- 6,436
- 1,664
- Thread starter
- #41
Bump...
I posted on Matt's message asking him to comment...
I posted on Matt's message asking him to comment...
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
What does bump and based mean?Bump...
I posted on Matt's message asking him to comment...
Off-screen feats are still validable if balatant enough.I... Think 2-A for Athena and a bunch of other characters scaling from random mentions of "Fought Zeus" off-screen is unfounded. I'm sorry.
Like Athena never had Holy Wars with Zeus and the stuff with Typhon in the Novel I don't think it's applicable because it's completely different writers with different ideas of how that went down.
And in Episode G Assassin which is the only Saint Seiya material where we actually see Zeus he is specifically noted as being stronger than Hades while in a vastly weakened form in a host body so the idea that Hades is comparable to Zeus.
Also the mad ravings of Gemini Saga's Evil Half aren't a valid source of information. Him thinking that he can kill Zeus or even Hades and Poseidon is just delusion.
Also Hades' underworld affecting all universes is a blatant lie. The Multi-Dimensional thing in the Underworld just connects across universes it doesn't mean there's only one underworld for all realities. In fact every depiction of the multiverse in Saint Seiya is contrary to that.
What evidence do you have that their all different Gods? What is to say there is infinite host bodies, but a finite god?We see in Assassin that different timelines have their own version of Athena, Zeus and Hades.
Because we see that there's multiple Hades in the same book.if the Underworld connects to "many" universes as you said. Why would it need multiple Hades?
The narration is hyperbolic this would mean Hades is stronger than Zeus which is not true.There is also the narration of Hades cutting an Urn that Zeus cannot destroy with his sword. This should show how comparable they are as well. This is a supporting feat.
The Typhon that Athena sealed was weakened, this much is clear? Zeus did most of the work in every account.The entire war with Typhon is completely unknown. We only the major plot points, but the finer details are completely unknown
Also reverse the order of your statements and you debunk yourself. Saga may have all the knowledge ever but he was still super arrogant and consummed by hubris and he was defeated by Bronze Saints because of it. His aspirations of defeating Poseidon, Hades and Zeus and rulling the universe are nothing more than the ravings of a madman.hard disagree here; Saga might be boastful. He might have been arrogant. However, he had the entire history of all generations of previous popes, and wars, at his disposal
I don't have much time atmBecause we see that there's multiple Hades in the same book.
The narration is hyperbolic this would mean Hades is stronger than Zeus which is not true.
The Typhon that Athena sealed was weakened, this much is clear? Zeus did most of the work in every account.
I also think 2-A Cronus is kinda wonk...
I'm actually quite curious on how Episode G Requiem is progressing and it is elaborating on the Primordial Gods. We might get more clear feats.
You're right, a few statements saying they're comparable shouldn't be enough for an upgrade. However, I'd argue 2-C Zeus is therefore more consistent than his current rating, 2-A is an outlier if a bow from Athena (a 2-C) can destroy his body and soul.I"m fine whatever with 2-C. But 2-A based on a few statements of "Oh Hades is comparable to Zeus" or a character boasting which are demonstrably untrue are not acceptable.
Not at all, there is 0 reason to believe the narration is hyperbole, Zeus would simply do more damage to the urn than Hades would, but Hades would downscale from Zeus.The narration is hyperbolic this would mean Hades is stronger than Zeus which is not true.
that is true, it's more likely time manip, so ironically, Zeus would upscale from Hades' 2-C feat.....I also think 2-A Cronus is kinda wonk...
Saga being wrong about himbeating the gods doesn't make him wrong about Athena and Zeus partaking in holy wars which was the initial argument.Also reverse the order of your statements and you debunk yourself. Saga may have all the knowledge ever but he was still super arrogant and consummed by hubris and he was defeated by Bronze Saints because of it. His aspirations of defeating Poseidon, Hades and Zeus and rulling the universe are nothing more than the ravings of a madman
explained in the post above.Because we see that there's multiple Hades in the same book.
The feat can only be 2-A under the interpretation there is only 1 Zeus throughout the cosmology this is due to Cronus' dialogue that "not even Zeus could escape him" - which we know from GA that Zeus can freely roam the cosmology no issues, but with multiple Zeus, that statement doesn't support 2-A, it debunks it.I personally thought the initial 2-A feat from Cronus had some backing; at least for confirmation of the cosmologies size. But I'm not knowledgeable on the scaling or if anyone actually effected the multiverse. But I pretty much agree that not everyone should scale from the 2-A stuff.
Because we see that there's multiple Hades in the same book.
2 identical beings cannot co-exist alongside each other in the same world. Both will desire to be unique and will not accept their duality. Saga's split personality suffered this fate. Ikki vs Aiolia was also this fate. Esermalda was reborn and suffered this fate.
This unique verse mechanic also extends to hierarchies, objects, and locations
This was all stated by pope Kanon
and gets reiterated again by Ikki and Seiya
Why is this mechanic important?
Yoshino (an Athena) existed in the same timeline as Kido Saori Athena for 16 years without any issue.
Chaos Athena of the Lost World met Yoshino Athena which is her twin, but the two of them had no issue. (there is 3 scans here) In fact, the Lost World wants her back in their own world.
The narration is hyperbolic this would mean Hades is stronger than Zeus which is not true.
The Typhon that Athena sealed was weakened, this much is clear? Zeus did most of the work in every account.
I also think 2-A Cronus is kinda wonk...
I'm actually quite curious on how Episode G Requiem is progressing and it is elaborating on the Primordial Gods. We might get more clear feats.
it doesn't debunk anything. Sagas ultimate goal was world domination, but the gods that have been coveting the earth stand in his way. He needs a way fight them equally. he needed a counter measure so that he could keep earth under his control.Also reverse the order of your statements and you debunk yourself. Saga may have all the knowledge ever but he was still super arrogant and consummed by hubris and he was defeated by Bronze Saints because of it. His aspirations of defeating Poseidon, Hades and Zeus and rulling the universe are nothing more than the ravings of a madman.
But I pretty much agree that not everyone should scale from the 2-A stuff.
But we literally see it happen dude! The Lost World Zeus and the Lost World Athena are completely different people and we see the Lost World version of Hades kill his universe's version of the Saints. The mechanic is being misinterpreted!This gets contradicted by the mechanic the verse has created. There cannot be 2 of the same being that exist in the same world. They would attempt to kill each other, or one would actually go mad.
we see Zeus take control of LW Aiolia, we see LW Saori and we see LW Shun-Hades. - all of which are mortals.But we literally see it happen dude! The Lost World Zeus and the Lost World Athena are completely different people and we see the Lost World version of Hades kill his universe's version of the Saints. The mechanic is being misinterpreted!
I read the evidence. This is just gueswork. Never the book goes "Oh, only the hosts are different", rather the hosts alongside their gods being different is the far more likely explanation that I see.I implore you to actually read the evidence being presented to you. The argument put forth to you is trying to explain Gods have multiple hosts throughout the multiverse, which is supported by the fact two identical beings cannot coexist, and thus there can only be one of each God throughout the multiverse despite having many hosts.
Literally only Hades' Sword, Athena's staff and Shield scale to Zeus' lightning....About 2-A Cronus:
Also... The feat is just ******* weird? Like, I'm not a fundamentalist who thinks only punching feats are valid for tiers but Cronus' feat is just so weird. First he blows up the Hourglass of Time which starts distorting time on Earth and etc. And then when he's fighting the Saints he says that all of time will be destroyed and he summons this circle of flames on a wheel behind his back and he explains that when all the flames are out all of existence will collapse.
- The concept of a multiverse wasn't even introduced in Episode G, it was only clearly established much later with recent developments in Next Dimension and Lost Canvas Gaiden and only really solidied in Assassin
- Cronus talks about "Destroying all of time, all of past and future, all of existence" which I guess you can stretch to 2-A. But some translations I've seen have less clear language, like having Cronus say he will "destroy the whole world" which is far more vague. Given how we were all bamboozled for years by the Episode G Translations all saying Universe when Mu actually says Galaxy I think we could try looking at the RAW version of Cronus' lines, if possible.
- The evidence that I think best signifies that Cronus' feat is definitely affecting more than one universe is the line where he explains that both Earth and Tartarus will be destroyed. If it wasn't for that line I'd just say it was a universal feat without any further evidence.
Like I think it's definitely legit but it just rubs me the wrong way. And if you really want to start scaling practically every god (Which, if Athena scales, then virtually every god does) to this it'd be such an insane outlier.
However I think there may be a future to 2-A Saint Seiya what with recent developments in Saint Seiya Requiem making it very clear that the Primordial Gods are unique for all parallel universes, and also Pontos being very implied to be the literal "Black Sea" between all universes and timelines.
in your opinion*This is just gueswork
Because "all of existence" is not in every translation and it may just mean universe.It's pretty blatant there can only exist a single one of each God, I have no Idea why Cronus would attempt to destroy all of existence to find Zeus if there's infinite Zeus'.
which is fair, however, if the Japanese is "sekai" or "world" , world can translate to existence and if the official BR translation is translated to "existence", the official translation should take priority over any fan translation, and there wouldn't be any inherent contradiction with the raws.Because "all of existence" is not in every translation and it may just mean universe.
But we literally see it happen dude! The Lost World Zeus and the Lost World Athena are completely different people and we see the Lost World version of Hades kill his universe's version of the Saints. The mechanic is being misinterpreted!
About 2-A Cronus:
Also... The feat is just ******* weird? Like, I'm not a fundamentalist who thinks only punching feats are valid for tiers but Cronus' feat is just so weird. First he blows up the Hourglass of Time which starts distorting time on Earth and etc. And then when he's fighting the Saints he says that all of time will be destroyed and he summons this circle of flames on a wheel behind his back and he explains that when all the flames are out all of existence will collapse.
- The concept of a multiverse wasn't even introduced in Episode G, it was only clearly established much later with recent developments in Next Dimension and Lost Canvas Gaiden and only really solidied in Assassin
- Cronus talks about "Destroying all of time, all of past and future, all of existence" which I guess you can stretch to 2-A. But some translations I've seen have less clear language, like having Cronus say he will "destroy the whole world" which is far more vague. Given how we were all bamboozled for years by the Episode G Translations all saying Universe when Mu actually says Galaxy I think we could try looking at the RAW version of Cronus' lines, if possible.
- The evidence that I think best signifies that Cronus' feat is definitely affecting more than one universe is the line where he explains that both Earth and Tartarus will be destroyed. If it wasn't for that line I'd just say it was a universal feat without any further evidence.
Like I think it's definitely legit but it just rubs me the wrong way. And if you really want to start scaling practically every god (Which, if Athena scales, then virtually every god does) to this it'd be such an insane outlier.
However I think there may be a future to 2-A Saint Seiya what with recent developments in Saint Seiya Requiem making it very clear that the Primordial Gods are unique for all parallel universes, and also Pontos being very implied to be the literal "Black Sea" between all universes and timelines.
And if you really want to start scaling practically every god (Which, if Athena scales, then virtually every god does) to this it'd be such an insane outlier.
also Pontos being very implied to be the literal "Black Sea" between all universes and timelines.
Even so, Athena was iirc amped by the bronzes when she defeated Hades, implying Zeus<~Hades' sword>>>>Hades' physical~amped Athena>>>AthenaCould you explain to me how they would scale? because what I am applying on this thread is only for her Shield, hax, and Staff. I am not applying a higher tier to her physical base durability, punches, or kicks. I am only applying a higher tier to her Shield (Her blocking skill) and her Staff (her weapon) and her hax (Which doesn't scale to AP)
What other Gods have destroyed strictly only the shield, or staff?
I know what it's like to busy irl. We shouldn't rush anything lol. Sometimes its also good to take a couple day break from the wiki and come back later
Each universe has its own Underworld and each universe has its own version of Hades. The Underworld is not nexus to all realities, it is only the world of the dead, a world completely different from the time-space of the universe (it is not even affected by the distortion in time-space that is destroying the universe), but it is world created by Hades' version of that universe. Aiolos uses a portal (black nucleus) to connect his world (Lost World) with another world.Hades = Tier 2-A Scaling with Zeus but ONLY with his sword. Not his physical stats!
Range for Hades should be 2-A. His Underworld is connected to all worlds as if it is some sort of nexus of all realities.
It was never the attack with the power of 12 Gold Saints, because it was only an attack with a fraction of the power of some Gold Saints (Taurus, Cancer, Pisces and Aries), Silver Saints and Bronze Saints.Hypnos:
Attack Potency: Low Multiverse level (Comparable to his brother Thanatos)
Durability: Low Multiverse level (Hypnos tanked an attack that had the combined force/power of an entire era of saints including the Pope, all 12 Gold Saints, all Silver and Bronze saints of that era. He took some damage from a God Cloth Pegasus Seiya)
everything here has been explained in the thread.I have a question, because Cronus and Zeus are 2-A. What is the justification for this?
I read the profile and it says that Cronus threatens to destroy the multiverse, but that never happened in the manga.
Cronus only says that his power affects the time of planet Earth (altering the different epochs of the planet) and the area where he was fighting with Aiolia (the castle of the Titans in the Tartarus).
Even each universe in the multiverse of Saint Seiya has its own version of the gods, for each universe there is a Hades, Cronus, Zeus, etc, so destroying the multiverse was never an option for a god. The only god that is likely unique is the version of Chronus that appears in ND.
Cronus and Zeus are probably 2-C by powerscalling of Hades and other gods.
Each universe has its own Underworld and each universe has its own version of Hades. The Underworld is not nexus to all realities, it is only the world of the dead, a world completely different from the time-space of the universe (it is not even affected by the distortion in time-space that is destroying the universe), but it is world created by Hades' version of that universe. Aiolos uses a portal (black nucleus) to connect his world (Lost World) with another world.
Even in Dark Wing, Athena (with an attack known as the "light of Athena") destroyed the Underworld of Hades in that universe.
It was never the attack with the power of 12 Gold Saints, because it was only an attack with a fraction of the power of some Gold Saints (Taurus, Cancer, Pisces and Aries), Silver Saints and Bronze Saints.
Hakurei's attack only uses the souls of his former companions to strengthen his technique, but they are only souls with a fraction of the cosmos of the Saints, a group of souls that weren't even wearing his true armor.
The first translation is different in Japanese and Cronus only indicates that he will destroy Aiolia.everything here has been explained in the thread.
It is part of the multiverse and the Saint Seiya franchise, even the last chapter has a reference to the multiverse, because the version of Aiolos from this universe has a memory of the world of Seiya and company, or it is even possible that this Aiolos is the reincarnation of the Aiolos of the main universe.and prove dark wing is canon.