TheFinalOrder said:
4.)Except they were casual which you fail to understand. You also fail to understand Casual Yhwach is not just 5-C. It ranges much lower.
The 5-C feat is from a casual Yhwach post absorbing Mimihagi and SK.
TheFinalOrder said:
With no feats, context or implications, Shikai Ichigo and Base Yhwach are just "Arbitrarily" scaling from him which means neither Aizen nor Dangai scale to Kenpachi Either. (I'm sure even IMade would even agree that without any real evidence backing up the stat boost, they shouldn't scale considering his own arguments in Naruto revisions). If there is valid scaling or feats, then we can disregard this.
I personally have my own issues with the Keys and such, but I wouldn't say it's the Tiering of them, rather that the Keys where these scalings are occuring are messed up kinda. But I guess we'll stick to the keys being specifically discussed here:
High 6-A Scaling
Base Yhwach
Yhwach is deemed
High 6-A per his profile description:
Multi-Continent level (Far superior to Shikai Kenpachi, who casually destroyed a meteor without releasing his eyepatch. He is the only Quincy capable of handling the power of Yamamoto's Bankai). Yamamoto is
High 6-A because Royd Lloyd is
High 6-A and cause only Yhwach could contain Yamamoto's Bankai. The assumption of Royd Lloyd being High 6-A is cause he could withstand being near Yama's Bankai and mimicried Yhwach. If you notice, the Yama part is circular scaling. Royd is
High 6-A cause Yama is
High 6-A and Yama is
High 6-A because Yhwach is
High 6-A and half of Yhwach's reasoning is because Yama is
High 6-A. The other half of Royd's reasoning is also an issue. He's
High 6-A for mimicrying Yhwach... except that Loyd mimicry's power and Royd mimicries memories. Royd can only be
High 6-A through Yamamoto, but Yamamoto's reasonings are based on Yhwach and Yhwach's reasonings are being discussed right now with one half of it just being proven as incorrect scaling. This leaves us with the first portion of Yhwach's
High 6-A scaling:
Far superior to Shikai Kenpachi. The issue with this reasoning is that it's not completed. The Admin Dark applied this reasoning after the acceptance of the
High 6-A calc in mid August, but he left out the discussion that was given for why Base Yhwach was going to it.
You made this thread to bring up the calc to all our attentions even. In that thread
you even asked about True Shikai Ichigo and Base Yhwach scaling to the High 6-A yield.
If you read through that thread, it was actually SoldierBlue, BurningFullFingers and Dark649 that stated Bankai Yamamoto, Dangai Ichigo and Hogyoku Aizen as all superior to Shikai Kenpachi. Which reinforces the
High 6-A Base Yhwach as he is above Bankai Yamamoto. I think it's a mess cause it wasn't properly labeled and Royd's profile was a mess already, hopefully we can clean that.
True Shikai Ichigo
Simple scaling from Dangai Ichigo, profile could use some clean up though in my opinion. Took hits from a casual Post Mimihagi and SK Yhwach with Almighty off. Base Yhwach was casually
High 6-A from the start of the arc. Yhwach got stronger after the first invasion due to the deaths of Quincy and Shinigami. Then Yhwach got further stronger during the second invasion with more deaths. Then Yhwach activated Almighty during his fight with Ichibei. Then Yhwach got even more stronger after absorbing Mimihagi. Then Yhwach got even more stronger after absorbing the Soul King. It's a lot of amps off a casual
High 6-A from the start.
5-C Scaling
EoS Aizen / Muken Aize
Hollow Merge True Shikai is
5-C and could hurt Post Mimihagi and SK Yhwach with Almighty off. A stronger and more durable Hollow Merge True Bankai Ichigo was casually ****** by Post Mimihagi and SK Yhwach with Almighty on. EoS Aizen no-sold an attack from that same Yhwach that was greater than what he threw at Ichigo in his past two modes that are already
5-C.
The bigger crime here is that
I've been waiting for us to remove the Reiatsu = Durability = AP policy that we have for Bleach that would have properly explained this scaling between the three with better reasonings. There is also the fact that the Bankai multiplier takes a hand here, but we have yet to implement multipliers for Bleach, so the scaling is a bit more off too.
Should Also Mentio
If you refer back to the original thread where this discussion first started, you would notice that Soldier Blue refers a lot about the Cero Oscuras and Lanza Del Relampago calcs that could potentially yield High 6-A as well, we were actually waiting for those as support; however, Soldier Blue is really busy at the moment which is why we currently have a backlog of around 11 CRTs for Bleach. Account for this and the Reaitsu = Durability = AP cleanup removal and then the Bankai multpliers down the line and we'll probably finally have a more proper and cleaner reasoning for all profiles. Right now it's a patch-job waiting for some CRTs to go through and for the bottom up reasoning clean ups to begin.