• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Phoenix Wright downgrade

Status
Not open for further replies.
Both Anime and Game Phoenix have soul manipulation and explosion manip.

The only exclusive abilities anime phoenix has is wind and light manip.
 
Who said purification had to be consentual? The page sure as hell doesn't, it can be done against the user's will just fine and it's still purification. The fact that the page says "evil" spirits should be just semantics, as purification is usually used against evil spirits, not that the spirit needs to be evil to be purified.
 
No, MHA and Hajime no Ippo are literally the same thing as the manga, unlike Phoenix Wright, which not only adds a ton of abilities he has never used anywhere else, but also dramatizes everything and adds new feats.

We don't accept that.
 
Anime Wright has different cases and in even haas some items missing that Game Wright has. (Anime wright doesnt get the magatama or the Rise from the Ashes case nor gets electrocuted by Von Karma just like Game Wright doesnt have the train case nor the light and wind hax.

They are valid for a composite/anime form/profile.
 
@Butters I said prove it. Evidence and such. Not give your opinion on why it wouldn't qualify.

Gonna throw my support in with Crim as well. Just coz other verses do fishy things doesn't justify this verse doing it.
 
Bambu, you should read my posts before cclaiming we have not posted evidence.

Anime and Game interpretations have several differences such as the events that haappen, how they happen, and the items and abilities Wright has on each interpretation.


This alone proves that anime Wright deserves to have his own page or the profile to be made into a composite like VARIOUS profiles.

Like the injustice profiles combining GAME and COMIC feats.

If you disagree with this, then you should make a CRT to remove all of those profiles.
 
''Injustice comics and game are literally in the same continuity and not a repeat of the same events they are literally within the same storyline''
 
I'm sorry but bringing up Injustice is a false equivalency.

Injustice's comics are a direct continuation of the story brought up by the games, not an adaptation. They're direct sequels, not remakes
 
Excuse me, but that is factually incorrect since some events in the comics tell the story from the games.

Also, you are contradicting yourself too since you said it was not allowed to have a character that was too similar for it to just be an "version with new powers" which is not allowed.

So be consistent if you want your argument to be considered valid.


Phoenix in the anime and game have differences and deserve to be part of a composite or different profiles.
 
Objection.

There are various differences between the game and anime continuities for Wright.

1.-Anime Wirght never goes thru Rise from the Ashes, never gets Magatama from Maya, Has the WInd and Light Haxes shown CONSTANTLY in almost all cases, is never electrocuted by Von Karma. Also, not meeting Ema affects the Apollo Justice continuity directly.

2.-Game Wright doesnt have the Train case, the wind or light haxes and does the soul hax on his own, without Mia even being there, also has the Apollo, Spirit of Justice and Dual Destinies games under his belt.


Play the games before claiming they aare the same continuity or are too similar to have different profiles for each one, specially when the wiki already agrees with MANY profiles that have fewer differences.


Someone please close this thread.
 
Now hold up buddy. Get off your high horse.

Literally your entire argument supports removing the anime stuff from the profile, since you are arguing they are different enought to have different profiles.

You still haven't proofed how evidence is standard equipment, or how soul hax isn't actually purification.
 
Phoenix has had those evidences on him at least once during cases.

THe most "standard" equipment is the magatama since he has had it on him for more than 3 cases in Justice for All.
 
Yes, he held them once.

He's never held them again since, Standard Equipment is equipment you always have on you. Phoenix doesn't walk around armed with a gun, statue, and knife at all times.
 
You haven't proven has soul hacks is purification. Removing spirits and souls is something that's possible in Ace Attorney. Spirit mediums are capable of doing it. So it's nothing super special. Phoenix has always been supernatural. Like his abilties to see spirits without a magatama or a spirit medium. Currently. Your just bringing up what ifs. Which don't work in this situation. Phoenix removed a soul. That's soul manipulation. And it's done in a serious non gag moment. Done across both game and anime. and by no means is it treated like a joke or a gag. Plus it's essential to the plot.
 
That's not standard equipment, especially so since he only used them for one case and never again. Magatama, finger prints finder (whatever the things name was) and etanol should be standard equipment since they are constantly used.

Shit like a bomb shouldn't, since he didn't even use it. We don't give Sherlock Holmes's evidence as standard equipment, even when he carries them for entire books.

At most, evidence is opitional equipment.
 
Phoenix didn't remove a soul, he removed a spirit.

Which is exorcism.

Which is purification because a part of purification is removing spirits from a body. Literally exorcism, which is what Phoenix did.

It fits purification more.
 
That is what i said.


Magatama, Ethanol aand finger print finder to be standard equipment

and the evidence as optional.
 
A soul that was possessing a different body. Not a soul that originally belonged in that body. Is the Exorcist suddenly a movie about soul manipulation and not purification?
 
It is never implied Dahlia being evil is a factor...ever.

On any case that tthe Kurai Spirit Channeling tehcnique is used.


If you find a single statement that implies the contrary, i will conceede.
 
That doesn't change the fact he interacted and removed a soul. That's soul manipulation. A Spirit Is A Soul. There isn't any way to twist that. And he removed it. It being in someone else doesn't change that fact
 
The spirit being evil is not a factor in whether it's purification or not. That's just semantics. Purification can still be done on "good" spirits. Even then most exorcisms don't specify the spirit has to be evil.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top