• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

One Piece General Discussion: Elbaph

Random thought: Why does Mihawk look like he could fit in the Castlevania verse?
Outside of his name and a bit of his style i don't much connection, his fighting style isn't very Castlevania-like (well, Soma can use huge swords so it wouldn't be a new thing if he was included, but anyway).
 
Wiki scaling doesn't mean anything for the actual story.

Pretty certain the likes of Doflamingo and Katakuri are up there with King and are NOT below the Tobi Roppo unlike what the profiles are trying to insinuate just because of people scaling off of Luffy.

Hate to say it, but if someone like Kin'emon can manage to draw blood from Kaido, I'm willing to bet so could Doflamingo, Cracker, and Katakuri (Gotta also remember the Scabbards were no match for Queen and King 20 years ago. Ashura, Inuarashi and Nekomamushi were each depicted as being equal to Jack in current day)
Thinking about this, these "problems" wouldn't be a thing if we didn't have the Yonkou scaling to WB's quakes, right? If we are talking about the previous ratings with H7A and 6C, the Yonkou would all scale >>>4,3Gts via Kaido one-shotting G4, while Doffy is really close to 6C with his strongest attacks and the Tobiroppo would probably downscale to H7A+ or just keep baseline 6C
 
Thinking about this, these "problems" wouldn't be a thing if we didn't have the Yonkou scaling to WB's quakes, right?
This may not be the place to discuss scaling, but just a question: Shouldn't Blackbeard's dura scale to Gura since he took it to the head and quickly shrugged it off? If so, shouldn't WB physicals scale since he also did almost the same thing with the Bisento?

PS.: I know this is currently "accepted" (even if not with this justificative) however, this is a personal doubt of mine.
 
This may not be the place to discuss scaling, but just a question: Shouldn't Blackbeard's dura scale to Gura since he took it to the head and quickly shrugged it off? If so, shouldn't WB physicals scale since he also did almost the same thing with the Bisento?

PS.: I know this is currently "accepted" (even if not with this justificative) however, this is a personal doubt of mine.
🤔 maybe... Maybe
 
This may not be the place to discuss scaling, but just a question: Shouldn't Blackbeard's dura scale to Gura since he took it to the head and quickly shrugged it off? If so, shouldn't WB physicals scale since he also did almost the same thing with the Bisento?

PS.: I know this is currently "accepted" (even if not with this justificative) however, this is a personal doubt of mine.
He scales close to it, no? And that Newgate was like, closer to death than he was to life.
 
He scales close to it, no? And that Newgate was like, closer to death than he was to life.
Yeah, but it goes for both ways, the same way his illness and wounds were making his physicals weaker, the same happens for his fruit (Unless a healthy WB Gura = A half dead WB Gura, but then a healthy WB physicals >>>>> Gura, which is weird). At the end of the day, Teach's dura would scale to a half dead WB lol.
 
Yall are tryna justify characters that have no feats scaling to the strongest characters in the series to axe the highest feats because your favorite characters aren't that strong?

All I see is the "YC1 level and Admiral level scaling" all over.
 
Not to mention they CURRENTLY, scale above sickbeard so you guys can’t even mention that they scale to his quakes being a problem, since he clashed with sickbeard which WB’s last key.
If Whitebeards 6-B calc gets accepted, then so would the low 6-B for sickbeard, which is where currently akainu would scale. Of course however, if a scaling crt were to be made (which I don’t think should, because m3x and damage didn’t bother to before), then akainu would be low 6-B, the other admirals and sickbeard as well, while the other yonko and old beard/prime beard scale to 6-B
 
All there is is a reluctance to scale people to the highest feats.

Originally it was an outlier since there was nothing around it.
Next it was ED when the power could be focused into a fist and slammed into another person.
Next it was trying to scale people's physicals 100x weaker than the DF even though the dude who has the power can casually backhand magma devil fruits even stronger than his own.

If yall don't want them to scale high, just say that.
Me personally, I don't miss the days when Vergo and Akainu could have an even fight and Vergo could win on this wiki.
 
All there is is a reluctance to scale people to the highest feats.

Originally it was an outlier since there was nothing around it.
Next it was ED when the power could be focused into a fist and slammed into another person.
Next it was trying to scale people's physicals 100x weaker than the DF even though the dude who has the power can casually backhand magma devil fruits even stronger than his own.

If yall don't want them to scale high, just say that.
Me personally, I don't miss the days when Vergo and Akainu could have an even fight and Vergo could win on this wiki.
Honestly it’s just ridiculous, because people certain PEOPLE who consistently lowball, give zero arguments and just say “It’s my opinion, that’s my argument” and then expect people to agree with them. I mean like we can respect it, but nobody will agree with you if you have ZERO reasoning and are just lowballing.
 
Anyways for now this is how I think it should be, supposing tempests calcs all get accepted.


Yonko, Roger, Shiki, garp, sengoku - 6-B
Blackbeard, Admirals, Marco, vista, jozu, ace - Low 6-B (from Wbs shima yurashi)
since that’s whT is accepted rn.

That’s what should be APPLIED instantly, not a single scaling crt should be made, because m3x and damage didn’t either did they?

then if wanted a scaling crt should be made scaling admirals to yonko which I already 100% agree with
 
Honestly it’s just ridiculous, because people certain PEOPLE who consistently lowball, give zero arguments and just say “It’s my opinion, that’s my argument” and then expect people to agree with them. I mean like we can respect it, but nobody will agree with you if you have ZERO reasoning and are just lowballing.
Aye aye aye hold on.

Idc about lowballing or highballing or whatever.

I care about the validity of the argument, the consistency of what you're arguing, and if it makes logical sense.

If someone comes and says 4-C Kaido, I will say "no" with no explanation whatsoever. Because logically, it makes no sense. I don't need to explain that.

But if there's consistency and you just don't like it, too bad
 
Aye aye aye hold on.

Idc about lowballing or highballing or whatever.

I care about the validity of the argument, the consistency of what you're arguing, and if it makes logical sense.

If someone comes and says 4-C Kaido, I will say "no" with no explanation whatsoever. Because logically, it makes no sense. I don't need to explain that.

But if there's consistency and you just don't like it, too bad
Literally why I said, if people give the argument of “it’s my opinion” then they shouldn’t expect anyone to give a flying ****, cause your opinion is invalid to them and isn’t an argument lol
 
Send scan
363.jpg



"The power of the "Yami Yami Fruit" is the strongest and worst of all abilities!" (I'm not really a japanese expert so the translation can be wrong).

However, as Tempest said, it 's too vague. All I can say is that we must be careful regarding some OP Statements.
 
363.jpg



"The power of the "Yami Yami Fruit" is the strongest and worst of all abilities!" (I'm not really a japanese expert so the translation can be wrong).

However, as Tempest said, it 's too vague. All I can say is that we must be careful regarding some OP Statements.
Yeah it’s way too vague.
For now, akainu and admirals scaling to the sickbeard key seems fine, since sickbeard pulled off the low 6-B feat and that is currently what is accepted. No Scaling CRT should even be required to make that, if tempests calcs are accepted.
 
363.jpg



"The power of the "Yami Yami Fruit" is the strongest and worst of all abilities!" (I'm not really a japanese expert so the translation can be wrong).

However, as Tempest said, it 's too vague. All I can say is that we must be careful regarding some OP Statements.
How many strongest devil fruits are there?
 
Yall are tryna justify characters that have no feats scaling to the strongest characters in the series to axe the highest feats because your favorite characters aren't that strong?
I mean, my top 5 scales to that pre or post wano, so at least to me that's not a thing.

My headcanon of how the ratings should be is more or less:

WB: 6C physically, up to H6C with the Gura Gura
Akainu: 6C physically, up to H6C with the Magu Magu

Not dismissing the feats as ED and thus not combat applicable, but at the same time noting that they aren't a level of damage everyone can do, but i know the above has quite a few problems so that's why it's just my headcanon.

But what did that guy say? A man's dream will never die?
 
My truecanon of how the rating should be is Pre timeskip monster trio islands lvl, Post monster trio somewhere around Country lvl, Admirals Country-continental lvl Yonko continental-moon lvl or country-moon lvl 😁 and Roger and Prime Beard Planet lvl
oNk.gif
 
Back
Top