MrKerf
He/Him- 2,101
- 842
That doesn’t sound right. In the same issue of FF he, as I recall, needed Franklin to create new universes with, no?
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
SCARLET WITCH AND THE GRIEVER Revisions
- Thread starter Yokoahh5743
- Start date
- 8,504
- 1,844
I'll need to reread the entire context of that to be sure so I'll get back to you on that. It was said that they eventually recreated the whole of Eternity that way though, so it should be much higher than what we currently rate the feat as for the two of them.
Because from what I read, while Molecule Man's powers was used as an anchor, it was Franklin who actively created everything that makes up Complete/True Eternity (which a lot of people seem to forget and just assumed Molecule Man provided the power to do the creating and anchoring, which isn't the case. He only provided the power to anchor those creations, not create them)
- 1,080
- 221
- Thread starter
- #203
Abstract entities that exist outside of Multi-Eternity may not need an m-body, or their m-body may not need to be on a Universal-Eternity scale. For example, the Never Queen has never stated that she has an m-body; if you consider her 4th-Cosmos form as her m-body, she is still H1-A. Similarly, the Phoenix Force (avatar) is currently described as a healing force for universes. It seems that some abstract entities do not need to exist on the same level of existence as Universal-Eternity.
MrKerf
He/Him- 2,101
- 842
4th cosmos was akin to Eternity so naturally she had m-bodies at the time. And usually Queen of Nevers never interacts with anything inside Eternity, just with him, thus portrayed as comparable.
And Phoenix here is specifically not the avatar, if I remember that issue correctly.
However, I don’t mind Griever not being M-body. Come to think of it, why would splitting her across realities be a hindrance if she is composed of Manifestation entities. Plus one can see some other contradicting things. But it won’t give Wanda higher tier, just downgrade Griever.
- 58
- 49
If the Grand Design is H1-A , then Scarlet witch is likely to be H1-A by altering it and containing Chthon and the Darkhold, as both of these threats jeopardize the Grand Design.
This kinda wrong, it's not the Waiting Room; the Waiting Room is a pocket dimension connected to the Eldritch Orchard. The Well Beyond Worlds/Eldritch Orchard is the highest plane of magic existence, existing beyond the Dream Dimension (Sleepwalker’s realm), which currently appears to be The Superflow itself. It is the source of all magic- so she is H1-A by creating The Well Beyond Worlds out of chaos.
(I know that in the VS Wiki, Marvel magic is still categorized as low 1-A, but it has shown potential for an upgrade. There are numerous examples, such as Gos Loki using magic to protect the Defenders and fighting the Beyonders, and Meggan Puceanu using magical forces in Otherworld to slow down the Chaos wave that is going to destroy all creation. Additionally, Dr. Strange's artifacts and various mystical realms demonstrate that Marvel magic deserves a significant revision for an upgrade.)
She hasn’t become the Ultimate Nexus yet, but her feats are really impressive for handling the Edge of Reality and threaten to the Grand Design by existing.
So If " the Griever is m-body or not "is the issue, we can still use her other feats for her new key, 'The Living Darkhold,' because she still has many feats that could make her tier higher and she isn't the Ultimate Nexus yet ,such as threatening the Grand Design, containing Chthon and the Darkhold, managing the Edge, and creating the Eldritch Orchard/The Well Beyond Worlds. All of this should make the Living Darkhold Varies, Low1-A, up to H1-A
- 92
- 25
Phoenix in Defenders:Beyond is an avatar, in Immortal X-Men #18 it is stated that the True Phoenix is the White Hot Room itself. And how can you downgrade The Griever when she represents the end of all creation?
Last edited:
MrKerf
He/Him- 2,101
- 842
Weren't they directly in the white hot room at that point? Image lacks context.
Here's how it works.
Regular Abstracts have their true Multiversal selves, their true Universal selves (which exist in every universe), and M-Bodies (avatars for personal matters and such).
If we'd accept Griever as lacking M-Body, she'd be just Omniversal, with Multiversal avatar. So, the downgrade would be in removing one of the keys.
Additionally, her rating would then be "varies due to not being proficient at using her powers against mortals", so she wouldn't cause Wanda's upgrade.
- 92
- 25
The Fire Bird that we all saw is just an avatar of the Phoenix. the Phoenix's true form is a WHR, an empty white space.
Wanda still spreads Griever across realities.
- 1,080
- 221
- Thread starter
- #209
Sorry for the mistake and I completely agree with your opinion.
- 1,426
- 3,583
Isn't this contradicting itself? The version of Owen that got one-shot was the version who'd just finished exhausting his Secret Wars powers by taking fragments of himself (all the alternate Molecule Men that were combined by Doctor Doom to construct the bomb that destroyed the Beyonders) and placing them in all the alternate earths to serve as anchors, so he wouldn't have his Secret Wars powers. It was stated several different times that the reason Griever attacked them when she did was because she was stalking The Future Foundation until the exact moment when they ran out of Universe-Creating energies.
- 168,510
- 77,216
I think that your conclusions in this post seem reasonable to apply.
- 168,510
- 77,216
Molecule Man is a glass cannon when not actively protecting himself with his powers, and he was very distracted and taken by surprise. Also, Dan Slott likely portrayed him as far less powerful than Al Ewing did.
MrKerf
He/Him- 2,101
- 842
I will apply those then.I think that your conclusions in this post seem reasonable to apply.
MrKerf
He/Him- 2,101
- 842
Actually, I won't be applying anything. Pages are protected. Can you open these, please?:I think that your conclusions in this post seem reasonable to apply.
Griever at the End of All Things (Marvel Comics)
Scarlet Witch (Marvel Comics)
- 58
- 49
What about the Well Beyond Worlds that Wanda created?I think that your conclusions in this post seem reasonable to apply.
- 168,510
- 77,216
I have done so. Tell me here when you are done.
- 168,510
- 77,216
I do not remember. It depends on what other knowledgeable members think.
MrKerf
He/Him- 2,101
- 842
Well, I did add most. Again, not sure why categories are so barren.I have done so. Tell me here when you are done.
Also, Wanda already has mention of containing Chthon and Darkhold in base, so I just added relevant statistics there.
- 58
- 49
Isn't her new form as The Living Darkhold meant to contain Chthon and the Darkhold? If so, why is it referred to in her base form?
Also IIRC , in Scarlet Witch Annual #1, it's stated that The Living Darkhold is much more powerful than Wanda has ever been, and the Darkhold is At least low 1-A, possibly higher. I don't think we should categorize The Living Darkhold as part of Wanda's base form.it should be considered a separate key.
Last edited:
MrKerf
He/Him- 2,101
- 842
I have no idea. But I don't think I should change anything not covered in this crt.
- 58
- 49
She doesn't have a new key and only provided feats from her battle with the Griever in her base form? So maybe we should wait till Antvasima comes, as you stated that the categories are quite barren.
Btw, I have read the issues , and Wanda did more than just fight the Griever. She created The Well Beyond Worlds , source of all magic energies and threatened the Grand Design, a concept that governs all creations. All of this should qualify her as At least low 1-A.
Last edited:
- 18,712
- 12,971
How did Wanda create the Well Beyond the Worlds?
- 58
- 49
In Trail of Magento, she created Eldritch Orchard from chaos magic, which appears to be The Well Beyond Worlds in Resurrection of Magneto.
MrKerf
He/Him- 2,101
- 842
Ugh. So, against my better judgement, I've read both Trial of Magneto and Resurrection of Magneto.
Trial didn't help. Wanda made a pocket dimension to act as mutant afterlife - no big deal.
Second is interesting though. Due to the #1 issue, it is fairly clear that the Waiting Room was created inside The Well Beyond Worlds. Why they aren't one and the same? Well, the Well was mentioned back in 2007 Marvel Tarot, not created by Wanda in any way.
Now, we don't know to what the Well scales to. However, it is at the very top of magical dimensions. Earth-616 dimensions. Very importantly, it is always stated to be related to one universe, which is in line with the whole technological and magical division that we know is in-universe.
Now, I can only speculate, how the road to afterlife went through the Overspace. But overall, still capped at Low 1-A in my opinion.
Trial didn't help. Wanda made a pocket dimension to act as mutant afterlife - no big deal.
Second is interesting though. Due to the #1 issue, it is fairly clear that the Waiting Room was created inside The Well Beyond Worlds. Why they aren't one and the same? Well, the Well was mentioned back in 2007 Marvel Tarot, not created by Wanda in any way.
Now, we don't know to what the Well scales to. However, it is at the very top of magical dimensions. Earth-616 dimensions. Very importantly, it is always stated to be related to one universe, which is in line with the whole technological and magical division that we know is in-universe.
Now, I can only speculate, how the road to afterlife went through the Overspace. But overall, still capped at Low 1-A in my opinion.
- 1,426
- 3,583
Yeah. The hierarchy of mystic dimensions as described in the old Marvel Magic handbooks from the late 2000’s was always:
-Inner Planes (God Realms, most Hells, Elder Gods of Earth’s Dimensions).
-Outer Planes/Consecution of Colors (Dark Dimension, Crimson Cosmos, Purple Dimension, Sixth Dimension).
-Far Realms/Celestial Concordance (Some niche Mystic Principality dimensions like Munnopor and Cinnibus, and the Well Beyond Worlds).
Then of course, the Abstract Dimensions are equal to or above the Far Realms, and the Scientific Universe (Negative Zone, Subspace) are beneath the Mystic Dimensions.
- 18,712
- 12,971
Yeah, and it seems relatively consistent with the exception of the Astral Plane being near the bottom
- 58
- 49
Wanda didn't just create a ' pocket dimension ' . She also created a whole dimension called Eldritch Orchard . After that, she created a pocket reality, the Waiting Room, to connect to Eldritch Orchard. The Waiting Room exists within Well Beyond Worlds because Wanda initially attempted to connect to Eldritch Orchard during the Resurrection of Magento. That's why the Eldritch Orchard is Well Beyond Worlds.
I know this events kinda messy but is reasonable, especially considering that one of the darkest forms of magic, time magic, in "Defenders" (2021) allows travel even before existence itself. And in "Trial of Magneto," the events frequently involve the timestream, intertwining past, present, and future.
I don’t think Well Beyond Worlds exists at the top of Universal-Eternity , as it exists in a layer called 'Cosmic Concordance.' One of the realms in this layer, the Dream Dimension/Sleepwalker's Realm, is currently confirmed to be The Superflow.
Last edited:
- 1,426
- 3,583
Some comments:
1. The Celestial Concordance is straight up just a tier of mystic dimensions that exist at (or near) the top of Universal Eternity, the outermost mystic planes in the Universe.
2. The "Splinter Realms" refers to a class of mystic dimensions across the Inner Planes, Outer Planes, and Far Realms. They originally belonged to one huge dimension called the "Dark Dimension," but split off into various Realms. The Dream Dimension is just one of the Splinter Realms, as is Dormammu's Dark Dimension (which is the largest of the Splinter Realms).
2. The Dream Dimension, in which Nightmare's Realm is located, is not the same thing as the Superflow. It's stated to be connected to the Splinter Realms, Astral Plane, and Far Realms (Celestial Concordance) simultaneously.
- 58
- 49
I don't know, but it was confirmed to be the Superflow, which is the informational space between universes. It is said to be where dreams, ideas, and visions originate, and where telepathy operates.
And the Dream Dimension/Mindscape is not part of the Splinter Realms, as it is said to exist beyond the layers of Splinter Realms.
Last edited:
- 1,080
- 221
- Thread starter
- #231
Should Scarlet Witch gain a new hax and an upgrade for the Griever based on a new statement in her current comic, Scarlet Witch issue #5? This issue shows her resisting existence erasure from The Griever's attacks, indicating that The Griever can erase things from existence, rather than just destroying them.
MrKerf
He/Him- 2,101
- 842
I can get behind EE, but I think we should stop at this point and continue in the next crt, once the run is either finished, or has more issues.
Aside from EE mentioned above, I am done. Since Wanda has Darkhold at base, I have added new abilities and if new key is needed - restructuring of her page can be dealt with in some other threads.I have done so. Tell me here when you are done.
- 1,080
- 221
- Thread starter
- #234
Maybe we should move Darkhold into her new key instead of her base form and create a new key, or we could wait for another CRT for her revisions because there are many things we didn't put in her AP.Do we still need to do anything here, or should I close this thread and lock the Scarlet Witch and Griever pages?
- 58
- 49
For me, we should close this thread and wait for another revision for Wanda, iWhat do the rest of you think?
- 1,080
- 221
- Thread starter
- #237
Yeah, and I think we should remove all her new statuses, like defeating the Griever and having immeasurable speed from the profile, since those apply only to her Darkhold state , not base form nor HOM. And wait for her new crt.
- 92
- 25
I agree, if you don't split the key, you should probably remove it and wait for a new CRT.
Excellence616
He/Him- 6,125
- 4,405
- 92
- 25
I agree.
Similar threads
- Locked
