ShionAH
He/Him- 17,387
- 5,433
I will be trying this again since I feel like I was unable to debate at the last CRT.
Literally the second and the sixth ******* reply for the CRT is a mods agreeing with it
Important evidence will be bold.
This CRT is trying to consider the novel of Saiki Kusuo (Extra Stories of Psychics)
Kusuke directly states the existence of the Light Novel
Kusuo directly grabs the Light Novel in the manga and promotes it
Heck even the anime makes a reference to it
In the Light Novel we see direct references to the events of the manga, several times, direct statements of the manga existing in the same universe "for the readers" (who are actual characters in verse) and we even have statements for the events of the manga from Nendou (who generally cannot even break the fourth wall!)
Counter Argument: Saiki has shown that he can do this to even his own manga. So is the manga itself also fictional? Is everything fictional and Saiki is featless? No this is simply a way Saiki breaks the fourth wall. As we also see that Kusuke and Kusuo talk about the events of the novel as things that actually affected his powers. If it was just work of fiction OR not canon then why would Saiki use it as a way to prove how his Teleportation works?
We have like 3-4 scans showing Novel is canon while 0 that imply it is not.
Agreements: (9) @Sir_Ovens, @Lord_Farquaad69420, @Comiphorous, @BadSystems, @Edutyn, @noninho, @Rockysbalboa, @Mizuki67, @Jozaysmith?
Disagreements: (4) @DontTalkDT, @AdamVhenJP, @DarkDragonMedeus, @Reiner04, @Fallen_Angelicx
Literally the second and the sixth ******* reply for the CRT is a mods agreeing with it
Important evidence will be bold.
- Purpose
This CRT is trying to consider the novel of Saiki Kusuo (Extra Stories of Psychics)
- Proof
Kusuke directly states the existence of the Light Novel
Kusuo directly grabs the Light Novel in the manga and promotes it
Heck even the anime makes a reference to it
In the Light Novel we see direct references to the events of the manga, several times, direct statements of the manga existing in the same universe "for the readers" (who are actual characters in verse) and we even have statements for the events of the manga from Nendou (who generally cannot even break the fourth wall!)
- The Problem with the evidence according to DontTalk
Counter Argument: Saiki has shown that he can do this to even his own manga. So is the manga itself also fictional? Is everything fictional and Saiki is featless? No this is simply a way Saiki breaks the fourth wall. As we also see that Kusuke and Kusuo talk about the events of the novel as things that actually affected his powers. If it was just work of fiction OR not canon then why would Saiki use it as a way to prove how his Teleportation works?
We have like 3-4 scans showing Novel is canon while 0 that imply it is not.
Agreements: (9) @Sir_Ovens, @Lord_Farquaad69420, @Comiphorous, @BadSystems, @Edutyn, @noninho, @Rockysbalboa, @Mizuki67, @Jozaysmith?
Disagreements: (4) @DontTalkDT, @AdamVhenJP, @DarkDragonMedeus, @Reiner04, @Fallen_Angelicx
Last edited: