• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Minor upgrades and additions

Status
Not open for further replies.
That doesn't mean he is using ink to do so.
He's just stretching his body.
His body was not stretching; it was LITERALLY growing in volume. His hands became bigger and his horns too. He was gaining mass (Ink) to become bigger, stronger and faster. That's baisc logic. If something is growing bigger, then its mass is expanding, increasing in volume. A normal tall man has more flesh to offer than a normal smaller man. A bigger ink creature has more Ink than a smaller ink creature. Simple to understand, no?

Also him consuming Audrey was probably due to more of ego thing
"Was probably" does not apply. We are dealing with what we have, not what you think it was. And what we have is this: The ink demon literally devours Audrey and then becomes taller and stronger right in the next scene. Done, no further explanations.
Him being "too storng" means nothing he was literally described to be strong prior
"And all the ink around me too."

Since you did not understand, let me point it more specifically to you this time. The Key thing is him saying the Ink too; It wasn't just Bendy; the ink was ALSO pulling him and following Bendy's will since, well, it was Bendy after all who was controlling the Ink to his will since now he had it to do so.
 
"And all the ink around me too."
The ink being around buddy means absolutely nothing. Also the ink around buddy was because buddy dropped bendy into ink and bendy was dragging him also nothing implies he was controlling that ink.
"Was probably" does not apply. We are dealing with what we have, not what you think it was. And what we have is this: The ink demon literally devours Audrey and then becomes taller and stronger right in the next scene. Done, no further explanations
Didn't you literally just argue he can increase his mass himself why would he need Audrey bendy also we see him consuming other ink creatures and he doesn't get bigger.
If you want to use "what we have" he just grew on his own.
His body was not stretching; it was LITERALLY growing in volume. His hands became bigger and his horns too. He was gaining mass (Ink) to become bigger, stronger and faster. That's baisc logic. If something is growing bigger, then its mass is expanding, increasing in volume. A normal tall man has more flesh to offer than a normal smaller man. A bigger ink creature has more Ink than a smaller ink creature. Simple to understand, no?
"His arms and legs lengthening,his head spreading,his teeth getting sharper" its literally stretching
 
The ink being around buddy means absolutely nothing. Also the ink around buddy was because buddy dropped bendy into ink and bendy was dragging him also nothing implies he was controlling that ink.
It was before Buddy dropped into the ink but i agree, Bendy controlling the ink to pull Buddy just doesn't make sense cuz Bendy was incarnated by all the ink inside the trapdoor. So, most likely it means that the demon was hauling him when he was on a slippery, inky floor, making him think the ink is like pulling. Anyway, everything in that novel is under the delivery boy perspective so it can be somewhat vague and hard to properly understand.
Didn't you literally just argue he can increase his mass himself why would he need Audrey bendy also we see him consuming other ink creatures and he doesn't get bigger.
If you want to use "what we have" he just grew on his own.
Damn strong point here dude, Bendy having consumed millions of ink creatures but only Audrey strengthened him despite the thing that he grows stronger by the ink is absolutely contradicted to the previous assmuption and accidentally put an end to the misconception of "absorptive transformation", similar to the believe of "Bendy will die if he runs out of ink".
"His arms and legs lengthening,his head spreading,his teeth getting sharper" its literally stretching
Stretching and increasing in mass can be the same. Like your body is stretching during the grow up progress also means it is gaining more masses.
 
Last edited:
It was before Buddy dropped into the ink but i agree, Bendy controlling the ink to pull Buddy just doesn't make sense cuz Bendy was incarnated by all the ink inside the trapdoor. So, most likely it means that the demon was hauling him when he was on a slippery, inky floor, making him think the ink is like pulling. Anyway, everything in that novel is under the delivery boy perspective so it can be somewhat vague and hard to properly understand.
Haven't read the book in a bit so I may have messed up on that.
Stretching and increasing in mass can be the same. Like your body is stretching during the grow up progress also means it is increasing in mass. These both are also the primitive working principle of size shifting tho
Fair point but my main problem was the idea that bendy was adding ink into his body to make himself bigger. Which I doubt he was he the way the book made it seem is like he just pulled his body into a more exaggerated form of what he was originally. As arguing he added ink to his body seems disingenuous
 
Fair point but my main problem was the idea that bendy was adding ink into his body to make himself bigger. Which I doubt he was he the way the book made it seem is like he just pulled his body into a more exaggerated form of what he was originally. As arguing he added ink to his body seems disingenuous
I like to think he does that like Inque, shapeshift by possesing an uncertain amount of masses and can change it at will no matter what. Regardless, your point above just screwed the entire of that assumption.
The absorption thing mostly comes from how Buddy described the way Bendy regenerates, but probably, Bendy absorped ink to do that just because he was not so good at regenerating that time or he created an aura while utilizing regeneration looks like he taking masses from the subtance.
 
Last edited:
Another possibility is Bendy almost lost his ink-generating ability once he was dissolving by the ink that time so he had to absorp them to reform himself.
 
Last edited:
The ink being around buddy means absolutely nothing. Also the ink around buddy was because buddy dropped bendy into ink and bendy was dragging him also nothing implies he was controlling that ink.
How tf does this not mean absolutely nothing? It's explicity SAID that the Ink was obeying Bendy's commands. The absolute part of the book I mentioned is telling with all the letters that the Ink was pulling Buddy with Bendy as well. Are you kidding me? How it's not Bendy controlling it when there's COUNTLESS of scans showing Bendy controling the Ink both in games and books? Seriously, what are you trying to prove with this? Because just saying "It doesn't mean anything" won't help you. Show me how this DOES NOT prove anything. Where are your scans showing otherwise?
Didn't you literally just argue he can increase his mass himself why would he need Audrey bendy also we see him consuming other ink creatures and he doesn't get bigger.
If you want to use "what we have" he just grew on his own.
Because Audrey is special and she has powers Henry doesn't. You can also see that the Beast Bendy from Dark revival is a complete evolution compared to the one we see in BATIM. And this is confirmed by Meatly himself in the Bendy archives where he mentions that the Ink demon himself is an evolution compared to the one in BATIM. In the game itself he mentions why he needs Audrey. So yes, he can use both his own mass to grow in volume or eat other Ink creatures to gain more mass since it's Ink. Basic logic, again.

"His arms and legs lengthening,his head spreading,his teeth getting sharper" its literally stretching
This is from the Books. I'm talking about BATIM's ending where bendy literally just expand his hands and horns to become bigger in mass. He grows in size and gains more Ink out of his own.
 
It was before Buddy dropped into the ink but i agree, Bendy controlling the ink to pull Buddy just doesn't make sense cuz Bendy was incarnated by all the ink inside the trapdoor. So, most likely it means that the demon was hauling him when he was on a slippery, inky floor, making him think the ink is like pulling. Anyway, everything in that novel is under the delivery boy perspective so it can be somewhat vague and hard to properly understand.
Guys, Bendy literally controls Ink. He did this before and he does this in the games where he uses it to cover places; flood and even corrupt other ink creatures such as the Butcher Gang members. Why wouldn't he do it to pull Buddy into the pit? Actually, it's even STATED that the Ink was dragging him as if it had proper strenght. And of course it had, because it was being used by the Ink demon so he could drag Buddy to the pit.
 
Damn strong point here dude, Bendy having consumed millions of ink creatures but only Audrey strengthened him despite the thing that he grows stronger by the ink is absolutely contradicted to the previous assmuption and accidentally put an end to the misconception of "absorptive transformation", similar to the believe of "Bendy will die if he runs out of ink".
Audrey is not a common Ink creature as the game proves many, many times. She literally has the same powers as him since it's mentioned that Audrey has a link with the Dark puddles, since she was born from there, just like bendy himself. This is the sole reason why the Ink demon hunts her the entire game and even tries to make her mind so she would give up and give him her being so they could fuse and become a stronger being. So no, this point does not make sense. Bendy consuming Audrey and she being the only one capable of buffing him for good is actually the sole reason why he hunts her, simply because out of everyone in the Cycle, she is special.
 
How tf does this not mean absolutely nothing? It's explicity SAID that the Ink was obeying Bendy's commands. The absolute part of the book I mentioned is telling with all the letters that the Ink was pulling Buddy with Bendy as well. Are you kidding me? How it's not Bendy controlling it when there's COUNTLESS of scans showing Bendy controling the Ink both in games and books?
The only thing you sent to prove bendy was using the ink in said paragraph was "ink around me to" that doesn't prove anything.
Because the context is this
"I took a deep breath I was scaring myself again it was time to leave. It was time to finally confront mister drew. A hand burst out and grabbed my leg "buddy!" It happened so fast I don't actually know how. I just know I was suddenly through a trapdoor, neck deep in thick ink" tell me throughout any of that did it state he was controlling said ink.
Audrey is not a common Ink creature as the game proves many, many times. She literally has the same powers as him since it's mentioned that Audrey has a link with the Dark puddles, since she was born from there, just like bendy himself. This is the sole reason why the Ink demon hunts her the entire game and even tries to make her mind so she would give up and give him her being so they could fuse and become a stronger being. So no, this point does not make sense. Bendy consuming Audrey and she being the only one capable of buffing him for good is actually the sole reason why he hunts her, simply because out of everyone in the Cycle, she is special.
He did the same to Henry. He hunted him nonstop.
Also a lot of ink creatures are born from the ink originally like Allison,Tom and Henry
 
Guys, Bendy literally controls Ink. He did this before and he does this in the games where he uses it to cover places; flood and even corrupt other ink creatures such as the Butcher Gang members.
Cool. in what way does that imply the infinite power statement was referring to that?
 
The only thing you sent to prove bendy was using the ink in said paragraph was "ink around me to" that doesn't prove anything.
Because the context is this
"I took a deep breath I was scaring myself again it was time to leave. It was time to finally confront mister drew. A hand burst out and grabbed my leg "buddy!" It happened so fast I don't actually know how. I just know I was suddenly through a trapdoor, neck deep in thick ink" tell me throughout any of that did it state he was controlling said ink.
Bendy can literally manipulate Ink to come out of walls/ disappear whenever he feels like and you're here telling me that he was not controlling the lnk? It's like saying a creature with air manipulation can't control air... it's just.. nonsense? Seriously, it's not that hard. Buddy says "The ink around me too, was stronger" as if it was sucking him in the pit along with the Ink demon. HE IS saying the Ink was making action against his will the moment Bendy grabbed his leg. Want another proof of it? In the same book, there's a part where Buddy and Dot are trying not to get in contact with the Ink coming from Bendy, because it is moving and trying to locate them. This part is in the 90th page. So yes, Bendy controls ink... wow.. what a surprise, isn't it?
He did the same to Henry. He hunted him nonstop.
The difference is that Henry is not linked to the Dark Puddles and is totally absent in powers. It's more than obvious that Audrey is FAR, FAR more special than Henry and that she has more power than him, being the reason why she can absorb, banish and teleport. Even Wilson calls this "Devilish powers of yours" when he is confronting her before we fight Shipahoy. You cannot compare Henry to Audrey. It's just ridiculous.

Also a lot of ink creatures are born from the ink originally like Allison,Tom and Henry
But they are not human. Audrey isn't just an Ink creature born from Ink; she's a HUMAN that was created out of INK by Joey. He even calls her "My perfect creation". The Ink demon had EVERY reason to hunt her and try to make her accept his bargain so they could fuse and become stronger, which is what happened though.
 
Cool. in what way does that imply the infinite power statement was referring to that?
Maybe because the fact that he controls Ink is the fact he can get stronger the more Ink he has? And because of that, due to him being a walking Ink fabric, that literally means his power is infinite since he will never cease to have Ink at his disposal to, y'know, use his powers, which are based on Ink manipulation?

Not calling you dumb or anything.. but this is a rather basic logic to understand y'know?
 
Bendy can literally manipulate Ink to come out of walls/ disappear whenever he feels like and you're here telling me that he was not controlling the lnk? It's like saying a creature with air manipulation can't control air... it's just.. nonsense? Seriously, it's not that hard. Buddy says "The ink around me too, was stronger" as if it was sucking him in the pit along with the Ink demon. HE IS saying the Ink was making action against his will the moment Bendy grabbed his leg. Want another proof of it? In the same book, there's a part where Buddy and Dot are trying not to get in contact with the Ink coming from Bendy, because it is moving and trying to locate them. This part is in the 90th page. So yes, Bendy controls ink... wow.. what a surprise, isn't it?
Do you actually own the book or are you using the file version of it because what you are talking about was never said in the actual book (which I own physically) and page 90 never said that nor did anything in the book say that.
 
Maybe because the fact that he controls Ink is the fact he can get stronger the more Ink he has? And because of that, due to him being a walking Ink fabric, that literally means his power is infinite since he will never cease to have Ink at his disposal to, y'know, use his powers, which are based on Ink manipulation?

Not calling you dumb or anything.. but this is a rather basic logic to understand y'know?
Yeah um.
The ink he's controlling is a finite amount so it wouldn't make sense for it to be considered infinite power
 
Bendy can literally manipulate Ink to come out of walls/ disappear whenever he feels like and you're here telling me that he was not controlling the lnk? It's like saying a creature wit
The difference is that Henry is not linked to the Dark Puddles and is totally absent in powers. It's more than obvious that Audrey is FAR, FAR more special than Henry and that she has more power than him, being the reason why she can absorb, banish and teleport. Even Wilson calls this "Devilish powers of yours" when he is confronting her before we fight Shipahoy. You cannot compare Henry to Audrey. It's just ridiculous.
Literally everyone is connected to the ink saying Henry isn't is just dishonest.
Also flow and fast travel weren't even her abilities originally. also The archives confirm even Sammy has flow
 
Do you actually own the book or are you using the file version of it because what you are talking about was never said in the actual book (which I own physically) and page 90 never said that nor did anything in the book say that.
I have the file downloaded. But yes, in the file is said "page 90". I don't know if it's different for you, but it is the part before they find the violinist.

Yeah um.
The ink he's controlling is a finite amount so it wouldn't make sense for it to be considered infinite power
I'm not saying that specific Ink was infinite. What I'm saying is that Bendy is a literal walking ink fabric; he literally produces Ink just by existing. Because of that, he will ALWAYS have ink at his disposal to use his powers and hax. He will never run out of Ink because his whole being makes Ink out of nothing as we see when he is near, where Ink starts to manifest in the walls and floor. The thing is: Bendy controls Ink, and he produces Ink infinitely. But he can also control Ink from other sources, such as Ink from puddles or Ink from barrels. He controls and produces Ink, that's why the "Infinite power" means that the source of his power will never cease to exist, because he himself makes it.
Literally everyone is connected to the ink saying Henry isn't is just dishonest.
Also flow and fast travel weren't even her abilities originally. also The archives confirm even Sammy has flow
When I said Henry is not connected I meant that Henry can't interact with it or don't have the same affinity as Audrey. The Dark Puddles literally gave her the power of banishment, which ONLY Audrey has as far as we know. And if you recall, this ability literally banish Ink creatures' souls back to the Dark puddles, so she can literally control who, and who may not be inside of it. The point is: Audrey is clearly more special compared to everyone in the Cycle and that's a fact, because even Joey confirms this at the end where he calls her "My perfect creation"
 
In the summary of BatDS, Bendy is stated to be capable of stalking us for eternity, by the line You’re not alone! The monstrous Ink Demon stalks you at every turn. I think this is most likely hyperbole but eh, at least, it is still worth to be mentioned as a supportive statement.
This doesn't say anything about eternity.

Allison implied him to be a sadistic creature that does nothing but endlessly hunts and kills all beings.
You can do this without infinite stamina.

Judging by BatIM Chapter 3, he was just stalking Henry at every corner and the whole BatDS is just a no-end loop of being chased by Bendy. He is also constantly seen to be hunting, moving between places, and fight other ink creatures.
This doesn't really directly imply infinite, either.

Audrey has a stamina bar that will drain whenever she runs. But when fused with Bendy, the bar is just...not there anymore, heavily pointing out that Bendy's stamina is not something we can measure by any ways.
All this implies is that his stamina is sufficient to not be relevant to the scenes in which he is used. I don't know what Audrey's stamina is but at the end of the day, all this would really imply is that Bendy is greater than her in that regard (assuming we take the lack of game mechanic UI as evidence, which I do but recognize that it is tenuous).
 
oh yeah and

For Additions, Bendy may have 4th Wall Breaking and Awareness as in BSotM, when you left the game pausing for about several minutes, he will instantly reactivate your game and jumpscare you on the screen, meaning he must aware of the game being suspended and have some right to interfere itself.
Honestly, this reads more like Bendy isn't aware of it. It's just a cute way of the game saying 'no pauses', wherein the game character doesn't give a **** about it. Funny, but not really an ability.
 
This doesn't say anything about eternity.
The phrase "stalks at every turn" comes from the belief "death stalks at every turn", meaning the death tracks you non-stop until you eventually die. In fact, this supports for my previous point, as the Cycle is an endless loop in which you can't actually die and the Ink Demon stalks you constantly no matter what or where so basically, he stalks you for eternity.
 
Honestly, this reads more like Bendy isn't aware of it. It's just a cute way of the game saying 'no pauses', wherein the game character doesn't give a **** about it. Funny, but not really an ability.
Ah so, how Bill Cipher changed the authors name in Gravity Fall's intro is just how the show saying "this is weirdmageddon and i do this plotwise".
Characters don't only demonstate their 4th Wall cognition by dialogues or letter boards, ya know. It can be implied anyway.
 
Ah so, how Bill Cipher changed the authors name in Gravity Fall's intro is just how the show saying "this is weirdmageddon and i do this plotwise".
Characters don't only demonstate their 4th Wall cognition by dialogues or letter boards, ya know. It can be implied anyway.
...what? This isn't Gravity Falls lol
 
Ah so, how Bill Cipher changed the authors name in Gravity Fall's intro is just how the show saying "this is weirdmageddon and i do this plotwise".
Characters don't only demonstate their 4th Wall cognition by dialogues or letter boards, ya know. It can be implied anyway.
I don´t really know about Bendy, but Bill changing the opening is something directly acknowledge as canon + He has other 4th Wall Breaking feats (Such as directly talking to the viewer and even creating a Reddit account)
 
I don't understand what you're trying to say
 
I don´t really know about Bendy, but Bill changing the opening is something directly acknowledge as canon + He has other 4th Wall Breaking feats (Such as directly talking to the viewer and even creating a Reddit account)
I know, i just wanna say that characters don't only show their 4th Wall awareness through visual or aural manners but also can be hinted by actions (eg: looking at the camera,...)
 
Last edited:
I don't understand what you're trying to say
Look, no character really meant to possess 4th Wall awareness, they're all owing to the details or their developments in the plot. You saying Bendy doesn't really have this ability because it's actually the game operates those stuffs just sounds weird.
Like, saying Bendy's enhanced hearing is a game mechanic cuz developers programmed his AI to track broken cutouts.
 
Look, no character really meant to possess 4th Wall awareness, they're all owing to the details or their developments in the plot. You saying Bendy doesn't really have this ability because it's actually the game operates those stuffs just sounds weird.
Like, saying Bendy's enhanced hearing is a game mechanic cuz developers programmed his AI to track broken cutouts.
No, actually a lot of characters are indeed meant to break the 4th wall. Bendy just interrupts a pause menu.
 
No, actually a lot of characters are indeed meant to break the 4th wall. Bendy just interrupts a pause menu.
And interrupting a pause menu, or more specifically interfering the game system, requires you to have a consciousness of the fictionality of the virtual world you reside. Before you saying it is a game mechanic again, the anti-pausing jumpscare is the mechanic that only Bendy has so it can be counted canon.
To know a characters ability is a game mechanic or not, just consider if the feature above is applied to all/most characters (HP, stats, levels...) or whether it is relevant to the plot (unbreakable trees in GTA, creative mode in MC...)
 
And interrupting a pause menu, or more specifically interfering the game system, requires you to have a consciousness of the fictionality of the virtual world you reside. Before you saying it is a game mechanic again, the anti-pausing jumpscare is the mechanic that only Bendy has so it can be counted canon.
To know a characters ability is a game mechanic or not, just consider if the feature above is applied to all/most characters (HP, stats, levels...) or whether it is relevant to the plot (unbreakable trees in GTA, creative mode in MC...)
No it doesn't. The menu doesn't exist in that world. All this means is that on a meta level, the pause menu isn't truly a pause. If Bendy appeared and clicked the unpause button, he would be interacting with it, that would be something. Here, he very specifically doesn't interact with it, at all.
 
Last edited:
No it doesn't. The menu doesn't exist in that world. All this means is that on a meta level, the pauseenu isn't truly a pause. If Bendy appeared and clicked the unpause button, he would be interacting with it, that would be something. Here, he very specifically doesn't interact with it, at all.
For you saying pause menu isn't truly a pause, it can still function as one if you delete Bendy from the game.
His interaction with it may not be visible enough for us to perceive cuz reactivating the game is not something you need to access the database to operate.
 
Last edited:
This is fine. as Bendy is no longer jump-scaring Railey (the protagonist). Bendy is jump-scaring the player through the pause menu, forcing them restart the game if they are away from keyboard longer than 20 minutes. Bendy is basically telling the player “you cannot be away from keyboard longer than 20 minutes”. I will be making a thread touching more on this and more interesting feat I have found and see what Vs Battle community thinks of it. As this one for some reason doesn't seem to be getting notice that much. If it’s accepted it’s accepted, if it’s debunked it’s debunked, it is what it is.

Now one might try and argue that other horror game antagonist(s) like Five Nights at Freddy’s or Poppy Playtime also Jump scare the player but that’s not true. They don’t intentionally jump scare the player spastically they intentionally jump scare the protagonist spastically. The player is just seeing the jump scare through the protagonist point of view which makes it look like the antagonist(s) are jump scaring the player. But this isn’t the case with Bendy.

Also if you pause the game while being chased by the taxi it does pause the game and the taxi cannot kill you until you resume the game. So as of right now no characters in the game can prevent the player from pausing besides Bendy.
 
Last edited:
Điều này ổn. vì Bendy không còn hù dọa Railey (nhân vật chính) nữa. Bendy đang hù dọa người chơi thông qua menu tạm dừng, buộc họ phải khởi động lại trò chơi nếu họ rời khỏi bàn phím quá 20 phút. Về cơ bản, Bendy đang nói với người chơi rằng "bạn không thể rời khỏi bàn phím quá 20 phút". Tôi sẽ tạo một chủ đề đề cập nhiều hơn về điều này và chiến công thú vị hơn mà tôi đã tìm thấy và xem cộng đồng Vs Battle nghĩ gì về nó. Vì lý do nào đó, điều này có vẻ không được chú ý nhiều. Nếu được chấp nhận thì được chấp nhận, nếu bị vạch trần thì bị vạch trần, nó là như vậy.

Now one might try and argue that other horror game antagonist(s) like Five Nights at Freddy’s or Poppy Playtime also Jump scare the player but that’s not true. They don’t intentionally jump scare the player spastically they intentionally jump scare the protagonist spastically. The player is just seeing the jump scare through the protagonist point of view which makes it look like the antagonist(s) are jump scaring the player. But this isn’t the case with Bendy.

Also if you pause the game while being chased by the taxi it does pause the game and the taxi cannot kill you until you resume the game. So as of right now no characters in the game can prevent the player from pausing besides Bendy.
Thanks a lot Inky for your approval. Now, i've just figured out something more interesting. If even a character with great 4th Wall Awareness like Sans or Kenny (HoL) couldn't break through the game UI but not Bendy, doesn't it mean he must have something more than just the consciousness of the 4th Wall?
Law Manipulation probably?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top