Knight vs Hero: Xue Ying vs Supergirl (CW)

[Planck69]

While attempting to escape the Sea Deity Palace, a mishap casts Xue Ying into a minor world far away from the Grand Xia, Earth. When he decides that he would interrogate the surrounding mortals to get better sense of where he is, he is stopped, not just by the language barrier, but by the arrival of National City's resident hero, Supergirl. Realizing the misunderstanding, he shrugs and resolves to settle it after defeating the strange "Legend Knight".

A random Asian-resembling metahuman (alien?) was far from the strangest thing she'd faced, but Kara was curious about the odd way he held himself, a calm confidence she wasn't used to. Regardless, he was bothering her city's denizens and would need to be brought in if nothing else. Hopefully this won't cause too much collateral damage....

Mortal Xue Ying is used. Speed is equalized. Otherwise SBA.

Spear Demon:

Girl of Steel:

Inconclusive:

 

[ByArrow]

Supergirl's profile is outdated. And her and the whole arrowverse is undergoing an overhaul. So this match should not take place.

 

[Planck69]

BUMP

Supergirl's profile is outdated. And her and the whole arrowverse is undergoing an overhaul. So this match should not take place.

I'm aware, but I figured that it could just be discussed and if the coming changes alter tiers or outcomes too much, be removed.

 

[Zaratthustra]

Her only advantage I think its her higher lifting strength, otherwise I don't see a win for her.

 

[Planck69]

Her only advantage I think its her higher lifting strength, otherwise I don't see a win for her.

Her frost breath is Absolute Zero, which Xue Ying doesn't resist yet as well.

 

[Zaratthustra]

Oh, didn't know that. Guess she got two powers over him then but Xue still got a broader arsenal and likely better martial arts.

 

[Planck69]

Supergirl's pros (as I understand them);

• Better lifting strength, so she could pin him down and hold him in place if she ever gets a hold of him.
• Absolute Zero frost breath, which Xue Ying doesn't resist at all.
• Can deprive him of oxygen, though Xue Ying's control of air can mitigate this.
• Has a lot more experience in flying battles than Xue Ying at this point.

Xue Ying's pros;
Significantly higher raw power and durability (around 3 times)

• Better martial skill and reach with his spear.
• Greater versatility with his elemental attacks.
• Can multiply his power by 2, which would spell huge trouble for Supergirl, but this also lasts a relatively short while and leaves him temporarily vulnerable afterwards.

The fight leans a lot on Xue Ying with this but the AZ breath could catch him off guard. Pinning him also works but she'd have to get in close.

 

[Planck69]

bump

 

[Rikimarox2]

Yeah uh, reading both profiles, Supergirl's only wincon is AZ.

Meanwhile:

1. Xue Ying can fodderize her with skill considering his skill shit is far above her.

2. Has law stuff.

3. Has afterimage technique which can confuse her.

4. Precog to sense danger aka he'll know if she uses AZ.

5. Fear manip that brings instinctual terror, and I don't see any resistance on Supergirl's profile.

6. Her breath attack seems so not impressive and easily avoidable. Not to mention it seems the range isn't even that high, just a few meters. (Could be wrong, only saw a feat or two of her doing it)

Honestly, I'm seeing Xue Ying go amp his attack, just destroy her in the fight and evade or use technique of afterimage, or just damage her throat.

Also, him not having experience doesn't seem to be that big of a deal for a guy who has Accelerated Development. And even if not, with his range of three hundred meters, he can destroy her from afar since she doesn't have good range, and even if not that, her range is horrible and she had to fight up close where he can beat her.

Voting Xue Ying low-mid diff.

 

[Planck69]

The law-stuff isn't directly offensive in this key. Just a mechanism for his elemental attacks. And the amplification is usually when he's at a disadvantage. Otherwise counted.

This is a wee bit more one sided than I thought, now that I've had a night to sleep on it....

 

[Rikimarox2]

Kind of why I didn't add explanation on it, just mentioned it since I thought it was Dao stuff.

Even then, Amp or not, and no law stuff, he still handily wins without much of a problem due to his skill and techniques, and the fact that he's a genius at combat so I think he can comfortably handle the whole AZ stuff.

It isn't a stomp tho. There are scenario where she might actually catch him with AZ and her lifting strength, it's just less likely than him winning.

 

[Hixkaryana]

With Kara's current profile she would probably lose, but with all the updates she'd one tap.