Problems with The Player (Meteor 60 seconds)

[Wokistan]

The Player (Meteor, 60 Seconds)

Let's begin.

Attack Potency and Durability
Attack Potency: Small Building level (Can kill people, athletes, and soldiers in few punches, Can destroy a rocket ship, Can destroy a car)

The issue here is that this calc is for a pretty specific method of destroying a car, this can easily have been done over multiple hits, and no citation is provided here. A clip of the car being destroyed should be supplied so we can verify it's even the type of destruction the calc even works for.

Dwarf Star level with nuclear receiver (The nuke completely vaporizes earth)

Again, this is calcless and I feel like I've seen vaporizing the earth at weirdly low results before. I have no source for this claim yeah but it's still as much of a source as the file has for this rating, so...

At least Human level, possibly Small Building level (He doesn't show any feats outside the simulation, however it's likely he should scale to his strength in the simulation)

Gotta love when there's no reason for this being likely. Seriously, this seems like a completely random assumption. Do I scale to any game character because I've used VR before?

Speed
Subsonic (Can outrun bikes on foot, isn't much slower than bullets)

Bikers shouldn't be assumed to constantly be going at the fastest speeds ever hit on a bike, and I'd at least like an example of the latter to be shown.

At least Normal Human, possibly Subsonic (He doesn't show any feats outside the simulation, however it's likely he should scale to his strength in the simulation)

Same issue as before.

Range
Range: Standard melee range, Extended melee range with baseball bat, Dozens of meters with an Assault Rifle, Several Kilometers with Nuclear Receiver

Rifles would be hundreds of meters, unless he has poor showings with it or something. If we take the High 5-A thing as truth, that's a lot more than just "several kilometers."

Intelligence
Intelligence: Above Average (Managed to save the earth without killing anyone from an meteor in under 60 seconds, Can operate a rocket ship, Knows how to use an assault rifle)

This is quite frankly just bizarre. The first one is very circumstance dependent but likely way above "above average", the second really depends how realistic the rocket ship is, and operating a rifle really isn't that hard. They're rather intuitive.

In conclusion, this profile has problems. Fix them.

 

[Buttersamuri]

I can answer these problems in a bit but A bit busy atm

 

[Jackythejack]

To elaborate on the earth vaporizing

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/U...l_Calc:_Vaporizing_Earth#WikiaArticleComments

 

[Buttersamuri]

AP/Durability

As far as grabbing links. I'll have to either record my own video of doing it or check youtube when they do it, but I'll get clips on the Car feat. The Rocket ship feat should also be supportive of the feat. Considering he can destroy it. Which it's this big


I put dwarf star because that's where I've seen several planet destruction feats Get. But Jacky linking that gives us what level it actually is. So we can fix that.


Speed

here's a few times where he started to move after shooting. I don't have much to say about the bike

Range

Well that's an easy fix. I've just seen these weapons typically get dozens unless shown otherwise. Not hundreds of meters


Intelligence

First one is mostly quick thinking, with a mixture of intelligence. Solving small problems to solve the big one in under 60 seconds. People in the way. Items he needed to grab. The most intelligent part is operating the ship, operating the nuclear receiver, and Handling this all in under 60 seconds.

We don't know how complicated it was. He runs in and shoots up into space. He also can use it to dodge the meteor and fly off into space to escape earth and the meteor. (Side note. This may offer a good reaction feat)

Operating a rifle in the spot is still fairly intelligent. It's still worth noting in his intelligence