- 20,509
- 1,590
- Thread starter
- #281
What? Me? What do you mean? I don't get it.Antvasima said:
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Medaka content revision.
- Thread starter Firephoenixearl
- Start date
- Status
- 20,509
- 1,590
- Thread starter
- #283
I listed the numbers that were agreed by most ppl. The numbers correspond to the numbers of the topic.Antvasima said:
- 20,509
- 1,590
- Thread starter
- #285
Ok will keep in mind for next time. Now time for ppl to settle on the OP points.Antvasima said:
- 167,683
- 76,264
Sigh. I have tried to alude to that this thread is very long, and it is much easier to reach a conclusion if we make the structure easier to follow by summarising all of the consensus so far for the different points. But if you are not able to help in this regard, perhaps somebody else can do so.
- 20,509
- 1,590
- Thread starter
- #287
Well not a lot of progress has been made so far but ok i will do a recap on every point that has been reached to a conclusion. I mean most of this has been "this is wanked" and "all fiction can do that" so out of topic discussions. Which i would urge everyone to not engage in them anymore.Antvasima said:
- 20,509
- 1,590
- Thread starter
- #288
So the all in all progress made is (the numbers correspond to the numbers of the OP topics):
1) It hasn't been argued or disproved but since there is proof, I don't see why anyone would disagree. (it has a feat)
1.1) Also concluded. The profile info wasn't wrong, nor is this much different, just to say that Bookmaker gets ppl on the level of a minus, since saying "kumagawa" can be confusing.
2) Agreed by everyone. In different ways, but everyone agrees.
3) Agreed for the most part, though not rly talked about. Still "infinite" should be added either way due to all fiction (even without counting ajimu's abilities).
4) 100% Agreed
5) Ppl agreed to have the link added even though it would be useless. So i say add (and a note on abilities being banned unless they are clear on definition like "instant movement skill")
6) As you said, while it is risky to give "all free" power creation (it's too broken). I think we keep it on the powers hanten has been shown to be able to use along with Devil style.
7) It's still in discussion on whether it should be added.
8) This is basically treated as fact by now. So it should be changed ASAP.
9) In discussion. So let's wait on this to get argued a bit more before saying anything else.
10) This is just true, no matter how much it's low balled, authority still is authority, same for divinity. The abilities can't be used but the fact that Medaka copied them means that it's not limited to "authority" or "divinity".
11) This is also true in 2 ways. 1 is she fought Zenkichi and the 2nd via Power Creation.
So did i do a good job on the recap?
1) It hasn't been argued or disproved but since there is proof, I don't see why anyone would disagree. (it has a feat)
1.1) Also concluded. The profile info wasn't wrong, nor is this much different, just to say that Bookmaker gets ppl on the level of a minus, since saying "kumagawa" can be confusing.
2) Agreed by everyone. In different ways, but everyone agrees.
3) Agreed for the most part, though not rly talked about. Still "infinite" should be added either way due to all fiction (even without counting ajimu's abilities).
4) 100% Agreed
5) Ppl agreed to have the link added even though it would be useless. So i say add (and a note on abilities being banned unless they are clear on definition like "instant movement skill")
6) As you said, while it is risky to give "all free" power creation (it's too broken). I think we keep it on the powers hanten has been shown to be able to use along with Devil style.
7) It's still in discussion on whether it should be added.
8) This is basically treated as fact by now. So it should be changed ASAP.
9) In discussion. So let's wait on this to get argued a bit more before saying anything else.
10) This is just true, no matter how much it's low balled, authority still is authority, same for divinity. The abilities can't be used but the fact that Medaka copied them means that it's not limited to "authority" or "divinity".
11) This is also true in 2 ways. 1 is she fought Zenkichi and the 2nd via Power Creation.
So did i do a good job on the recap?
- 9,738
- 1,523
I barely know the series, but i will help Ant and trying to undertand Fire requests:
1] The Bookmaker is a sealing ability that makes her opponent weaker than a minus, but since i don't know what it means, the last part should be not taken unless is better explained.
2] Abilities like All fiction that allows to manifest or use against most fictional abilities and turn all of existance into nothingness do not work on Medaka.
3] Medaka gets Infinite stats rating for copying/obtaining powers from an omnipotent being as Fire stated.
4] Same as 2.
5] Medaka should have listed all the abilities she copied from Ajimu, the omnipotent being, including Omniscience as said by Fire.
6] Medaka gets life creation, power creation and power bestowal.
7] Medaka gets the ability to create, manipulate, remove, change, etc, the supernatural energies/properties in all beings that give them their powers, including themselves, thus allowing every variation of superpowers manipulative abilities.
8] Medaka can't replicate a feat, but can replicate any skills that can cause a feat.
9] Medaka gets that she is not bound by dimensions and is in a higher stater of being.
10] Medaka gets abilities like Life and Death Manipulation, Creation and Control, Destruction, Divine Protection from evil beings and etc. since what is said in 5.
11] Medaka gets that she nullifies fate, plot, probabilities and narration from interfering with her.
While i don't have that problems for the abilities, but for the infinite stats. So, it is more safe for Unknown because its linked to a rather Omnipotent Unknown character [that her unknown rating was discussed to remain many times] that might receive her incredibly high tier since Medaka obtained stats from her.
1] The Bookmaker is a sealing ability that makes her opponent weaker than a minus, but since i don't know what it means, the last part should be not taken unless is better explained.
2] Abilities like All fiction that allows to manifest or use against most fictional abilities and turn all of existance into nothingness do not work on Medaka.
3] Medaka gets Infinite stats rating for copying/obtaining powers from an omnipotent being as Fire stated.
4] Same as 2.
5] Medaka should have listed all the abilities she copied from Ajimu, the omnipotent being, including Omniscience as said by Fire.
6] Medaka gets life creation, power creation and power bestowal.
7] Medaka gets the ability to create, manipulate, remove, change, etc, the supernatural energies/properties in all beings that give them their powers, including themselves, thus allowing every variation of superpowers manipulative abilities.
8] Medaka can't replicate a feat, but can replicate any skills that can cause a feat.
9] Medaka gets that she is not bound by dimensions and is in a higher stater of being.
10] Medaka gets abilities like Life and Death Manipulation, Creation and Control, Destruction, Divine Protection from evil beings and etc. since what is said in 5.
11] Medaka gets that she nullifies fate, plot, probabilities and narration from interfering with her.
While i don't have that problems for the abilities, but for the infinite stats. So, it is more safe for Unknown because its linked to a rather Omnipotent Unknown character [that her unknown rating was discussed to remain many times] that might receive her incredibly high tier since Medaka obtained stats from her.
- 167,683
- 76,264
@Dark649
Thank you for the help. I do not think that we can give Medaka any abilities that she has not been stated to possess, nor that the consensus is that it is acceptable to do so.
Undemonstrated infinite statistics are also a big no-no.
However, if there are abilities that she has been stated to possess that are not listed within her page, we can probably add them.
Thank you for the help. I do not think that we can give Medaka any abilities that she has not been stated to possess, nor that the consensus is that it is acceptable to do so.
Undemonstrated infinite statistics are also a big no-no.
However, if there are abilities that she has been stated to possess that are not listed within her page, we can probably add them.
- 21,783
- 4,826
The problem with this part, is the abilities listed in the wall of text.Antvasima said:
Is she stated to have them? Yes, that's why they are there.
But there's skills there like "create universe skill" in there.
- 32,358
- 20,298
I would simply not consider them acceptable.
- 21,783
- 4,826
I'm all for adding straightforward powers.
- 21,783
- 4,826
Pretty sure that would annoy the MB fans
And I KNOW WE DON'T WRITE PROFILES TO PLEASE FANS, but abilities that she is listed as having should be indexed on her page.
Just list the powers and keep her at Unknown.
And I KNOW WE DON'T WRITE PROFILES TO PLEASE FANS, but abilities that she is listed as having should be indexed on her page.
Just list the powers and keep her at Unknown.
- 21,783
- 4,826
What it says now:
Unknow (It was stated that she created a universe. However, since she comes from a metafictional parody manga, it is uncertain whether or not this should be taken seriously)
Way we could rewrite it
Unknow (Has a "Create New Universe skill", however it is unknown how large this universe would be)
Also, I just saw this. For the justification of "Unknown with Book Maker", it lists "Kumagawa sealed an exact copy of Ajimu with little difficulty while using the same ability". However, the image only shows him actually stabbing the copy with the screws, and I don't see anything saying she was actually brought down to his level.
Unknow (It was stated that she created a universe. However, since she comes from a metafictional parody manga, it is uncertain whether or not this should be taken seriously)
Way we could rewrite it
Unknow (Has a "Create New Universe skill", however it is unknown how large this universe would be)
Also, I just saw this. For the justification of "Unknown with Book Maker", it lists "Kumagawa sealed an exact copy of Ajimu with little difficulty while using the same ability". However, the image only shows him actually stabbing the copy with the screws, and I don't see anything saying she was actually brought down to his level.
- 11,531
- 8,017
I like "Unknow (Has a "Create New Universe skill", however the nature of this ability and how it'd go about creating a new universe is completely unspecified. As well this statement, if treated as its highest interpretation, being extremely inconsistent with every other feat shown by her)"
- 167,683
- 76,264
Well, I suppose that could work, but do not know which powers that we need to add.
Kumagawa defeated the Ajimu Najimi copy, so it is at least heavily implied that his screws/bookmaker worked on her.
Kumagawa defeated the Ajimu Najimi copy, so it is at least heavily implied that his screws/bookmaker worked on her.
- 21,783
- 4,826
I haven't seen the whole scene, only that image, so I'm likely missing context, but he did still stab her with a bunch of screws. Actually power nulling / sealing her wouldn't be necessary to defeat her.Antvasima said:
- 167,683
- 76,264
I think that Ryukama's suggestion is good.
Regular physical attacks should not work on Najimi, and Kumagama uses bookmaker via his screws, so it is at least heavily implied that he sealed her abilities.
Regular physical attacks should not work on Najimi, and Kumagama uses bookmaker via his screws, so it is at least heavily implied that he sealed her abilities.
- 32,358
- 20,298
I'm fine with Ryu.
- 21,783
- 4,826
Ryu's suggestion works for me.
- 32,358
- 20,298
Just link the Wall of Text in the Gallery, and in her powers an abilities section just add:
", has supposedly hundreds of other skills and abilities (See Gallery)"
", has supposedly hundreds of other skills and abilities (See Gallery)"
- 32,358
- 20,298
The problem with that is that they would be applied on versus threads. We need to make clear that they are supposed powers, not definitive things which can be applies in versus.
- 21,783
- 4,826
I mean, there's powers in there like "standing on the edge of a blade skill" and "use swords and guns at the same time skill", so it's not all going to be linked to powers and abilities. Some of it could also be added to other sections, for example "Apostrophe Shake: No miscalculations skill" could be added to her intelligence section.
- 21,783
- 4,826
I don't necessarily see this as a problem.Matthew Schroeder said:
Sure they'd be brought up. And then what would be used to counter?
"what's the most it's done"
"what's the highest resistance it's beaten"
etc.
The answer to all those questions is of course "None because it has no showings", so we just assume they are all baseline and continue with the debate.
- 21,783
- 4,826
Pity.Ryukama said:
Well I'm not that bothered either, but I guess I could go through. Even if non-combat applicable, indexing them is still a worthy goal.
I'll go through them some time in the next 24 hours, I'm a little busy currently though.
- 20,509
- 1,590
- Thread starter
- #315
Wait i could do that. The thing with ajimu's abilities (in like 7h doe after i come back from school). I don't mind. Also yeah i think that some of the abilities are pretty straight forward and don't need "showings" for limits and stuff. Example "make instant movements skill" or "make no misscalculations skill", stuff like that, that are pretty easy to get a grasp of what they do even without a showing.
Also just "infinite" on her speed stat would be good enough. There are many abilities that could achieve that. So i say do sth like this "Infinite through All Fiction and "make instant movements skill" (i will find the names for Make instant movement and the others when im back).
Also just "infinite" on her speed stat would be good enough. There are many abilities that could achieve that. So i say do sth like this "Infinite through All Fiction and "make instant movements skill" (i will find the names for Make instant movement and the others when im back).
- 32,358
- 20,298
No, no Infinite Stats based on All Fiction.
- 20,509
- 1,590
- Thread starter
- #317
Also since u want me to reexplain the topics here it is: 1. Medaka's Bookmaker has the topic of "weaker" not "on the same level as the user".
1.1. Bookmaker makes u as good as a minus in everyway.
2. Medaka can turn off Scar Dead and Encounter.
3.Medaka's speed stat should be infinite with full powers.
4. Medaka can turn off Unknown Hero.
5. We should add link to Ajimu's skills on Medaka's profile.
6. Medaka copied Hanten's power creation, which is missing from her profile.
7. Medaka has possibly copied power manipulation from Shiranui.
8. The end can copy any skill, not raw power. (change on her profile)
9. The End can copy stuff independed of Medaka's state of existence.
10. The End can copy divinity and authority.
11. Medaka is missing Devil Style from her profile.
1.1. Bookmaker makes u as good as a minus in everyway.
2. Medaka can turn off Scar Dead and Encounter.
3.Medaka's speed stat should be infinite with full powers.
4. Medaka can turn off Unknown Hero.
5. We should add link to Ajimu's skills on Medaka's profile.
6. Medaka copied Hanten's power creation, which is missing from her profile.
7. Medaka has possibly copied power manipulation from Shiranui.
8. The end can copy any skill, not raw power. (change on her profile)
9. The End can copy stuff independed of Medaka's state of existence.
10. The End can copy divinity and authority.
11. Medaka is missing Devil Style from her profile.
- 20,509
- 1,590
- Thread starter
- #318
Ok then just "make instant movements skill".Matthew Schroeder said:
- 32,358
- 20,298
Except that's among the skills that genuinely cannot be applied.
- Status
