- 6,928
- 7,292
Yeah, i saw his """Contributions""" for the wiki and he already vandalized some Bleach profiles
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Rule Violation Reports (New forum)
- Thread starter Antvasima
- Start date
The_Yellow_Topaz
She/Her- 1,477
- 1,512
Why is GOKU'S profile even open? This is one of the most popular characters in the site, his profile should be closed.
- 6,928
- 7,292
Someone probably made an edit to it and forget to ask to it be closed
- 31,579
- 28,028
Blocked them.
- 7,904
- 14,966
We have a new thread for Wiki Vandalism located here just for future reference.
- 13,329
- 21,302
If this is a joke, it's in very poor taste. And if it's not, that's even worse...
Should something be done about this? Personally, I believe so
noninho
He/Him- 4,035
- 1,282
Personally if there isn't anything done I will be very offended as I have a trans woman in my family and do not think is acceptable that we have a rule against that in our site, it happens on a place full of people that I trust to have high regard for that and all the other rules and nothing happens.
- 17,636
- 13,172
so uhh what do?
noninho
He/Him- 4,035
- 1,282
Like racism, Transphobia kills many people | every day.
Where the actual f*ck is our moderation that can take care of a racist vandalism in less than 10 minutes to give a statement about a literal crime that the person who spoke that sh*t doesn't even mind deffending themselves?
- 31,579
- 28,028
- 17,636
- 13,172
As someone who knows Shmoopy, he jokes around a lot. He joked around a bit too much this time. I think equating his mild implication that he is transphobic (which is clearly a joke) to calls for trans murder and to a guy who outright smeared a profile with words like "I hate n-" is very much wrong. Should he be punished? That's up to staff to decide. However I think treating it as outright blatant transphobia is very much wrong.
- 10,541
- 12,358
Imagine the absolute disrespect comparing actual tragedies to this random comment.
The_Yellow_Topaz
She/Her- 1,477
- 1,512
I do think noninho is going a bit overboard, it's a joke done in poor taste
Personally think it's disrespectful to my community to compare tragedies and the bigotry we have to face almost everyday to this backhanded comment. If they should be punished for it or not? I don't really mind, but I'd be satisfied with at least a warning. It's obvious that implying someone is not trans because of your "transphobia" is needlessly hurtful
Personally think it's disrespectful to my community to compare tragedies and the bigotry we have to face almost everyday to this backhanded comment. If they should be punished for it or not? I don't really mind, but I'd be satisfied with at least a warning. It's obvious that implying someone is not trans because of your "transphobia" is needlessly hurtful
- 13,329
- 21,302
I don't find the comparison between piracy and transphobia to be an apt one at all...
That being said, this should be left to the staff now. (Edit: Topaz's input is also welcome since she was the one the comment was directed toward, I feel)
That being said, this should be left to the staff now. (Edit: Topaz's input is also welcome since she was the one the comment was directed toward, I feel)
- 31,579
- 28,028
I think that at the very least, Shmoopy should get an official warning for it. The RVT especially (but also this forum as a whole) is a not a place for jokes in such poor taste.
- 10,541
- 12,358
I can definitely agree there.
- 13,329
- 21,302
Also worth noting, I checked the Warning Tracker and Shmooply has 1 prior warning atm
Idk how much it affects things but I felt it was worth bringing up
Idk how much it affects things but I felt it was worth bringing up
- 7,904
- 14,966
That's more or less my same opinion. I'm hesitant to label it overt transphobia, but a transphobic joke levied against an actual transperson inside an RVR report (one that -- as far as we can tell at this moment -- is inaccurate) is not good and we should at least issue a warning.
- 13,329
- 21,302
I'd say a warning at minimum yeah. I'm content with further action as well if that's agreed on
- 31,638
- 34,660
Lots of posts here and some not so necessary derailment here but.
@Shmooply I will have to give you a strict warning since it was perhaps a joke, but it was a really bad one. It is against Fandom's TOS to be making such comments about sensitive topics such as transphobia or any kind of bigotry regardless of whether or not it is a joke. And therefore, against our TOS since our wiki is still powered by Fandom.
@Shmooply I will have to give you a strict warning since it was perhaps a joke, but it was a really bad one. It is against Fandom's TOS to be making such comments about sensitive topics such as transphobia or any kind of bigotry regardless of whether or not it is a joke. And therefore, against our TOS since our wiki is still powered by Fandom.
User was permabanned, but we do have a separate violation report for vandalism though the racist comment is permaban trolling on top of vandalism yes.
Well, I already informed you about the wrong approaches, so I suppose no further warning on your end. But for now, a light warning sounds like the worst case for now. But most certainly some instructions are needed for that new user at minimum.
- 15,445
- 7,155
I'd like to report @BrainiacWorld for supposed trolling behavior.
Basically, the first is on Bill Cipher vs Alien X, where they suddenly popped up, and made extremely weird comments:
Basically, the first is on Bill Cipher vs Alien X, where they suddenly popped up, and made extremely weird comments:
- Bill Cipher is only possibly 2-A as well, his only determined tier is Low 2-C
- You do realize Celestial Sapiens are capable of destroying universes with a single thought, meanwhile Bill gets spray painted in the face and he yelped in pain
- Whatever the hell is this
- Tell that to the large community on youtube who accept Bill Cipher's Fate to Alien X
GarrixianXD
University Enthusiast
Any/AllVS Battles
Joke Battles
Administrator
Content Moderator
Thread Moderator
Translation Helper
- 4,918
- 11,302
I dealt with them on the wiki before and they seem to be a user who wants to contribute legitimately. Anyways, they're quite new and don't know that debates need to be relevant to the profile statistics so I left them a message.
Last edited:
marosuke
He/Him- 69
- 42
- 3,052
- 1,672
You mean stuff said about Korean people ? Well he deleted it so will it still matters?report a racist word. its deleted.
marosuke
He/Him- 69
- 42
I didn't know that deleting words justifies racist words.
- 9,982
- 10,821
It doesn't justifies.
- 4,621
- 6,678
That is a very inappropriate comment. I will leave them a warning.report a racist word. its deleted.
- 32,835
- 38,111
https://vsbattles.com/threads/black...and-light-speed-statement.163656/post-6331551
https://vsbattles.com/threads/black...and-light-speed-statement.163656/post-6331556
Reporting Luci5678 for condescending behavior and getting hostile over a poorly-made CRT that boasts no scans, no proper justifications and is running solely on argument of incredulity.
Some of the other comments responding there might've been a tad too hostile as well, so if some thread mods could go over there and issue warnings and close the thread (Since it's been met with rejection), that'd be great.
https://vsbattles.com/threads/black...and-light-speed-statement.163656/post-6331556
Reporting Luci5678 for condescending behavior and getting hostile over a poorly-made CRT that boasts no scans, no proper justifications and is running solely on argument of incredulity.
Some of the other comments responding there might've been a tad too hostile as well, so if some thread mods could go over there and issue warnings and close the thread (Since it's been met with rejection), that'd be great.
- 2,269
- 2,104
Calc group members have no authority to reject threads. The thread can still probably be argued for after the new user learns to ignore hate and put his or her messages in one post. The thread shouldn't be closed until staff (not including calc group members/content mods) properly reject it.
- 3,052
- 1,672
- 32,835
- 38,111
We actually do if it involves a calculation or the methods for calculating stuff are involved in it.
- 2,269
- 2,104
You know, telling the user that it’s a rule instead of berating them with insults would have been nice (not you). But it seems staff couldn’t give a **** less unless it hurts them. Seeing as it took me (a normal user) to have to tell people to stop derailing and making fun of the user for a single staff member (out of the 3 in that thread) to do even something remotely helpful.
Is that the case with this thread ? No.
- 111
- 35
i mean i was getting hostile because of the lack of respect these people had, there was no argument against anything i said just insults but when i say insults im just the bad guy? and the rest just begs the question
GarrixianXD
University Enthusiast
Any/AllVS Battles
Joke Battles
Administrator
Content Moderator
Thread Moderator
Translation Helper
- 4,918
- 11,302
You have the right to report the users who you find were behaving offensively.
- 32,835
- 38,111
The RVT is not the place to create this kind of drama, in fact, you should refrain from making such comments in the future. If you think there are issues with staff, go report them to Human Resources.
Yes it is. It discusses the validity of a calc based on it being an outlier or not, and we calc members are expected to have a firm grasp on the wiki's policies (Which includes Outliers) to make said decisions.
- 31,638
- 34,660
While I agree responses to the thread weren't the best, the rejection had points that having no context, scans, or substance equals a recipe for disaster of a thread that can result an immediate closure.
- 111
- 35
I already talked with another mod and she said i could add scans to keep it up
- 111
- 35
but its very late for me so idk if I should add them now or I could wait (5am)
Similar threads
- Sticky
- Featured
- Locked
