my little pony cosmology possible upgrade

[Realabod]

So, in my little pony, it was shown that the infinite hallway is just a metaphor for choice, each door in it represents another choice you might make and another future it would create.
that would mean, every logical possibility would exist why? you would ask, why wouldn't it be many worlds interpretation.

let me explain the difference

many worlds interpretation: so, let's say if someone dies, there is 50% 50% that he dies or he doesn't so, that's going to create two worlds, one where he dies and, the other where he doesn't. the worlds are a perfect replica of each other.

but logical possibilities are different, why? let me explain.

(Possible worlds will exist if, a logical proposition is true in some other world. modal realism suggests that every possible world will exist)

logical possibilities/possible world: it's when you make a proposition this, proposition would be true in some possible world. if i say a elephant can fly, if it doesn't break the laws of thought then, it's possible and logical to happen, so in another possible world it will happen.

Modal realism: modal realism, suggests that every possible world exist

possible worlds: how do they work, let me explain.

1-they are just as real as our world


2-they differ in content, not in kind.


3-they are irreducible entities in their own right.


4-we mean only that it is our world.


5-every world is spatiotemporally isolated from every other world.


6-Possible worlds are causally isolated from each other.

now, how to connect that to my little pony so, every possible world exists why? because in my little pony each door in the infinite hallway represents another choice you might take and another future it would create that wouldn't be many worlds interpretation as many world interpretation suggest that only two worlds would be created and they will all be connected and the same no changes in laws no nothing but logical possible world can differ in many things like i explained so yeah i think that qualify for high outer+ what do y'all think

 

[TheGatememer]

This is just 2-A; 1-A and above stuff (except for Tier 0) is strictly for stuff relating to Qualitative Superiority, ie, Reality-Fiction Differences.

 

[Realabod]

This is just 2-A; 1-A and above stuff (except for Tier 0) is strictly for stuff relating to Qualitative Superiority, ie, Reality-Fiction Differences.

ong

 

[TheGatememer]

ong

The scan you just provided seems to just be your standard "every choice is another universe" multiverse shenanigans; You'd need to prove qualitative superiority, meta-qualitative superiority, meta-meta (so on and so forth) for this to even remotely be considered High 1-A+.

 

[Accelerated_Evolution]

I agree with memer, there ins´t any evidence that suggests a High 1-A+ rating

 

[BestMGQScalerEver]

literally peak

 

[Realabod]

literally peak

ong

 

[Realabod]

The scan you just provided seems to just be your standard "every choice is another universe" multiverse shenanigans; You'd need to prove qualitative superiority, meta-qualitative superiority, meta-meta (so on and so forth) for this to even remotely be considered High 1-A+.

you're not seeing one thing it's saying being on which their powers influence the space of all logical possible worlds and second
logical possible worlds contain everything as they contain every logical thing to happen and even every law as they can differ in quality that why they can be high outer you're not even using your eye lol

 

[Accelerated_Evolution]

you're not seeing one thing it's saying being on which their powers influence the space of all logical possible worlds and second
logical possible worlds contain everything as they contain every logical thing to happen and even every law as they can differ in quality that why they can be high outer you're not even using your eye lol

Nothing of what you are saying is showed on the scan itself

The image just talks about each door creating a future for each choice you could do, nothing proves that these choices extends to stuff like Qualitative Superiority and it´s a No Limits Fallacy to assume so

 

[Realabod]

Nothing of what you are saying is showed on the scan itself

The image just talks about each door creating a future for each choice you could do, nothing proves that these choices extends to stuff like Qualitative Superiority and it´s a No Limits Fallacy to assume so

hmm your red herring me I didn't argue that I argued that because every action that you might even make will have a door then every literally logical possible world will exist because every possible action will exist in a door even more the infinite hallway is just a metaphor for choice

 

[TheGatememer]

you're not seeing one thing it's saying being on which their powers influence the space of all logical possible worlds and second
logical possible worlds contain everything as they contain every logical thing to happen and even every law as they can differ in quality that why they can be high outer

You have yet to prove the Qualitative Superiority aspect, let alone the Meta-Qualitative Superiority, let alone the Meta-Meta(ad infinitum) Qualitative Superiority Aspect that is required for it to even be considered High 1-A+ in the first place. Show me a scan that the possible worlds proves that, and then you'd have a proper argument.

you're not even using your eye lol

I ask that you carefully read the pages to understand the standards, since you clearly haven't.

 

[Accelerated_Evolution]

hmm your red herring me I didn't argue that I argued that because every action that you might even make will have a door then every literally logical possible world will exist because every possible action will exist in a door even more the infinite hallway is just a metaphor for choice

And? It still doesn't prove that the choices extends to stuff like Qualitative Superiority

 

[Realabod]

And? It still doesn't prove that the choices extends to stuff like Qualitative Superiority

hmmm doesn't prove but respectfully are you genuinely stupid? like i'm sorry but are you really because logical possibilities would include literally everything so it would include even that if you read your wiki wow

 

[BestMGQScalerEver]

And? It still doesn't prove that the choices extends to stuff like Qualitative Superiority

Them extending to "QS" isn't necessary (since it just does by default if its the actual concept) but there's no basis for MR anyways lol. You kinda have to have explicit evidence that refers to a characters ability to create extending to logical possibilites (i.e. someones creative ability having no limits aside from laws of logic) or directly stating something like "all logically possible worlds".

 

[Realabod]

Them extending to "QS" isn't necessary but there's no basis for MR anyways lol. You kinda have to have explicit evidence that refers to a characters ability to create extending to logical possibilites (i.e. someones creative ability having no limits aside from laws of logic) or directly stating something like "all logically possible worlds".

hmm so like you want me to prove the existence of logic or what? because i can prove that the laws of thought exist and that all of these worlds are just a copy of the real one??? I'm genuinely asking

 

[Realabod]

Them extending to "QS" isn't necessary (since it just does by default if its the actual concept) but there's no basis for MR anyways lol. You kinda have to have explicit evidence that refers to a characters ability to create extending to logical possibilites (i.e. someones creative ability having no limits aside from laws of logic) or directly stating something like "all logically possible worlds".

hmm you know that MR exist if all possible world exist which i proved lol and possible worlds would contain all of that lol so your point is kinda bad respectfully

 

[BestMGQScalerEver]

hmm you know that MR exist if all possible world exist which i proved lol and possible worlds would contain all of that lol so your point is kinda bad respectfully

Ok but what sort of possibilities? "all possible worlds" is a vague term that doesn't mean much as there are a multitude of possibilities like metaphysical or nomological possibilities. The concept of logical possibilities being used in relation to the cosmology is a must.

Choices creating branching worlds is just some generic possibility in relation to quantum mechanics.

 

[Realabod]

Ok but what sort of possibilities? "all possible worlds" is a vague term that doesn't mean much as there are a multitude of possibilities like metaphysical or nomological possibilities. The concept of logical possibilities being used in relation to the cosmology is a must.

Choices creating branching worlds is just some generic possibility in relation to quantum mechanics.

hmm did you read my thread lol worlds getting created from choices are just two worlds buttttt like i said all possibilities will exist so that would include every set of them so yeah all the types will exist there

 

[Duedate8898]

hmmm doesn't prove but respectfully are you genuinely stupid? like i'm sorry but are you really because logical possibilities would include literally everything so it would include even that if you read your wiki wow

Hello there! Just wanted to warn you off for this comment here. Disagreeing and questioning others is a-ok, but please be a bit more mature and don't essentially call other's stupid.

You've been warned.

 

[Dark_Soul20189]

Yeah, I hard disagree with this thread.

 

[Realabod]

Yeah, I hard disagree with this thread.

why?

 

[Dark_Soul20189]

why?

For the reasons stated above, from what I see it is just 2A, nothing more nothing less.

 

[BestMGQScalerEver]

hmm did you read my thread lol worlds getting created from choices are just two worlds buttttt like i said all possibilities will exist so that would include every set of them so yeah all the types will exist there

lol

 

[JustANormalPerson01]

Disagree. Infinite doors containing infinite worlds depending of choices is just 2-A.

All logically possible worlds contain way more than just what choices the characters could've made.

 

[Realabod]

For the reasons stated above, from what I see it is just 2A, nothing more nothing less.

what reasons you know that i refuted their arguments and your just saying bc of the reasons above

 

[TheGatememer]

hmm did you read my thread lol worlds getting created from choices are just two worlds buttttt like i said all possibilities will exist so that would include every set of them so yeah all the types will exist there

Put it this way: Your argument is basically like arguing a character is Tier 0 just because the author claimed that "no one can beat him", which would "logically" include any verses with Tier 0 characters. Of course, this is illogical, since there is zero proof that said character is anywhere close to Tier 0.

Much like your argument here, where you are taking the "all possible worlds" statement, and exaggerating it so that it includes QS, despite there being no proof of that. Prove that, and you have an argument; if you don't prove that, you don't have an argument, and certainly haven't disproven anything.

 

[Realabod]

Disagree. Infinite doors containing infinite worlds depending of choices is just 2-A.

All logically possible worlds contain way more than just what choices the characters could've made.

I'm just arguing that because every possibility will exist then it would include logical possibilities in the set

 

[Mad_Dog_of_Fujiwara]

Disagree FRA.

 

[Realabod]

Put it this way: Your argument is basically like arguing a character is Tier 0 just because the author claimed that "no one can beat him", which would "logically" include any verses with Tier 0 characters. Of course, this is illogical, since there is zero proof that said character is anywhere close to Tier 0.

Much like your argument here, where you are taking the "all possible worlds" statement, and exaggerating it so that it includes QS, despite there being no proof of that. Prove that, and you have an argument; if you don't prove that, you don't have an argument, and certainly haven't disproven anything.

ok so

logical possible worlds are worlds that are logically possible within the laws of logic because we know that these doors are copies from the real world as they are other choices that might happen and other future then they would be a copy as we knew even character have personalities and all of that in these worlds so how can i prove the existence of logic discord defies the laws of logic and his realms defies it that would mean the normal world would contain logic

 

[JustANormalPerson01]

I'm just arguing that because every possibility will exist then it would include logical possibilities in the set

You've given no actual proof of that.

because in my little pony each door in the infinite hallway represents another choice you might take and another future it would create

This is literally MWI

that wouldn't be many worlds interpretation as many world interpretation suggest that only two worlds would be created and they will all be connected

Source? Because pretty sure in MWI each world is independent of each other.

and the same no changes in laws no nothing but logical possible world can differ in many things like i explained so yeah i think that qualify for high outer+ what do y'all think

This scan does not prove that all logically possible worlds exist. It only says that each door contains one possible future, i.e., MWI.

 

[Oblivion_Of_The_Endless]

"Every possibility exists" would just be defaulted to the generic kind of possibilities (since there are different types of possibilities, such as metaphysical, nomological, temporal, etc). Without evidence that it's specifically referring to logical possibility it would be just assumed to be "all generic possibilities exist" and thus be only 2-A in this case.

 

[GodSinBad2280]

Oh, I disagree with this.

 

[VoidGoji]

Disagree. Its just 2-A; every choice generates a new timeline where it wasn't made/an opposite choice was made, ad infinitum. Its literally the most basic thing when people talk about multiverses in fiction. There is no "this means it goes infinitely into higher dimensions and transcends every single definition of space-time in a way that its nothing but fiction compared to this"

 

[Lord_Farquaad69420]

Your mistaking MWI for Modal realism

 

[Laviossiii]

Disagree.

 

[Gasper]

At this point make every character on the wiki 1-A.

 

[BoastJr]

Allat just for Goku to solo. Tisk Tisk.

 

[Railgun]

Looks like 2-A to me. Disagree

 

[Iamunanimousinthat]

Isn't this supposed to be locked till the staff reviews it?

 

[BestMGQScalerEver]

Isn't this supposed to be locked till the staff reviews it?

that'd just be a waste of a queue spot