PMMM Scaling Based on "New" Info

[SomebodyData]

Introductio

Hello, it's me again, your friendly neighborhood Somebody, and today while watching JoJo I found a little article that is pretty good for the scaling of the PMMM characters, which I leave here.

http://www.crunchyroll.com/anime-ne...-quantifies-who-is-the-strongest-magical-girl

Attack Potency and Durability
6 =53.15 Megatons (City) < Madoka Third Timelines is City level

1.5 gap = 100.4x

4.5= 52.9 Kilotons (Town) < Mami Tomoe is Town level

3= 529 tons Multi-City Block

1.5= 5.29 tons Large Building Level

This Means That:
Sayaka gets High 8-C as a magical girl (Has an offence rating of 1.5)

Kyoko's dura is increased to 8-A (Has a defence rating of 3.5), and have her AP downgraded to 8-A as well

Homura and Mami have their duras increased to High 8-C (Has a defence rating of 1)

Speed
2 = Mach 66 (High Hypersonic +) < Sayaka

This Means That:
Kyoko and Madoka should be upgraded to Massively Hypersonic (Speed Rating of 4) (Madoka however, should be at least Massively Hypersonic)

It should be noted that Mami will be Mach 99, or the maximum of High Hypersonic

NOTE #1: Homura has the speed rating of 0, which would put her at human speed, however, she has shown time and time again to be quick enough to match Mami and has several supersonic feats. This would imply, that rather than actually having human speed, she uses her "Initial Magic" or "Additional Magic" is used to amplify her speed, similarly to her AP

NOTE#2: I'm not using the multiplier for dura and ap because it would land outlandish results, if you want them inputted, you would need a good argument for that

NOTE#3: This uses the mid ends of Town level and City level respectively, in case ya wonder where the numbers came from.

 

[Matthew_Schroeder]

Homura being that weak seems inconsistent. Plus, she was handling Mami very well during Movie 3, and she was still reluctant to kill her.

 

[SomebodyData]

@Matthew, I believed that Note 1 actually mentioned this, not to mention episode 10 showed Homura to be very physically fragile, intill Mami showed her how to use her abdunce of intial magic of course.

 

[Ryukama]

I think it is pretty cool that PMMM has a tiering system. I think these upgrades are reasonable as long as these ratings don't contradict the series' showings, which it seems they do not all that much.

Either way pretty nice and well thought out blog.

 

[Matthew_Schroeder]

I want stats for God Madoka and Devil Homura now.

 

[SomebodyData]

I want stats for God Madoka and Devil Homura now.

We all do lol.

 

[CrossverseCrisis]

I agree with Ryu on this. So long as these ratings don't contradict the series's showings, then i can say it's reasonable to make these changes according to this.

 

[Lina_Shields]

If a 1.5 gap in stats is approximately 100.4x, we can approximate the gap in each level by doing this.

100.4^(1/1.5) = ~21.6x. This would mean that for an increase in each level, we would get a 21.6x increase in terms of AP.

 

[DontTalk]

If this is canon information, is what would have to be proven first (no idea what is canon here).

And then the stats should likely be only used for powerscaling and not for calculating new levels from given feats and mathematical functions. I don't trust not stated logarithmic functions for this stats to be accurate. That initial and additional magic can influence the other stats beyond what they state makes it additionally uncertain how things are weighted.

 

[SomebodyData]

@Crazystarf wouldn't it be approx 66x per each level?

@DontTalk , the pamphlet is WoG

Fair enough about the logarithmic functions, however, with the levels, its seems that leaving Kyoko back to Town level AP and Building level dura, which the stats seem to disagree with greatly. Not to mention the intial and additional magic would only boost the characters (far greater in Homura's case) further, so it would be more of a lowball.

 

[Antvasima]

I don't think that we can assume that the changes for each tier have a specific value, and think that it may be safer to go by feats.

 

[SomebodyData]

@VsBattlesStaff and @FellowMembers Hmmm, alright, thank you for your input.

However, before I close this, I do wanna mention that feats wise and etc this is extraordinarily consistent, in that there are no major contradicts if at all with what the series shows.

EDIT: Just realized this can't be closed. Whoops. Just ignore the thread lol.

 

[Maria_Lucero]

I agree.

Homura never managed to beat Mami.

She would have normal human speed in base, but supersonic (like she was barely faster than thr cars in the freeway when Madoka threw Sayaka's gem.)

I agree with the info.

 

[Antvasima]

Well, as DontTalk said, I am fine with power-scaling characters on the same level from each other, as long as the statistics are official, and it makes logical sense to do so.

 

[CrossverseCrisis]

Alright so......anything?

 

[Antvasima]

Apparently not. I still agree with DontTalk though.

 

[CrossverseCrisis]

Alright.