- 13,711
- 3,929
If I'm being honest here, I do not like how the stats for the series is handled. The way the stats are currently handled in terms of physicals is how (Base) Timmy has a variable rating from 10-C to 8-B, and yet nobody scales to his high end rating for some reason despite the fact that there have been instances of characters being able to physically harm Timmy on multiple occasions throughout the 10 seasons the show has been around for (IE. Francis, Vicky, etc). Apparently, this reason is because of "Toon force"... except the reason Timmy has a high end rating in the first place is because he is literally scaled from his Cleft form which is merely him wearing a costume that isn't implied to be making him stronger, with said form allowing him to keep up with villains who can keep up with the Crimson Chin.
The thing is, a varies rating should only be allowed if there's a given canon explanation as to why they should vary in power (IE. a fluctuating power source). It should not be given if a character is inconsistent in power, as explained on the Attack Potency page. In this case, just because Timmy can be inconsistent doesn't mean he should vary in power, because these moments of inconsistency for all we know could be PiS moments. That being said, Timmy himself has consistently done many superhuman things that I'm pretty sure no 10-C character can do, especially with this calc compilation I made that compiles many superhuman feats that prove he should be way above where his current low-end rating is.
I know what you're thinking: "Timmy's an average 10 year old kid who is weak compared to others!" Sure, he's weaker than them, but that only indicates these stronger characters upscale from him. And also, Timmy being less competent than other people his age in terms of doing tasks (As explained on his profile for the AP justification for his 10-C rating) has literally nothing to do with his strength, but rather intelligence in knowing how to do the tasks. That being said, there should be no reason as to why characters superior to Timmy shouldn't be able to upscale from his best (Base) feats (Especially since you have characters like Vicky, Francis, Mr. Crocker, and Timmy's Parents who are not only shown to be physically superior to Timmy, but they have also performed their own superhuman feats to prove they are superhuman as well in a sense), and as such, Timmy should have no reason to be keeping his 10-C rating any longer.
And then there's speed. So what if Timmy is treated as the slowest of his class in running a race? This is basically the same case as the problem with his AP rating, being that it just proves that they upscale from him through being, well, superior to him. Mind you, Chester and AJ (Who are Timmy's classmates) have been shown reacting to light before, so it's basically the same sense that these characters outspeeding Timmy are superhuman just like him. As such, Timmy's average speed rating should be removed and he should just be solidly Massively FTL. Also, the same should apply to Cosmo and Wanda since it's the same case as Timmy of simply being outsped by other humans who have superhuman stats.
That being said, now that I've debunked why the low ends of Timmy's tier feel pointless, it's time I address how the feat he scales to in his 8-B rating is wrong. Timmy scales to his parents as Mighty Mom and Dyno Dad who were able to push a meteor back which has been calculated to be 41.5 tons of TNT. The issue, however, is that the formula was done wrong via square rooting the mass instead of multiplying it by 0.5, causing the result to become much lower than usual. That being said, I recalculated said feat to be 7-C, which is consistent with feats like Timmy withstanding a missile from Shirley who is this strong, Timmy at full brain capacity (withstanding himself) kicking a soccer ball around the world, Timmy and his parents surviving getting launched from the North Pole to a tropical island, Remy and Juandissimo withstanding an explosion that vaporized Remy's mansion, and Mr. Bickles withstanding an explosion that vaporized his house, all of which are in the tier 7 range.
But they can also get much higher than that, as proven by how Crocker withstands Timmy crashing into him hard enough to splash all of its water into space, as well as the entire world population being able to survive being crushed by the Timmadome collapsing on them as seen with them appearing in the next episode (Chicken Poofs), which both yield tier 6 results. But perhaps I should introduce the highest possible feat the cast should scale to: that being the Pumpkinator being able to withstand its own self-destruction powerful enough to blow up a pumpkin planet, a feat that yield's High 5-A results. While it's true that this feat happens in an in-universe TV show, in the episode the feat happens (Scary Godparents), Timmy makes a wish that would turn everyone's costumes "real and scary" (9:15), which literally caused all of the costumes everyone was wearing to have them gain the powers and abilities of something based on their costume (10:32). That being said, later in the episode, Timmy wears a Crimson Chin mask to gain the powers of the Crimson Chin's chin which he uses to harm a replica of the Pumpkinator that became real from the wish he made (18:27), therefore the Crimson Chin would be able to scale to said Pumpkinator feat, who in turn Timmy himself would scale to since he can fight off the villains who can keep up with the Crimson Chin.
Now, the biggest concern that may be brought up is if this is an outlier or not. And I am fortunate to say that it is not an outlier, as there are 2 feats also in the tier 5 range that prove this rating is consistent:
- Dark Laser is able to survive his Death Ball exploding with him inside of it in 2 episodes (The End of the Universe-ity [1:48] and Please Don't Feed The Turners [11:49]), with the Death Ball being durable enough to withstand being hit by its own laser that was stated by Dark Laser himself to be capable of destroying Earth. In a later episode (When L.O.S.E.R.S. Attack), Dark Laser would then get attacked by a bear which would be the same bear Crocker and Foop would survive getting attacked by, so they scale to Dark Laser's durability.
- Jorgen and many other fairies in Fairy World are able to survive a bomb that would've destroyed Earth in Five Days of F.L.A.R.G. (10:47), with said fairies being able to trade blows with each other in episodes like Most Wanted Wish (6:12).
Finally, as much as I still believe in 3-A fairy magic, I'd like to remove 2 justifications that justify their 3-A tier.
- Firstly is the evidence of series creator Butch Hartman stating that Cosmo & Wanda can create a universe. Although this looks convincing when taken out of context, in context he stated this while retelling a popular fan theory that Timmy Turner and Danny Phantom are the same person, not even confirming at the end if this is true, just giving his thoughts on it. Just because that statement was taken from the creator's mouth should not mean that his words are the absolute truth, especially since he was only retelling a theory and not confirming if they are actually capable of doing something like this.
- Secondly is the evidence of Calamitous fused with Jorgen's body creating the Big Bang Bomb with the intent on destroying the universe. The thing is, based on what Calamitous says, he never mentions anything about destroying the universe when explaining his Big Bang Bomb, only stating that it has the ability to "tear the very fabric of time" and "revert Earth to its original state". The former statement especially never mentions it will do so on a universal scale, but rather evidenced by the latter statement that it is at least on a planetary scale, albeit no evidence of it being any further than that. And although Cindy mentioned at one point that it was going to destroy the universe, Calamitous never says this at all, so she wouldn't be much of a reliable source to go by especially when she said this in a state of panic.
tl;dr
- Timmy (And others who have it) should lose his Varies rating and gets upgraded to High 5-A while everyone else gets upgraded to High 5-A and Massively FTL speed
- Humans and regular fairies scaling to Timmy and Cosmo become Class K, Mighty Mom & Dyno Dad as well as Crimson Chin characters become Class M, and Jorgen becomes Class M
- 2 3-A justifications should be removed for being faulty pieces of evidence
Last edited:
