Swords Skills Only: Anakin Skywalker (Star Wars) vs Ike (Fire Emblem)

[TegamiBachi25]

EDIT: as DaReaperMan pointed out, Sw characters gets ****** by using any other weapons than lightsabers. My dumb ass forgot about it, so I decided to change the post to be more basic and simplistic

Who is the more skilled swordsman out of the two? No fight between them. No any confrontation. Just their feats and accolades, who they defeated, their tactical prowess of their respective universes. Again, no fight between either of them.

I’ll tally up the votes to 7 like in original matches but this is who is the more skilled swordsmen of their respective universes (again. Fun and games. Please no one take this seriously.)

 

[DaReaperMan]

Yeah this fight pretty much can't work.

Think about lightsabers for a moment: They're maybe half a pound for the human-sized lightsabers, and all that weight is in the hilt, not the blade. It's why form II is such an effective style, you don't NEED to put effort in going through pretty much anything with a Lightsaber.

Now give someone used to that kind of thing a maybe 2-pound sword, assuming it's perfectly weighted and everything, and they'll suck with it, they won't use it well, they'll make a strike and the sword will bounce off the armor unlike what Lightsabers do to 99% of beings

And restricting abilities restricts 50% of what makes a Jedi so good with their lightsaber, any lightsaber duel is basically precog vs precog as much as it is training vs training, it's also where 50% of their precision with blaster bolts comes from.

 

[TegamiBachi25]

Yeah this fight pretty much can't work.

Think about lightsabers for a moment: They're maybe half a pound for the human-sized lightsabers, and all that weight is in the hilt, not the blade. It's why form II is such an effective style, you don't NEED to put effort in going through pretty much anything with a Lightsaber.

Now give someone used to that kind of thing a maybe 2-pound sword, assuming it's perfectly weighted and everything, and they'll suck with it, they won't use it well, they'll make a strike and the sword will bounce off the armor unlike what Lightsabers do to 99% of beings

And restricting abilities restricts 50% of what makes a Jedi so good with their lightsaber, any lightsaber duel is basically precog vs precog as much as it is training vs training, it's also where 50% of their precision with blaster bolts comes from.

It’s literally in fun and games for a reason. Lightsabers are replaced with swords. Jedi used steel blades in legends before the whole sabers thing was built. It literally doesn’t change a Jedi’s effectiveness since lightsaber forms to metal blades don’t change.

Anakin just getting his lightsaber makes this match undoable. Why can’t standard equipment be replaced or changed, since this matchup isn’t even a serious vs discussion and abilities have been restricted in fun and games matches before?

 

[DaReaperMan]

It’s literally in fun and games for a reason. Lightsabers are replaced with swords. Jedi used steel blades in legends before the whole sabers thing was built. It literally doesn’t change a Jedi’s effectiveness since lightsaber forms to metal blades don’t change.

And how many millenia before Anakin's time was that? There weren't even forms of lightsaber combat at that time, or if there were, they don't resemble modern lightsaber forms

Anakin just getting his lightsaber makes this match undoable. Why can’t standard equipment be replaced or changed, since this matchup isn’t even a serious vs discussion and abilities have been restricted in fun and games matches before?

I mean, you want a skill debate and then hand one of the people you want to debate with a weapon he's never even picked up in his life lol

Like, imagine handing Ike a ******' great axe with all of it's weight being forward

 

[TegamiBachi25]

And how many millenia before Anakin's time was that? There weren't even forms of lightsaber combat at that time, or if there were, they don't resemble modern lightsaber forms

I mean, you want a skill debate and then hand one of the people you want to debate with a weapon he's never even picked up in his life lol

Like, imagine handing Ike a ******' great axe with all of it's weight being forward

well. I guess ignore this then.

EDIT: okay. I decided to change it to not be a fight and instead who has more skill since it would be a better debate then