MaxLevel_King
He/Him- 356
- 64
Original CRT: https://vsbattles.com/threads/servant-scaling-moon-cell-downgrade-proposal-2-0.148944/
Since my CRT was closed before I got the chance to argue all my points and counter-points, I'm opening up a discussion on this topic here. I'll start with my reply to a counter-argument made on the CRT;
2. So there are no cases of Gaia directly weakening a Servant anchored to reality by their Master then.
3. The Meteor wasn't a NP, the aimbot was. Moriarty specifically created a giant tower gun and was going to use the aimbot NP to shoot the meteor from the tower gun directly into the center of the Earth's core, destroying it. The NP itself didn't have Planet-destroying power.
4. Fair enough
5. The MMC Servants stood an astronomically low chance to beat her (BB) to begin with and they were both (BB and Kiara) being nerfed to beatable lebels, so I think that speaks for itself.
6. The scan literally states that not even Gilgamesh knew about this. The rest of the scan's context that debunks your reasoning aside, you think Gilgamesh didn't know about the power he had in life?
7. The Sun having Gods which are embodiments of it doesn't prove that the Sun itself is abnormal. On top of that, it's a fallacy to claim that since other Celestial Bodies are abnormal, the Sun is as well when it's never indicated as such.
8. There are no "literal universes" inside the Moon Cell. You're conflating simulated realities with being genuine realities.
9. No. Textures being affected (and not even destroyed) doesn't equate to planetary and above AP/DC. As for INS (Imaginary Number Scramble?), I don't recall any Servants destroying the entire space.
10. That's not my point. I know that no calc can come close to Tier 1, my point is that calcs capping at 5-B and not higher such as in Tier 3 doesn't line up with the most powerful Moon Cell Srrvants being that powerful outside of the Moon Cell.
11. You completely missed the point I was making. I stated that "Anti-" means effective against, not necessarily that it can destroy that thing. I didn't state that it absolutely couldn't destroy that thing either. Anti-Country refers directly to Country (either effective against or can destroy), which is why I said that Karna's NP is Country-level at best. I said it was comparable to a nuke at worst because the power of his NP has directly been compared to a nuclear blast. If one of the strongest Servants possess Country-level AP at best outside of the Moon Cell, and can beat most other Moon Cell Servants outside of the Moon Cell with Country-level AP, then it stands to reason that any if not most Servants that scale to Low 1-C inside of the Moon Cell shouldn't scale to that outside of the Moon Cell.
12. It's completely true.
I don't think that most Servants are listed at Low 1-C, I think that most of the ones that are shouldn't have that tier or it should be clarified that they only have that tier inside of the Moon Cell. As for the Beasts, Grands, and Gods you've brought up, most if not all of them don't have any feats remotely comparable to Low 1-C either.
Since my CRT was closed before I got the chance to argue all my points and counter-points, I'm opening up a discussion on this topic here. I'll start with my reply to a counter-argument made on the CRT;
1. I'll probably need to add in a scan later, but it's been stated that Servants with less Mystery are usually buffed by their Servant container, possessing powers that they didn't in life (you know, because some Servants were actually relatively normal human beings).You acknowledge that they're a unique case, but then extrapolate that to mean any new servant is buffed by it (never even hinted at). Jeanne being a top servant in Extra also doesn't matter even if her regular self lacks tier 1 feats, because her non top servant self isn't tier 1 (Top Servant is a type of graph you can be summoned with, like a Grand Graph, it's a level of power set by that)
That's the only instance you should need they're being literally erased from reality without a master, this is also the entire reason for mana issues for them, or for projections disappearing, etc
"Moriarty was going to destroy the planet with a meteor, this doesn't contradict Da Vinci saying the planet can't be destroyed by an NP", yeah okay moving on
Yes, I haven't proven such because it's irrelevant to your proposal, as many of your points are
There were other factors at play that led to Kiara's defeat yes, this literally does not matter though. Find me a single statement that Kiara or BB were nerfed by several degrees of uncountable infinity, and you'll have a point, otherwise you just have "Servants had a >1% chance to win, and did" which means they still are on that level, otherwise it'd be a 0%, and then you have them beating a Kiara nerfed by an unknown amount
I've read the scan, I've read the whole game even, it doesn't say it's stronger than in life, in fact it's saying it's unlocking their Origin of their life specifically
The sun is clearly not a normal Sun when it has several gods who are embodiments of it, when it exists in a universe where even meteors have Ultimate Ones, and exists outside of Earth, which has the known universe as a layer of itself, it is very clearly not normal, and to say otherwise is either willful ignorance, or blatant misrepresentation of the series
It's a simulated reality full of literal universes, higher dimensions, and multiple things which can affect the outside world, the computer itself is that tier by necessity
Any feat involving the planet (6d Avalon 8d space whatever) any feat involving INS (explicitly higher d) any feat which just scales to the Mooncell stuff (the entire CCC event and then the Ooku one via scaling to Kiara) etc
That's not how that works no. Because no calc can come close to tier 1, that's just sorta how tiers work, therefore it doesn't matter if they had a high 3-A calc or a 9-B calc, they're all equally as nothing compared to tier 1, making this entire point meaningless, furthermore, if you've actually read the pages, most servants are below 5-B, fun fact
But you said Anti X doesn't mean destroy X, therefore saying it has at best country level AP doesn't work, unless you then say that Anti World and stuff does mean world. And again, most servants, funnily enough, aren't that tier.
That's just not true though as mentioned before, and as you'd see if you actually read the profiles or source material
These scans are almost meme tier considering the text ones are literally just copy pasting TM wiki, couldn't even actually search the sources for your points rip.
Beyond that this thread is a mix of
1. Complete non points, such as the calc point, or the Brahmastra thing
2. Things which have been addressed in multiple threads since before the upgrade even happened, with no variation, including the Da Vinci statement without even looking at its context
Furthermore, the OP seems to have a fundamental misunderstanding of the tiering of the verse based on some of his comments. The average servant isn't tier 1 as he seems to think, bringing up examples like Brahmastra as anti feats, or Jeanne not having tier 1 feats as a servant, the average servant is 6-C, a 3 dimensional being. Tier 1 is the god tiers, who literally nothing said here applies to even if it were to be accurate. It's the Beasts, the Types, the Grands (when summoned as a Grand and given the grand graph), Top Servants (when summoned as one with the graph), Gods and such.
2. So there are no cases of Gaia directly weakening a Servant anchored to reality by their Master then.
3. The Meteor wasn't a NP, the aimbot was. Moriarty specifically created a giant tower gun and was going to use the aimbot NP to shoot the meteor from the tower gun directly into the center of the Earth's core, destroying it. The NP itself didn't have Planet-destroying power.
4. Fair enough
5. The MMC Servants stood an astronomically low chance to beat her (BB) to begin with and they were both (BB and Kiara) being nerfed to beatable lebels, so I think that speaks for itself.
6. The scan literally states that not even Gilgamesh knew about this. The rest of the scan's context that debunks your reasoning aside, you think Gilgamesh didn't know about the power he had in life?
7. The Sun having Gods which are embodiments of it doesn't prove that the Sun itself is abnormal. On top of that, it's a fallacy to claim that since other Celestial Bodies are abnormal, the Sun is as well when it's never indicated as such.
8. There are no "literal universes" inside the Moon Cell. You're conflating simulated realities with being genuine realities.
9. No. Textures being affected (and not even destroyed) doesn't equate to planetary and above AP/DC. As for INS (Imaginary Number Scramble?), I don't recall any Servants destroying the entire space.
10. That's not my point. I know that no calc can come close to Tier 1, my point is that calcs capping at 5-B and not higher such as in Tier 3 doesn't line up with the most powerful Moon Cell Srrvants being that powerful outside of the Moon Cell.
11. You completely missed the point I was making. I stated that "Anti-" means effective against, not necessarily that it can destroy that thing. I didn't state that it absolutely couldn't destroy that thing either. Anti-Country refers directly to Country (either effective against or can destroy), which is why I said that Karna's NP is Country-level at best. I said it was comparable to a nuke at worst because the power of his NP has directly been compared to a nuclear blast. If one of the strongest Servants possess Country-level AP at best outside of the Moon Cell, and can beat most other Moon Cell Servants outside of the Moon Cell with Country-level AP, then it stands to reason that any if not most Servants that scale to Low 1-C inside of the Moon Cell shouldn't scale to that outside of the Moon Cell.
12. It's completely true.
I don't think that most Servants are listed at Low 1-C, I think that most of the ones that are shouldn't have that tier or it should be clarified that they only have that tier inside of the Moon Cell. As for the Beasts, Grands, and Gods you've brought up, most if not all of them don't have any feats remotely comparable to Low 1-C either.