• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Tatsumaki upgrade.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quangotjokes

Quangotjokes

7,349
3,748
Tatsumaki casually stopped the bullets that destroyed City A. Which is the size of a country. She should be upgraded to at least country, or Continent.
 
If that were the case then demon level threats should be considered country or continent level as you suggest and level dragon threats much more than that as well as the heroes who are able to defeat them, but not so many of those threats do not have a level not even close and can be checked. A calculation should be made to determine the destructive power of these bullets and if it certainly supports the fact that Tatsumaki is a country or continent there is no problem, but if it is only by speculation can not say such a thing.
 
In the anime (which is the only place where country level cities come from) there's a clear contradiction to what gets destroyed.

The ship only destroys a city sized area. For Sitch to then right after say the "destruction levels are at 99.8%" and that "City A has been destroyed in an instant."

So the later showings and statements in the series directly go against the map saying cities are country sized.

The manga also has this ship's best attack only destroying a city sized portio (though I can't find as explicit statements of this one portion being A-City like in the anime)

This means either A-City isn't really country sized. Or that Sitch and his highly advanced scanner both made a huge mistake and somehow only got a city cized portion got confused for an entire country. But even if we assume the ship eventually destroyed this entire country sized city (which it couldn't since the ship stays right where it is since that scene), based on the potency we see of a single attack, we can't say it did that in one shot.
 
Ryukama explains it perfectly, certainly the ship of Boros destroys an area not comparable to a city that can be noticed by the buildings that it contains, if it were of the size of a country could be noticed a more gigantic area and the ship of Boros would have to be very high In the sky so that their guns covered all that. Certainly the cities of OPM are huge megacities and I have confused that statement that 99.8% of one was destroyed because it is not appreciated that it was an area of that size that destroyed the ship of Boros.
 
Comparing it to those buildings it's near, no it is not. Nor is the size of the area it destroys.
 
There's also the fact that the planet's urbanization isn't visible from space, which it would be if the cities were country sized.

I think when I brought up the issue with sizes in the past it was agreed on that unless there's further proof we should treat it as if the cities were something like capitals of country sized regions that are referred to by the name of the city, since that's the only way the contradictory sizes actually make sense.
 
Look at how this ship compares to the buildings. That is not the size of an entire country. The rest of that size area is irrelevent. Boros's ship never destroys those parts. Only what I showed.

Also how do you explain the anime (which is the only media this map comes from) explicitly calling a city sized area 99.8% of this "country"?
 
http://*********.com/Manga/Onepunch-Man/Punch-003?id=369846#22

Can also see the curvature of the earth here.
 
Ryukama said:
Look at how this ship compares to the buildings. That is not the size of an entire country. The rest of that size area is irrelevent. Boros's ship never destroys those parts. Only what I showed.
Also how do you explain the anime (which is the only media this map comes from) explicitly calling a city sized area 99.8% of this "country"?
Click to expand...
That's just murata's size inconsistancy.
 
No. The inconsistency is the map. The ship clearly isn't the size of a country in any of the shots it's in. A city sized portion is explicity stated to be 99.8% percent of A-City. And the ship never destroys anything besides that area.

This is just as valid as arguing those galaxies that are dwarfed by the Earth and stated to be smaller than the Milky Way in Asura's Wrath are actual galaxies. Every other showing and statement goes against it.

Even if we're to say country level cities. The ship still ever only destroys a city sized portion of this country.
 
It seems that as much the ship of Boros destroys an area similar to a small island, sincerely does not see anything close to a country.
 
Where are you getting that only a portion was destroyed? He clearly stated 99.8 of A city has been destroyed. Not a city within A City. You're just lowballing it for no reason.
 
Right after this attack happens, Sitch states that 99.8% of A-City was wiped out in an instant. We see no other attacks occur after that portion is destroyed, which if we did that'd contradict the statement that it was destroyed "in an instant." And the ship stays right where it's at since that scene.

So according to the anime, that city sized portion was A-City, and that was what the ship destroyed.

For the manga, find a scene where the ship destroys anything more than this (Which doesn't even matter since the ship is now proven it can't one shot the country. So no 6-B)

I'm not lowballing for no reason. You're simply in denial. City sized portions are the only thing shown and explicityly stated to be the extent of this ship's destruction.
 
http://*********.com/Manga/Onepunch-Man/Punch-037?id=369888#29

Scan clearly states City A disappeared from the map. Not a portion of it.
 
Quangotjokes said:
http://*********.com/Manga/Onepunch-Man/Punch-037?id=369888#29Sca clearly states City A disappeared from the map. Not a portion of it.
Click to expand...
Doesn't matter when all we see get destroyed is a city sized portion. The ship never moves or goes out to destroy anything more since then. Anime explicitly states that the city sized portion is 99.8% of A-City. The fact that country level cities are never even a thing in the manga you're citing. And that even if it did eventually destroy the country after that city sized portion, which it couldn't have, it didn't do it in one shot.
 
Let's illustrate it graphically by taking the image showing the side effects of Saitama's seriuos punch. The pink circle is what finishes all city A, the blue line would be the equivalent of a country:

One Punch Man Scan

the ship of Boros never destroyed something equivalent to that, that spacecraft is the size of a city not of a country.
 
Ryukama said:
Quangotjokes said:
http://*********.com/Manga/Onepunch-Man/Punch-037?id=369888#29Sca clearly states City A disappeared from the map. Not a portion of it.
Click to expand...
Doesn't matter when all we see get destroyed is a city sized portion. The ship never moves or goes out to destroy anything more since then. Anime explicitly states that the city sized portion is 99.8% of A-City. The fact that country level cities are never even a thing in the manga you're citing. And that even if it did eventually destroy the country after that city sized portion, which it couldn't have, it didn't do it in one shot.
Click to expand...
That's where you're wrong. The ship only fired one shot of bullets. the second time it fired were to kill the S class. You're reaching for a debunk. It takes time for them to reload the bullets anyways.
 
I'm not reaching in the slightest. Everything else goes against this.

  • City sized portion is directly stated to be 99.8% of A-City
  • When the ship does that attack that only destroys city sized portion, it's stated that A-City is wiped out in an instant.
  • Only attack ever shown is the one that just destroys city sized area in both media.
  • This ship stays in the exact same place since since the first attack, so it couldn't have gone out and destroyed the rest of the country.
  • The fact that A-City was stated to be wiped out in an instant also means it couldn't have gone out and destroyed the rest of a country sized land.
  • Even if it did go out and eventually destroy the rest of a country sized, it didn't do it in one shot, so it isn't 6-B.
  • "The ship only fired one shot of bullets. the second time it fired were to kill the S class." "Second time fired" also means it can't be 6-B since again, it didn't destroy a country in one shot.
Unless all of this is somehow addressed, there is no upgrade to be made. And to do one would to be in denial.
 
  • City sized portion is directly stated to be 99.8% of A-City
No it wasnt

  • The fact that A-City was stated to be wiped out in an instant also means it couldn't have gone out and destroyed the rest of a country sized land.
Emphasis on why the first set of bullets destroyed the whole City A.

  • The ship only fired one shot of bullets. the second time it fired were to kill the S class. "Second time fired" also means it can't be 6-B since again, it didn't destroy a country in one shot.
City A was destroyed along with the first barrage.
 
Yes it was. Did you not see my links?

Boros's ship does that attack which destroys a city sized portion. Right after Sitch states that "destruction levels are at 99.8%" and "A-City was destroyed in an instant."

"Emphasis on why the first set of bullets destroyed the whole City A." "City A was destroyed along with the first barrage."

And this first barrage only destroyed a city sized area. If that attack destroyed all of A-City, then A-City is only city sized. Which is directly stated in the same anime you get this map from.
 
When he said A-City he meant City A. Not a portion of the whole thing, but the whole thing. You do realize that the percentage that wasnt destroyed was the HQ right?

"And this first barrage only destroyed a city sized area."

There was no other attack on City A. It has been destroyed already.
 
When he said A-City he meant City A. Not a portion of the whole thing, but the whole thing. You do realize that the percentage that wasnt destroyed was the HQ right?
Yes. And "the whole A-City" is only the size of a city. We directly see that within the attack.

A city sized area being destroyed is shown. That area is stated to be 99.8% of A-City. A-City is directly shown and stated to be city sized.

There was no other attack on City A. It has been destroyed already.

And again, that attack destroyed a city sized area. If that attack was what destroyed A-City, then A-City is only city sized.

You really are in denial. And cannot accept the blatant showings and statements that A-City is not country sized. If this continues to go around in circles, I'm sorry but I or someone else am going to have to close this.
 
"Yes. And "A-City" is only the size of a city. We directly see that within the attack.

A city sized area being destroyed is shown. That area is stated to be 99.8% of A-City. A-City is directly shown and stated to be city sized."

You do realize that's only stated in the anime right? MAnga he says "They destroyed city A in an instant" so that debunks your portion claim.

"And again, that attack destroyed a city sized area. If that attack was what destroyed A-City, then A-City is only city sized."

The ship destroyed the area under, and all around it as well. So that debunks your claim. Nothing denial about it.
 
You do realize that's only stated in the anime right?

Just like cities being country sized is only a thing in the anime.

"They destroyed city A in an instant" so that debunks your portion claim.

They also say a similar statement in the anime. But it doesn't matter. We only see a city sized area get destroyed, and they say that's the attack that destroyed the city. Therefore, A-City is only city sized.

"They destroyed city A in an instant" so that debunks your portion claim.

No it didn't. After this attack we still see a good chunk of an area still around. It only destroys the surrounding area near the ship, which is city sized.
 
@Ryukama I don't think you need to keep repeating yourself, its just a waste of time really.
 
I'm pretty sure scaling things by using the curvature of the planet wouldn't work out to well, especially using that one with beefcake in it, the one with beefcake showing that much of the planets curvature would mean that this planet is quite a bit smaller than our earth since beefcake himself is officially stated to be 279m tall.
 
The series of zooming shots during the meteor chapter show that a very significant portion of the land is just urban sprawl.
 
Only the super continent is confirmed by Murata's Twitter. Not that other map depicting cities as country sized. Which even then, we clearly see that the ship did not destroy an entire country.
 
> The series of zooming shots during the meteor chapter show that a very significant portion of the land is just urban sprawl.

Those were retconned out (similar to how Genos outrunning his cannon was retconned). So now all the meteor stuff shows is space shots.
 
Qawsedf234 said:
Those were retconned out (similar to how Genos outrunning his cannon was retconned). So now all the meteor stuff shows is space shots.
Click to expand...
Do you have a link to the volume version?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

ZillertheBucko
  • Locked
It’s another Boros > Tatsumaki crt hooray
2 3
Replies
89
Views
8K
Damage3245
Damage3245
Shadow_x007x
  • Locked
Symbol of Fear vs Tornado of Terror
Replies
27
Views
3K
Maverick_Zero_X
Maverick_Zero_X
Ignatheus
Sango upgrade (InuYasha)
Replies
0
Views
371
Ignatheus
Ignatheus
Shadow_x007x
  • Locked
One-Punch Man - Downgrade Black Sperm
Replies
6
Views
1K
Shadow_x007x
Shadow_x007x
Shadow_x007x
Tornado of Terror Vs Metal Bat
Replies
31
Views
2K
Shadow_x007x
Shadow_x007x
Back
Top