-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
My Hero Academia Revisions
- Thread starter Therefir
- Start date
- 8,180
- 1,377
Of course Izuku & Lida could do that cause they r the H2H combat fighters. Your telling me that Uraraka has the AP to be able to BREAK DOWN A BUILDING lol yeah no her quirk can be able to do that but in her base no unless yur telling me she's comparable to 5% Deku & above. The only thing I could say is that yup they should have the durability but the AP is suspicious at the highest peak unless I see low tiers being able to destroy building & such
So stop w/ this AoE Fallacy u keep mentioning, I can understand why u meant that from my post b4 but now u keep trying 2 repeat the process. I should had finished my sentence but I should had said that I love this show just as much as all of u even I know some of these characters shouldn't be at a certain tier unless if it has something to do w/ their quirks
So stop w/ this AoE Fallacy u keep mentioning, I can understand why u meant that from my post b4 but now u keep trying 2 repeat the process. I should had finished my sentence but I should had said that I love this show just as much as all of u even I know some of these characters shouldn't be at a certain tier unless if it has something to do w/ their quirks
- 11,444
- 1,997
@TataHakai
Heck, the intro to the second season of the anime has Deku illuminating half the planet with a single punch so...
Not suggesting this as significant evidence, but it's there.
Heck, the intro to the second season of the anime has Deku illuminating half the planet with a single punch so...
Not suggesting this as significant evidence, but it's there.
- 11,444
- 1,997
@BlackeJan
Again, AP =/= AoE, which you don't seem to understand. Characters who have a certain level of AP don't always bust stuff that their AP would otherwise show.
If we needed a direct destruction feat for every character rating then power-scaling would be virtually impossible. We'd end up with things like Tier 9 Cell beating Goku or Tier 8 Kingdom Hearts when Keyblade Wielders are explicitly stated to be able to bring salvation or ruin to entire worlds and have wielded powers that can move hundreds of worlds at the bare minimum.
Mega Ma doesn't regularly bust planets. Heck, MegaMan.EXE doesn't regularly bust universes. Their powers are where they are because of their feats and regular scaling.
It makes little sense for a character who can survive a point blank explosion and keep going or even get caught in explosion as a gag without even activating his Quirk to be harmed by a 9-B character.
Again, AP =/= AoE, which you don't seem to understand. Characters who have a certain level of AP don't always bust stuff that their AP would otherwise show.
If we needed a direct destruction feat for every character rating then power-scaling would be virtually impossible. We'd end up with things like Tier 9 Cell beating Goku or Tier 8 Kingdom Hearts when Keyblade Wielders are explicitly stated to be able to bring salvation or ruin to entire worlds and have wielded powers that can move hundreds of worlds at the bare minimum.
Mega Ma doesn't regularly bust planets. Heck, MegaMan.EXE doesn't regularly bust universes. Their powers are where they are because of their feats and regular scaling.
It makes little sense for a character who can survive a point blank explosion and keep going or even get caught in explosion as a gag without even activating his Quirk to be harmed by a 9-B character.
- 31,304
- 27,536
The OP mentions that Mei is even weaker than Aoyama.
Is there anything to back this up?
Is there anything to back this up?
- 8,180
- 1,377
Lol that's not a false equivalence cause I'm proving a point here. Both scene was made to be comedey what just b/c one has an explosion while the other is Bulma slapping Goku? Bulma ain't 3-A cause I'm a SERIOUS FIGHTING SCENE Bulma would lose & they same thing is applied for Mei, if it was a serious scene then she would be injuredJs250476 said:
- 10,758
- 6,491
Whis telling Beerus that it would take around 20-30 minutes to reach Earth was meant as a comedy scene. I guess that also isnt a legit speed feat.
- 10,758
- 6,491
Sigh...okay I will take this seriously now. BlackJan apart from the scene being meant as comedy do you have any other arguments against the feat?
- 31,304
- 27,536
We also don't see Mei taking the brunt of the explosion. We don't know if she was really in the middle of it or only caught a bit of it.
- 10,758
- 6,491
A feat being meant for comedy is not good justification in itself to disregard it. Mei being able to tank a 9-A explosion is consistent with the series and we have no actual reasons to ignore it.
- 6,108
- 963
This is a terrible comparison. You're comparing a massive PIS outlier to a durability feat with mild comedy.BlackeJan said:
- 8,180
- 1,377
Lol that's not a false equivalence cause I'm proving a point here. Both scene was made to be comedey what just b/c one has an explosion while the other is Bulma slapping Goku? Bulma ain't 3-A cause I'm a SERIOUS FIGHTING SCENE Bulma would lose & they same thing is applied for Mei, if it was a serious scene then she would be injured
This is a terrible comparison. You're comparing a massive PIS outlier to a durability feat with mild comedy.
It is a good comparison cause it's both meant for A COMEDY SCENE
This is a terrible comparison. You're comparing a massive PIS outlier to a durability feat with mild comedy.
It is a good comparison cause it's both meant for A COMEDY SCENE
- 10,758
- 6,491
BlackeJan Bring me one example of a feat meant for comedy being rejected which isn't also an outlier or inconsistency.
- 6,108
- 963
Blacke please, just stop. This is honestly getting tiresome. You are using AOE Fallacy, and Disbelief as your arguments. And you;'ve also done this on the AGK revison thread too. Those are the same fallacies/arguments that all the crappy low-tier debaters on Spacebattles.com uses. Do you not realize that those are insanely weak arguments to use?
The Beerus scene was an outlier. Serious or not.
Comedy or not, Mei taking the blast was a legit feat, it doesn't matter if it is comedy.
Let me tell you the difference between a comedy feat and a gag feat.
Spongebob sucking up the entire Ocean. that is a "comedy feat" But it was not accepted because it is a massive outlier.
^Comedy feat, legit, but an outlier^
Popeye the Sailor Man destroys the film reels he is in. That could be interpreted as Low 2-C, yet it is clearly a gag feat. Because it's in a show that is a consistent gag.
The Beerus scene was an outlier. Serious or not.
Comedy or not, Mei taking the blast was a legit feat, it doesn't matter if it is comedy.
Let me tell you the difference between a comedy feat and a gag feat.
Spongebob sucking up the entire Ocean. that is a "comedy feat" But it was not accepted because it is a massive outlier.
^Comedy feat, legit, but an outlier^
Popeye the Sailor Man destroys the film reels he is in. That could be interpreted as Low 2-C, yet it is clearly a gag feat. Because it's in a show that is a consistent gag.
- 10,758
- 6,491
@Versusjunkie I know you sometimes have to be harsh in these threads but that kinda felt a little too aggressive.
- 6,108
- 963
I do have a tendency to be harsh. But my intention was not to insult or be agressive or anything.Andytrenom said:
- 8,180
- 1,377
No it seems u can't handle the truth! I even debunked u on the AGK revision as well. STOP BRINGING UP THINGS THAT R OUTLIERS!! my goodness it is not that hard! Mei tanking that blast was LITERALLY A COMEDY SCENE! It's not meant to be TAKEN SERIOUSLY like this is tiresome of me debunking u in almost everything that u bring up. We don't even know how Mei durability is in a serious scene so why use something meant for comedy (again not to be taken seriously at all) for something that of course she is going to tank? (it was literally set up for her to land on Deku)
Yur comparing a cartoon to anime. Spongebob is a cartoon for kids so pump course he is going to do something like that ITS A COMEDY SHOW. Boku no Hero has a few comedy but 97% of it is SERIOUS
Yur comparing a cartoon to anime. Spongebob is a cartoon for kids so pump course he is going to do something like that ITS A COMEDY SHOW. Boku no Hero has a few comedy but 97% of it is SERIOUS
- 11,444
- 1,997
@Blacke
First, write coherently. You aren't texting.
Second, don't quote blocks of text.
Third, by your logic it'd be impossible to quantify the feats of any gag comedy series. Bugs Bunny and Mickey Mouse would not have profiles.
If it happens in the story it happens in the story. It doesn't matter if it's a gag or not. Unless it's an outlier (which it isn't given the scope of the series), it's still something to be used and analyzed.
First, write coherently. You aren't texting.
Second, don't quote blocks of text.
Third, by your logic it'd be impossible to quantify the feats of any gag comedy series. Bugs Bunny and Mickey Mouse would not have profiles.
If it happens in the story it happens in the story. It doesn't matter if it's a gag or not. Unless it's an outlier (which it isn't given the scope of the series), it's still something to be used and analyzed.
- 6,108
- 963
This isn't Looney Toons, or Popeye the Sailor Man. There is a clearly defined difference between a gag, and comedy feat. In any case, this is consistent with other durability feats in the series.
- 8,180
- 1,377
For the last time....stop using this as some gag feat! Boku no Hero is not a gag anime. Though I guess I can see what y'all r saying (somewhat) cause yes this was a comedy scene for Mei, for all we know in something serious she could had actually died in that explosion (using the Mei scene for an example).
@Versus U were also somewhat correct in the AGK revision
@Versus U were also somewhat correct in the AGK revision
- 8,180
- 1,377
Also we don't even know if Mei was close to that explosion she could had been farther away from it
Ex: I remember when I was near an explosion (no one died thank goodness) but I was far away from it. The moment it exploded (I saw it) the explosion was small but then I was thrown away cause of the air blast yet not a single of the explosion flame touched me
Ex: I remember when I was near an explosion (no one died thank goodness) but I was far away from it. The moment it exploded (I saw it) the explosion was small but then I was thrown away cause of the air blast yet not a single of the explosion flame touched me
- 8,180
- 1,377
@ReppuzanBlackeJan said:
No yur comparing a H2H combat fighter to a support type character who just sits in the back & help out. Deku is FAR stronger then Mei & not only that he trained his body as well so of course he would (luckily) be able to come out of w/ a broken arm. If it was Mei she would had died
EDIT: why did this quote my own message when I meant to Merge it w/ my post above?
