Fezzih_007
He/Him- 6,075
- 2,178
The Madness Manipulation of the witches should be removed, for 2 reasons:
1- The reason of them having this ability, is because of both of this scans, in which show Echidna killing a bunch of mobs. The page says " Being in the presence of a witch causes people to go insane resulting in them killing themselves" But nothing in the scan says that all the witches have this ability, or why they should have this ability. The line "there does not seem to be any human being who is able to endure thirty seconds of hell and to meet the six witches." don't prove that each individual Witch can do this alone, the scan says that Omega, currently caring the six withes on her pocket, as able to kill everyone on her vicinity because of a combination of all of them.
The scan also says "The eighteen people who weren't able to reach the proposal's goal were all unbearable affected by Echidna's wickedness and madness" so there you go, this makes clear that is a Echidna ability, not a general thing about witches.
2- I was looking around, and people are saying that the MM are passive, and that's actually make my job easier tkx
. There's a problem saying that the ability is passive, because of every time is show a Witch around someone, they never show getting insane. Is said a bunch of time how the witches are around people, and is never stated of peope dying of MM, like how Typhon have to come close and touch people and using her powers and in any moment the MM kicks or is mentioned, Minerva as able to heal people by punching them and never once killed them with MM, Sattela as around Garfiel and the ryuzu clones and they don't die because of MM, Pandora as around Pete, Fort and Emi and they don't die of madnes manipulation. I have some other billions of example of Witches being around someone and they don't going insane, but this will make the thread very long, so les't cut short. So since is cleary show that people when near witches don't die, we have three options:
(Is also funny that neither of the witches have Resistance to madness manipulation in the profiles, but can stand around each other just fine lol)
While we are here, the Aura that are in they page should also dissapear because of the poor reasoning of them having said aura.
"Aura (Similar to Reid, a witch's presence causes others to experience fear, causing them to vomit)"
Nevermind the fact that is never once mentioned aura in there (Presence could mean a lot of things, not nescessary aura) the answer and the question never suggest this being a witches thing, is just a general thing of fear. If someone knows the thing in front of them is gonna kill them, they gonna vomit in fear, is nothing to do with aura. Also worth to note that Echidna is the only who benefits for this.
So for reasons above, all the witches should get Aura and MM removed, except best girl echidna.
Votes
Makes sense yeah:
Dissagre for X and Y reasons:
1- The reason of them having this ability, is because of both of this scans, in which show Echidna killing a bunch of mobs. The page says " Being in the presence of a witch causes people to go insane resulting in them killing themselves" But nothing in the scan says that all the witches have this ability, or why they should have this ability. The line "there does not seem to be any human being who is able to endure thirty seconds of hell and to meet the six witches." don't prove that each individual Witch can do this alone, the scan says that Omega, currently caring the six withes on her pocket, as able to kill everyone on her vicinity because of a combination of all of them.
The scan also says "The eighteen people who weren't able to reach the proposal's goal were all unbearable affected by Echidna's wickedness and madness" so there you go, this makes clear that is a Echidna ability, not a general thing about witches.
2- I was looking around, and people are saying that the MM are passive, and that's actually make my job easier tkx
. There's a problem saying that the ability is passive, because of every time is show a Witch around someone, they never show getting insane. Is said a bunch of time how the witches are around people, and is never stated of peope dying of MM, like how Typhon have to come close and touch people and using her powers and in any moment the MM kicks or is mentioned, Minerva as able to heal people by punching them and never once killed them with MM, Sattela as around Garfiel and the ryuzu clones and they don't die because of MM, Pandora as around Pete, Fort and Emi and they don't die of madnes manipulation. I have some other billions of example of Witches being around someone and they don't going insane, but this will make the thread very long, so les't cut short. So since is cleary show that people when near witches don't die, we have three options:- Since people are not going insane by the supposely passive Madness Manipulation, they don't have the ability.
- The ability itself is not passive, but something they have to activate.
- The ability is passive, but is something Echidna can control to lesser the effect and only she can do the MM.
While we are here, the Aura that are in they page should also dissapear because of the poor reasoning of them having said aura.
"Aura (Similar to Reid, a witch's presence causes others to experience fear, causing them to vomit)"
Nevermind the fact that is never once mentioned aura in there (Presence could mean a lot of things, not nescessary aura) the answer and the question never suggest this being a witches thing, is just a general thing of fear. If someone knows the thing in front of them is gonna kill them, they gonna vomit in fear, is nothing to do with aura. Also worth to note that Echidna is the only who benefits for this.
So for reasons above, all the witches should get Aura and MM removed, except best girl echidna.
Votes
Makes sense yeah:
Dissagre for X and Y reasons:
