, possibly 4-C, possibly 4-B, possibly 4-A, possibly 3-C, possibly 3-B, possibly 3-A, possibly 2-C, likely 0, higher with YouTube Algorithm
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top