• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Sonicverse 4-A Bracket Round 13: Super Shadow VS Dr. Eggman (CONCLUDED)

Gilad_Hyperstar

Gilad_Hyperstar

He/Him
11,379
4,319
Super Shadow VS Dr. Eggman

Rules for the match are listed here

Eggman: 3 (ElixirBlue, Theuser789, Ned_the_outer_god)

Super Shadow: 7 (Waka1979, BlastX, GlaceonGamez471, OnsokunoSonic, Psychomaster35, Maverick_Zero_X, ShakeResounding)

Inconclusive:

latest
e0cc27b0bd0c2d9940eb67af2f53cd2b.png
 
Last edited:
I'm voting shadow too, he's also not likely to fall for any of Eggman's underhanded tactics unlike sonic and knuckles.
 
Shadow low diffs, even though the doctor is pretty big brain, Shadow knows what he's capable of and will quickly hax him to death. Shad(ow) the H(edge)hog wins this
 
Well, I'm awake. Lets have a real debate.

Theuser789 said:
Shadow is pretty aware of how crafty the doctor can be, so I think he takes this
Click to expand...

When? (SA2 memory loss)

Waka1979 said:
I'm voting shadow too, he's also not likely to fall for any of Eggman's underhanded tactics unlike sonic and knuckles.
Click to expand...

What supports your headcanon?

sanicspood said:
shadow can prob clap eggman just like how sonic can since there both portrayed as equals, voting shadow
Click to expand...

Sonic has had YEARS of experience fighting Doctor Eggman. Doctor Eggman in VS debates is given everything he has ever made (expect individuals in his robot army).

While Shadow mainly has experience in H2H, not vs Mech, not vs actually strategy, and the only experiance Shadow has against Eggman, if that timeline in Shadow the Hedgehog is canon or not, is the Egg Dealer, one of the worst designs Doctor Eggman has.

Also, in Sonic Heroes, Shadow never faced Eggman, only Metal Sonic playing dress up.



How valid are these bare-bones wincons?
 
ElixirBlue said:
Well, I'm awake. Lets have a real debate.



When? (SA2 memory loss)



What supports your headcanon?



Sonic has had YEARS of experience fighting Doctor Eggman. Doctor Eggman in VS debates is given everything he has ever made (expect individuals in his robot army).

While Shadow mainly has experience in H2H, not vs Mech, not vs actually strategy, and the only experiance Shadow has against Eggman, if that timeline in Shadow the Hedgehog is canon or not, is the Egg Dealer, one of the worst designs Doctor Eggman has.

Also, in Sonic Heroes, Shadow never faced Eggman, only Metal Sonic playing dress up.



How valid are these bare-bones wincons?
Click to expand...
I'm assuming you vote Eggman?
 
Not yet. I have yet to give a wincon, however, I'm questioning the reasoning for the votes others have given so far.
 
ElixirBlue said:
Sonic has had YEARS of experience fighting Doctor Eggman. Doctor Eggman in VS debates is given everything he has ever made (expect individuals in his robot army).

While Shadow mainly has experience in H2H, not vs Mech, not vs actually strategy, and the only experiance Shadow has against Eggman, if that timeline in Shadow the Hedgehog is canon or not, is the Egg Dealer, one of the worst designs Doctor Eggman has.

Also, in Sonic Heroes, Shadow never faced Eggman, only Metal Sonic playing dress up.



How valid are these bare-bones wincons?
Click to expand...
yea but still hes as skilled as sonic if not probably better
 
Skilled =/= Experience

Theuser789 said:
plus as seen in both Rivals games he actively worked for him
Click to expand...

Er, barely any info in Rivals gave Shadow an insight on how Eggman fights, using all his equipment ever used.

I'm voting for Eggman via Chaos Energy Cannon usage after a few mechs go down. Eggman will trick Shadow, stale him because Shadow isn't bloodlusted with "Maria is my cousin. I cared for her so much" and power null Shadow.
 
ElixirBlue said:
Doctor Eggman in VS is given everything he has ever made (expect individuals in his robot army).
Click to expand...
Problem is that not much that Eggman has that can actually keep up with a super form like Shadow, and his 4-A mechs are honestly pretty weak
ElixirBlue said:
Eggman will trick Shadow, stale him because Shadow isn't bloodlusted with "Maria is my cousin. I cared for her so much" and power null Shadow.
Click to expand...
Shadow's game debunks that, since Eggman pulls the family card at the boss fight at the ark, which didn't work
 
Theuser789 said:
Problem is that not much that Eggman has that can actually keep up with a super form like Shadow, and his 4-A mechs are honestly pretty weak
Click to expand...
Staling tactic

Theuser789 said:
Shadow's game debunks that, since Eggman pulls the family card at the boss fight at the ark, which didn't work
Click to expand...

You mean while Shadow had no memories of Gerald and Maria and Dr. Eggman didn't use the Maria card? Shadow's Game does not debunk the Maria card, as Eggman didn't use it and Shadow had no memory of Gerald while Eggman used that card.
 
Click the video that I showed you, he clearly did remember and cared for Gerald and Maria there, as well as the Ark, plus why would he use the Maria card if he didn't beforehand?

It isn't a stalling tatic, if Shadow destroys his 4-A mechs it's kinda of over for our mad scientist

To add in 06 he didn't fall for Mephiles temptation, would would he know to someone he knows can be extremely dangerous?

 
Theuser789 said:
he clearly did remember and cared for Gerald and Maria there
Click to expand...

Dude, I know of that scene. Shadow express no memories, just knowledge of what he is and what his past is. Shadow does not indicate he remembers, only coming to that conclusion after hearing about his past from others.

Theuser789 said:
plus why would he use the Maria card if he didn't beforehand?
Click to expand...

Because Dr. Eggman cares about Gerald more than Maria, so he used the Gerald card first. Didn't work, so why not try the Maria card for the 2nd time, this vs debate match up?
 
ElixirBlue said:
Dude, I know of that scene. Shadow express no memories, just knowledge of what he is and what his past is. Shadow does not indicate he remembers, only coming to that conclusion after hearing about his past from others.
Click to expand...
You do know that is how Shadow currently is right? You yourself argued he didn't remember SA2 and yet you are arguing he is like SA2 Shadow that anything about Maria would freeze him like a deer in highlights even tho he already moved on from his past, if meontining the past didn't work back then it won't work now, he would just be like "I don't care"
ElixirBlue said:
Because Dr. Eggman cares about Gerald more than Maria, so he used the Gerald card first. Didn't work, so why not try the Maria card for the 2nd time, this vs debate match up?
Click to expand...
Except that ending never happened, therefore Eggman wouldn't know now it wouldn't work
 
Theuser789 said:
You do know that is how Shadow currently is right?
Click to expand...
Not during Shadow's game, which is when Eggman used the Gerald Card

Theuser789 said:
You yourself argued he didn't remember SA2 and yet you are arguing he is like SA2 Shadow
Click to expand...

As you said, Shadow remembers his past by the time Sonic Battle rolls around

Theuser789 said:
that anything about Maria would freeze him like a deer in highlights
Click to expand...

Hell no, I'm not disrespecting Shadow like that. The Maria Card would make Shadow listen to Eggman instead of going for the Karate Chop right away. Sonic Unleashed, Eggman didn't need much time to activate the Chaos Energy Cannon. The CEC is the only weapon Sonic knows that the rest of the cast doesn't.

Theuser789 said:
Except that ending never happened, therefore Eggman wouldn't know now it wouldn't work
Click to expand...

Fair. But, realizing, the Gerald Card did work in that cutscene, as Shadow stood around for a moment to listen Eggman. Dr. Eggman only needs them to stand around for a moment, like he pretended the turn good to Sonic, which played on Sonic's cockiness.
 
Chances are he won't be meaningfully distracted by Eggman's 4-A mechs. The only reason they even put up any meaningful resistance against Sonic whatsoever is because he doesn't really utilize his hax on them.

And on the off chance that Shadow does get distracted, he can easily take the Inhibitors off and that'll be the end of that. Not to mention that, worst case scenario, Shadow simply stops time through Chaos Control. As he's very prone to doing in many cases. Chances are Eggman doesn't even get a chance to talk his way out of his death with him.

Shadow has my vote.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

GlaceonGamez471
[0-0-0] Eggman Frontiers pt 2 (Super Eggman vs Wyvern)
Replies
2
Views
847
Theuser789
Theuser789
McFriesGuy075
The Ultimate Rematch | Shadow the Hedgehog vs Biolizard (Finalhazard) (5-0-0)
Replies
21
Views
3K
McFriesGuy075
McFriesGuy075
Chanimate
The Battle of Ultimate Lifeforms (Shadow vs Fecto Forgo) [0-1-0]
Replies
22
Views
3K
Chanimate
Chanimate
y3p_owo
Egg vs Dorito (Eggman vs Bill Cipher)
Replies
28
Views
3K
y3p_owo
y3p_owo
GlaceonGamez471
(Concluded) [7-0-0] Eggman tries to take things into his own hands (Super Eggman vs Giganto)
Replies
27
Views
4K
GlaceonGamez471
GlaceonGamez471
Back
Top