- 34,587
- 35,020
To be safe I think we'd need a third to give their input.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
One Piece: Problem with earthquake calcs
- Thread starter Floxy178
- Start date
- 1,038
- 1,103
- Thread starter
- #83
Could you call some?Preferably 4 I think, to stay on the safe side. At least if this would cause massive changes to the verse.
- 177,663
- 90,690
@Executor_N0 @DMUA @Migue79 @Aguywhodoesthings @DemiiPowa @SeijiSetto @SunDaGamer
Are any of you willing to help out here please?
Are any of you willing to help out here please?
- 4,239
- 4,085
Hey, although I'm no longer a calc group member, I believe I can help out here.
If I've got this right, KLOL is claiming you can use KE and the mass of the planet to calculate the KE of an earthquake right? Well, if I'm correct then,
KLOL, is blatantly wrong here. You're right, it would not require the entire planets mass, that's inherently flawed. An earthquakes energy does not come from the whole earths mass, an earthquake only actually affects the earths crust and MAYBE the upper mantle, not the entire mass of the earth. Making the entire calculation wrong.
- 5,137
- 4,219
You're in luck, that calc will also likely be removed with this thread being accepted.Also, can someone explain this calculation to me? I'm reading it and it seems to be wrong, but I don't want to misunderstand anything before I type out a debunk
- 4,239
- 4,085
Okay, I'm a bit eager to type it out so I won't hesitate too much.
Richter Magnitude of Earthquake = (11.6868517619) + 6.399 + 1.66*log10((109270/110)((2π)/360)) = Magnitude 20.1425679
This doubles the results of the magnitude of the earthquake. 11.6 is the magnitude and then your math doubles it. 6.399 + 1.66*log10((715262.352474/110)((2π)/360)) is wrong, after some research I realise it comes from here. It is not meant to be applied after you already calculated ME from the tsunami, as that doubles the results.
I believe I'm correct here, but we'll see.
Edit: I double checked with agnaa and he's not sure what ME is as it's not on the earthquakes page.
Richter Magnitude of Earthquake = (11.6868517619) + 6.399 + 1.66*log10((109270/110)((2π)/360)) = Magnitude 20.1425679
This doubles the results of the magnitude of the earthquake. 11.6 is the magnitude and then your math doubles it. 6.399 + 1.66*log10((715262.352474/110)((2π)/360)) is wrong, after some research I realise it comes from here. It is not meant to be applied after you already calculated ME from the tsunami, as that doubles the results.
I believe I'm correct here, but we'll see.
Edit: I double checked with agnaa and he's not sure what ME is as it's not on the earthquakes page.
Last edited:
- 177,663
- 90,690
So, about this...
- 4,239
- 4,085
I would be willing to recalculate themYou are allowed to summon other calc group members here to check if you wish, KingTempest.
Also, what would we replace these calculations with if they are rejected? And I did not notice DontTalk commenting here.
.
- 34,587
- 35,020
As mentioned there would be a Content Revision Thread to discuss replacements for ratings. This thread is more for the viability of the calcs.So, about this...
- 177,663
- 90,690
Thank you. That would be very appreciated.I would be willing to recalculate them
Okay. What about Luffy's gigantic compression attack against Kaidou?
- 34,587
- 35,020
There currently isn't a calc for that; it wouldn't help anyway since nobody else in the verse scales to that yet.Okay. What about Luffy's gigantic compression attack against Kaidou?
- 177,663
- 90,690
Okay. Is somebody willing to properly calculate that as well please?
- 1,038
- 1,103
- Thread starter
- #95
That's literally in the OP. It gets Mw, AKA moment magnitude then converts it to Richter magnitude, and then converts it to Richter magnitude again. Problem is it assumes that firstly converted value is magnitude at distance.
I don't know its current size values but if they're provided I can recalc and propose it being calculated with rotational KE which avoids lowballing feat for sake of simplicity (as in previous calculation).Okay. Is somebody willing to properly calculate that as well please?
Last edited:
- 34,587
- 35,020
One thing at a time Antvasima. We'll work on it.Okay. Is somebody willing to properly calculate that as well please?
- 2,425
- 460
Huh, wild. I was talking about this exact thing of discord a bit ago.
Yeah earthquakes are well beyond the point of being too complex to derive a calculation for with pen and paper maths. It’s all computers and a massive amount of data collecting up a working equation.
I agree with the removal of these calcs.
Yeah earthquakes are well beyond the point of being too complex to derive a calculation for with pen and paper maths. It’s all computers and a massive amount of data collecting up a working equation.
I agree with the removal of these calcs.
Ghostimuscrime
He/Him- 3,678
- 3,958
i think the replacement calculation wasn’t made yet for the new sizes so you’d have to make em from scratch, get that accepted and then be able to calc that feat
- 6,437
- 4,299
Who mfs turn into the second its time to make a primary One Piece feat incalculable
- 2,182
- 3,382
bump
- 6,437
- 4,299
Ax One Piece from the wiki because nothing about it can be scaled everSo what do we currently need to do here?
- 5,137
- 4,219
We are currently waiting to get this Accepted (we have 2 @Damage3245 and @DontTalkDT ), but you requested at least 4, but no other calc member seems interested, even after being pinged. (Damaged Also prefer 3, just to be safe)So what do we currently need to do here?
So yeah, we are just waiting for more.
- 177,663
- 90,690
It is the most popular comicbook of all time, and likely one of the most epic, socially relevant, and high quality stories of all time as well.
Okay. We also need to get new accepted versions of the relevant calculations before we apply the statistic revisions.
Should I ping calc group members again?
- 34,587
- 35,020
Don't be dramatic.
We don't need that in order to proceed with revisions, but it'd be good for more calc group members to take a look at this.Okay. We also need to get new accepted versions of the relevant calculations before we apply the statistic revisions.
Should I ping calc group members again?
- 34,587
- 35,020
It's alright Ant; I'll just keep non-relevant posts off of the thread because it's not helping.
- 5,137
- 4,219
- 177,663
- 90,690
Okay. We also need to get new accepted versions of the relevant calculations before we apply the statistic revisions.
Should I ping calc group members again?
@Executor_N0 @Mr. Bambu @Therefir @Ugarik @DMUA @Damage3245 @TheRustyOne @Armorchompy @Migue79 @Psychomaster35 @KLOL506 @Dark-Carioca @Aguywhodoesthings @Agnaa @Dalesean027 @DemiiPowa @Flashlight237 @SeijiSetto @SunDaGamer
Are any of you willing to help out here please?
Ghostimuscrime
He/Him- 3,678
- 3,958
CGM drought it seems
- 5,137
- 4,219
Not really, most Calc members just prefer not to touch Naruto, One Piece, Bleach, and DB.
Demon_Lord18
He/Him- 2,890
- 1,375
They would scale to the currently accepted calculations, there's no point in locking this down until someone redoes the calculations
- 34,587
- 35,020
It's not the content of the stories, I believe. It's the large fandoms and frequent arguments over them.Bleach I can understand, but why the others? Their stories mostly seem to be sympathetic and harmless.
- 52,789
- 47,113
Ant. It's the fanbases. People can be freaking rabid about things, and the HST+Dragon Ball are at the peak of that list.Bleach I can understand, but why the others? Their stories mostly seem to be sympathetic and harmless.
- 5,137
- 4,219
It has nothing to do with the stories, but rather the fanbase.Bleach I can understand, but why the others? Their stories mostly seem to be sympathetic and harmless.
Ghostimuscrime
He/Him- 3,678
- 3,958
Maybe so but I’ve scrolled the Calc Threads in the past 2 weeks and usually they have little to no CGM involvement or approval, in CRTs the way you have thread mods hopping in and aiding + evaluating things, CGMs aren’t that frequent (and Calc evals take ages)
There’s a dude with a non contentious Calc thread where everyone including 1 staff agreed but he has to keep bumping for days to weeks since no other staff looked at it and gave their second vote
I could be wrong ofc, this is solely from a limited personal observation
Yeah this is unfortunately true, M3X used to be one of the best CGMs on here but goons tried to attack his calcs and pester him so much (esp for the light fang stuff) it made him ditch Naruto entirely :/
Which is sad because he was really good with Naruto & made meaningful contributions
- 34
- 60
For the amount of times that this calculation has been recalced and this argument about whitebeard earthquakes has been made which has been for the course of over 5+ years id say honestly Just Lock the verse till the series ends because at this point all lines of scaling are either currently axed or just overall cant be used.
Similar threads
- Locked
