• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Status
Not open for further replies.
There's not enough staff agreement, although I personally think it's fine.
 
That's still not enough given that there's opposition.
Opposition that did not check the new arguments.

We can’t go with their opinion on the incomplete argument it’s stupid and a loss of time

It’s always a similar pattern they just stop responding and we never get what’s supposed to be accepted on the profiles else we have to wait for month.

The new arguments have 0 opposition let alone concrete arguments to go against the evidence we have.
 
"Small NNT upgrades"
Three whole pages later...

Right, so may I please have a rundown of the exact propositions being laid out here, as well as the arguments for and against said changes?
 
Right, so may I please have a rundown of the exact propositions being laid out here, as well as the arguments for and against said changes?
Just a few abilities that don't have enough staff input like Merlin getting a likely rating for Vivian's abilities, High regeneration. Resistance to density manipulation for the sins and high regeneration negation for High ranking demons. Byashura agrees with these we just need 1 or 2 more staff to give a thumbs up before the rest of the crt can be applied and then closed.
 
Listen, I don't really care about NNT, so don't expect me to be too coherent.

That being said, despite my honest intentions, I read everything, and while certain abilities have been put to the wayside, I will comment on the ones left remaining, which as you said, are:

  • Merlin getting a Likely for having the abilities of Vivian.
  • High Regeneration for Supreme Deity
  • Resistance to Density Manipulation for the Sins
  • Negation for High Regeneration for the higher demons
1. Fine, this seems reasonable.
2. Considering the showing of holes being closed up in the anime, it's definitely Regeneration of some kind. But considering the author statement has supposedly been retconned, and the initial scan clearly being a fancy Teleportation rather than Regeneration, I can't agree with High Regeneration being applied here.
3. Frankly, I don't really know if this is actual mass. In all honesty, this looks like Gravity Manipulation moreso than anything. I don't think I can really accept this at this point.
4. See Point #2. If I don't believe SD has High Regeneration, then they shouldn't get High Regeneration Negation for similar reasons.
 
Listen, I don't really care about NNT, so don't expect me to be too coherent.

That being said, despite my honest intentions, I read everything, and while certain abilities have been put to the wayside, I will comment on the ones left remaining, which as you said, are:

  • Merlin getting a Likely for having the abilities of Vivian.
  • High Regeneration for Supreme Deity
  • Resistance to Density Manipulation for the Sins
  • Negation for High Regeneration for the higher demons
1. Fine, this seems reasonable.
2. Considering the showing of holes being closed up in the anime, it's definitely Regeneration of some kind. But considering the author statement has supposedly been retconned, and the initial scan clearly being a fancy Teleportation rather than Regeneration, I can't agree with High Regeneration being applied here.
3. Frankly, I don't really know if this is actual mass. In all honesty, this looks like Gravity Manipulation moreso than anything. I don't think I can really accept this at this point.
4. See Point #2. If I don't believe SD has High Regeneration, then they shouldn't get High Regeneration Negation for similar reasons.
Makai has scans from the light novel which proves that SD has high regeneration even byashura agrees with it.
 
  • Merlin getting a Likely for having the abilities of Vivian.
  • High Regeneration for Supreme Deity
  • Resistance to Density Manipulation for the Sins
  • Negation for High Regeneration for the higher demons
1. Fine, this seems reasonable.
Nice
2. Considering the showing of holes being closed up in the anime, it's definitely Regeneration of some kind. But considering the author statement has supposedly been retconned, and the initial scan clearly being a fancy Teleportation rather than Regeneration, I can't agree with High Regeneration being applied here.
The « teleportation » thing isn’t what We use for the regen.
We use the fact that she regen holes in her body using light.
The fact that she can manipulate light and reform bodies using it show that she Is entirely made of it.

The retconned statement was about her face not being visible due to being light.
We could see her face a few times so it’s retconned


3. Frankly, I don't really know if this is actual mass. In all honesty, this looks like Gravity Manipulation moreso than anything. I don't think I can really accept this at this point.
Fair
4. See Point #2. If I don't believe SD has High Regeneration, then they shouldn't get High Regeneration Negation for similar reasons.
See point 2
 
Nice

The « teleportation » thing isn’t what We use for the regen.
We use the fact that she regen holes in her body using light.
The fact that she can manipulate light and reform bodies using it show that she Is entirely made of it.

The retconned statement was about her face not being visible due to being light.
We could see her face a few times so it’s retconned



Fair

See point 2
What about the scan for the light novel?
 
The « teleportation » thing isn’t what We use for the regen.
We use the fact that she regen holes in her body using light.
The fact that she can manipulate light and reform bodies using it show that she Is entirely made of it.
Okay, but see, the metric used for Regeneration is not the mode of how they regenerate, its dependent on how much they have been shown to regenerate above all else.

And from the scan, I could only give SD High-Low or Low-Mid, as there's no real proof here that if they get blasted into literal particles that they could pull themselves back together, regardless of their bodily construction. Unless you can provide proof that this would indeed be the case, I just can't lend my support to this. I apologize.
 
Okay, but see, the metric used for Regeneration is not the mode of how they regenerate, its dependent on how much they have been shown to regenerate above all else.

And from the scan, I could only give SD High-Low or Low-Mid, as there's no real proof here that if they get blasted into literal particles that they could pull themselves back together, regardless of their bodily construction. Unless you can provide proof that this would indeed be the case, I just can't lend my support to this. I apologize.
She regenerated her body from light particles which are photons that qualify for high regeneration there is even a statement saying that the SD was able to regenerate from light particles.
 
And how much of her body was regenerated, Speed? Because that's the only factor we use to determine regen.

If a ghost gets their arm cut off and regenerates it, do they get mid-godly?
 
She regenerated her body from light particles which are photons that qualify for high regeneration there is even a statement saying that the SD was able to regenerate from light particles.
Give me the exact statement and source that she could regenerate from light particles, then we'll talk.
 
Okay, but see, the metric used for Regeneration is not the mode of how they regenerate, its dependent on how much they have been shown to regenerate above all else.

And from the scan, I could only give SD High-Low or Low-Mid, as there's no real proof here that if they get blasted into literal particles that they could pull themselves back together, regardless of their bodily construction. Unless you can provide proof that this would indeed be the case, I just can't lend my support to this. I apologize.
She never was blasted to particles.
Though the pseudo teleportation show her going from scattered photons to a complete body.

As long as she Is able to manipulate light she can reform entire bodies using environment light which led us to believe she’d qualify
 
Yeah, see, I can't agree with something that is led by assumptions like that. Frankly, the teleportation and regeneration seem like two separate abilities, and nothing here has shown me that one automatically proves the other to be true.

Again, I'm sorry, but I am firmly against High Regeneration for the reasons given to me so far.
 
Yeah, see, I can't agree with something that is led by assumptions like that. Frankly, the teleportation and regeneration seem like two separate abilities, and nothing here has shown me that one automatically proves the other to be true.

Again, I'm sorry, but I am firmly against High Regeneration for the reasons given to me so far.
Okay
 
Just get the light novel translation please.
Yeah, see, I can't agree with something that is led by assumptions like that. Frankly, the teleportation and regeneration seem like two separate abilities, and nothing here has shown me that one automatically proves the other to be true.

Again, I'm sorry, but I am firmly against High Regeneration for the reasons given to me so far.
It not actually teleportation it specified that she regenerated her body from light particles. Also the counter argument for SD face is weak just because their was an outline of her face doesn’t disprove that her face isn’t made out light like her body.
 
Also if this is not accepted then kizaru needs to be nerfed because his high regeneration comes from being made of light and reforming his body there would be too much hypocrisy if that was overlooked.
 
She never was blasted to particles.
Though the pseudo teleportation show her going from scattered photons to a complete body.

As long as she Is able to manipulate light she can reform entire bodies using environment light which led us to believe she’d qualify
It wasn’t teleportation though it was her reforming her body in the living world from light particles as stated in the light novel.
 
Edit High regeneration for the supreme deity Here
Diane creation is not a physical attack it’s the magic power of the giant clan and she was able to regenerate holes in her body also here’s this nakaba qna she even says that she is light itself so her regeneration should be high.
Q377Why the face of the Supreme Deity cannot be seen?Because it's the light itself
Nakaba qna says that SD body is light itself. And she is shown regenerating from light.

Could you tag makai here?
No they weren’t.
They were physical attacks the white dots were just her using her ability he immune to physical attacks, which is why right after that King says they are going to start using magic on her instead.
Here’s the full clip
5Ma10rA.mp4

Also the SD says that see is light in the official translation or she is light itself. this is more than enough proof for high recreation for the SD. At least a likely rating works.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top